6 ms·
The "benefits" of lithium come at a cost, which this article doesn't really address. Lithium evens out your emotions, good and bad, some describe it as "turning
by hammock 12y ago
The "benefits" of lithium come at a cost, which this article doesn't really address. Lithium evens out your emotions, good and bad, some describe it as "turning into a soulless robot." That could mean a more docile society (the legal, behavioral, etc benefits described) but sounds pretty close to THX 1138 to me.
- dozenal 12y agoThey are talking about amounts that are a tiny fraction of the therapeutic dosages of lithium for mood disorders.
- jamesisaac 12y agoBut if the only reason decreased suicide rates are observed is that the members of society become slightly more docile (obviously to a much lesser degree than those on prescription doses), it makes it a lot more questionable whether this is a valid way to tackle the suicide problem. It would be one thing if micro-doses of lithium were sold as a supplement, which individuals can opt to take. But the article goes as far as to suggest adding it to drinking water -- it seems very irresponsible in my eyes to leave it to the government to decide "how docile" the population should be above the natural level / what trade-off with suicide rate is acceptable. There are better ways to deal with the problem of suicide than pushing society slightly closer to the "souless robot" end of the spectrum.
- derefr 12y agoBiology isn't made of perfect sliding scales between two extreme problems, where in the middle you have 50% of both problems. Instead, in the middle, you usually have neither problem. For example, the amount of moisture in your skin: too little and it cracks and bleeds, too much and you get fungal infections. But adding moisture to cracked-and-bleeding skin isn't making it "a bit more fungal" -- it's pushing it into the healthy buffer range.
- jamesisaac 12y agoAnd what suggests that we aren't "in the middle" already? With your hand moisture analogy - for the majority of the population, natural levels of moisture are perfectly fine, and no intervention is required. Perhaps natural levels of lithium are optimal too. I'd imagine there are many, more complex, factors involved in brain chemistry / mood suppression, so it would be a lot more difficult to determine where this middle lies. If you're using high suicide rates to suggest we're not in the middle and need more lithium in everyone's water, I'd have to disagree. In the vast majority of cases, a better healthcare system which ensures those who need it are connected with mental health professionals would help nip the problem in the bud. Rather than solving it with these lithium microdoses, causing to those on the verge of suicide to not have the lucidity of emotion to commit to the act, and the rest of the population having their brain chemistry played with too.
- derefr 12y agoUsually "the middle" makes up the vast majority of the scale. Here's a useful comparison: Before we were iodizing salt, most people were actually in "the middle" of iodine-consumption. Anywhere from "nearly none" to "tons and tons" was "the middle"--your body can work miracles to create homeostasis from random inputs. But some people were getting no iodine at all, and these people would get very sick. So we added just a little bit of iodine to salt. The iodine-deficient people--the people who were previously getting utterly no iodine--stopped getting sick, because now they were getting a little bit of iodine, and that was enough. Everyone else was getting slightly more iodine--but this didn't push anyone from "getting a tolerable amount of iodine with the excess just excreted" to "having a hyperiodine problem." There was nobody exactly one dose away from having too much iodine, because we just don't consume that much iodine. This same story holds for any vitamin or mineral. Calcium, phosphorous, iron, etc. are all things most people get the right amount of--but "the right amount" is almost any amount, because the body knows how to take just the right amount from the stream of input it's getting, and throw the rest out. The only wrong amounts are either zero, or more than exists in any human-friendly environment.
- 12y ago
- otakucode 12y agoYeah, I am also bothered by the fact that the options only seem to be 'it remains a controlled substance which people have to show a significant need for in order to acquire' and 'put it in the drinking water'. I realize it is very popular in modern society to think that if something has benefits that it should be forced on everyone, and if benefits can't be shown then the government should step in and forbid anyone from doing it, but I can't get comfortable with that. I would think what should be aimed for is easy availability of low-dose lithium supplements paired with education. Give people a choice. This isn't like vaccines where we have a legitimate reason to exert control over people (herd immunity, the safety of those too young or immunocompromised to be vaccinated, etc).
- andreasvc 12y agoWhere do you get this idea of lithium making people "docile"? It does not; you may be confusing it with antipsychotic medication. In any case as the comment you are responding to states, these are very low doses, such effects could not occur. Your emotional language of "soulless robots" is really just an uninformed, knee jerk reaction. I can see why the drinking water suggestion invites paranoia. As the article mentions a solution like adding it to salt could also work.
- milkshakes 12y agohave you taken lithium? i have, for years, and i currently take "antipsychotic medication", which is actually a yet another term that, thanks to marketing, has lost all meaning. the comments about lithium making you "docile", and "soulless robots" are spot on. and there are "antipsychotics" that act as mood stabilizers that are a lot less soul-sucking than lithium is. respectfully, it is you who are misinformed.
- andreasvc 12y agoYou are projecting your experience with therapeutic doses on the current discussion about doses that would be orders of magnitude lower, similar to naturally occurring levels in some water supplies. Even at therapeutic doses I think you are generalizing too much, as many people do not experience such side effects.
- milkshakes 12y ago> Where do you get this idea of lithium making people "docile"? It does not; you may be confusing it with antipsychotic medication. that is the statement i was responding to. > Even at therapeutic doses I think you are generalizing too much, as many people do not experience such side effects. that's cool and all, but that's just, like, your opinion, man. if you're going to accuse me of generalizing, you could at least do so with something other than a sweeping, unqualified generalization. i find it amusing that this thread is full of people who don't actually take this medication telling people who actually have what its effects are. in fact, lithium has been documented both anecdotally and in research[2] to have measurable effects on cognition, and a dulling effect on mood. [2]: http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=lithium+cognitive+effects http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=lithium+cognitive+effect...
- userbinator 12y agoI'm not so sure a "more docile society" is a good thing - given that one of the definitions is "easily led or managed", which brings to mind dystopian government controls...
- underwater 12y agoTHX 1138 is a reference to the George Lucas film about a dystopian future society.
- morganvachon 12y agoAt prescription amounts, yes it pretty much turns the patient into a robot. My stepfather is bipolar, and his doctor had to stop prescribing him lithium because it stripped away his normally upbeat (when not in a depressive state) personality, to the point that he was difficult to interact with. Again though, that's at prescription levels. Trace levels in drinking water probably won't make us all into soulless robots ripe for totalitarian rule. edit: missing words
- fifthesteight 12y agoI am bipolar. What you describe is why it's a "hard sell" to patients with mood disorders. Yes, others will point to the higher dose for psychiatric patients. I would point to the soulless robot, the empty husk of a once vibrant, creative brain. We are devs, and our brain is our livelihood. In me it killed my creativity and my passion. Not only did I not want to code anything new, I could not conceive of new things. I stopped improv jams on guitar, I could not write songs. I became wonderfully adept at doing scales. Scales over and over. I'll take my mood disorder- because it comes WITH emotions. This is just to give you a 'crazy person's' impression of Lithium. Your results may vary.
- untilHellbanned 12y agoWere you ever given an option to take a smaller dose? Something to limit the really bad swings? Is this something you'd be able to test?
- fifthesteight 12y agoAbsolutely. I have taken the same list of meds as the post above yours, and thankfully as he did I have found the right medicine for me. I perceive the tone of the post above yours to be condescending, as if my experience is trumped by his life experience (which, I assure you, isn't unique to his bipolar). I described my experience with lithium, and while there were sedatives and antipsychotics that I was prescribed which had a far greater numbing effects, I was not speaking to them. All of the medications I tried had different consequences, Lithium's were not the worst (Lamictals were the most interesting musically).
- abrak 12y agoI currently take lamictal for BP 1 - can you elaborate what you mean by lamictal being 'most interesting, musically'? I've found it to be without any discernible side effects, at least compared to depakote/valproate and lithium.
- nutate 12y agoI'm terribly condescending online. I'm glad that you have found a good mix for you and sorry I was an asshole there. I just didn't want people to get the picture that psych med X destroys everyone it touches. They all hit people differently. Possibly because the exact causes of these diseases aren't tacked down. Be well. I can only hope our life experiences both rock regardless of whatever bumps in the road we hit. I didn't put the low-lights of my life on meds into my post, but they are legion. Leeeeeeegion.
- nutate 12y agoI have been taking bipolar meds for a dozen years. Compared to atypical antipsychotics, benzos or other mood stabilizers, lithium is a walk in the park. I think the x hours of TV or internet 'use' a day makes a more docile society than a little lithium would. The article omits 7up (which contained lithium for a while) and lithia water which you can buy online right now: http://lithiamineralwater.com/store.htm http://lithiamineralwater.com/store.htm
- gwern 12y agoPsychiatric doses, perhaps, but I don't think trace doses have any meaningful effect. The doses are an order of magnitude or two smaller, and my personal experience doesn't agree: when I ran a blind self-experiment for around a year using lithium orotate doses higher than the trace water proposals, I noticed nothing subjectively and none of my recorded data changed (http://www.gwern.net/Nootropics#lithium-experiment http://www.gwern.net/Nootropics#lithium-experiment), so I'm fairly skeptical of the claim.
- phkahler 12y ago>> some describe it as "turning into a soulless robot. But doesn't pot bring apathy? People are actually starting to legalize that...
- Houshalter 12y agoThe dose makes the poison.
- KrisAndrew 12y agoLithium is not like you describe. I've taken half a dozen SSRI's, which at times made me feel totally empty and without motivation. I've taken one antipsychotic (risperidone) and it made me feel like an utterly stupid zombie, so much so that I stopped taking it against my doctor's orders. I was put on lithium and I found that I'm completely capable of feeling a full range of emotions, but what I don't experience is the accelerated spiraling of emotions that can send me into depression or mania. Compared to more recent psychotropic medications, lithium is pretty mild in terms of unwanted side effects; the only drawback is that if you're on a high dose, you have to stay hydrated to avoid lithium toxicity. That's a pretty small price to pay to stay level.
- dragonwriter 12y agoQuite a lot of psychiatric drugs affect different people in different ways; I would be very unsurprised if the people the grandparent post recounts describing it as "turning into a soulless robot" are fairly describing their own experience, while the parent post fairly describes that poster's experience. One probably should avoid hastily generalizing one's own experience to what the drug's effects are like generally.
- KrisAndrew 12y agoWe'll agree to disagree then. I've heard several complaints about lithium but none of them was "it turns me into a soulless robot." The way lithium works is by stabilizing mood, not by inducing a different mood like other medications (i.e. antidepressants). So I'm going to be facetious and say the people making those claims were soulless robots before taking lithium.