10 ms·
Should We All Take a Bit of Lithium?
- lilymuki 12y agohttps://www.facebook.com/pages/Miami-Dolphins-vs-Buffalo-Bills-live-stream-watch-here-NFL-online-and-enjoy/451733201632922 https://www.facebook.com/pages/Miami-Dolphins-vs-Buffalo-Bil...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- steveplace 12y agoNo.
- sethbannon 12y ago"But there are undoubtedly other reasons for its neglect. Pharmaceutical companies have nothing to gain from this cheap, ubiquitous element." It's a tragic condemnation of the way we do health and nutrition that if no one profits from marketing and selling something, the masses typically won't hear about the benefits of it.
- andylei 12y agothis just doesn't make sense. people sell bottled water! why can't they sell lithium?
- cbd1984 12y agoBecause conspiracies drive page views. If a website can pin something on Big Pharma, well, it must be true, because a huge increase in click-through revenue doesn't lie.
- lutusp 12y agoBecause bottled water doesn't have real or imagined therapeutic properties, and lithium does. Eventually someone unfamiliar with the rules will advertise a lithium/water product as having medical effects, and that will end the game (advertising medical benefits is a no-no without both research backing and FDA approval). EDIT: this is another example of the "fact rule" -- if you post something factual and uncontroversial, you will be downvoted with a probability of 1.
- andreasvc 12y agoI disagree. There is a market for supplements, as long as they walk a careful line of avoiding the promise of any medical benefit. Lithium could be sold this way, in low dosages ("Lithia Springs water"), but it's probably not allowed? I remember that 7-up once contained lithium, but it was banned, even though the amount was very small. BTW: There is indeed an annoying level of unnecessary downvoting going on.
- gwern 12y agoLithium is already sold as a supplement. If you want to run out and buy eg lithium orotate, you certainly can. It's cheap too.
- ozy23378 12y agoAnd bulk analytical-grade lithium carbonate, sulphate and citrate not marketed for human consumption are equally easy to acquire and even cheaper.
- Symmetry 12y agoIt's not quite as bad as that. You can always take a common element, create a particular formulation you get past the FDA and market and sell that. http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/06/15/fish-now-by-prescription/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/06/15/fish-now-by-prescriptio...
- jvagner 12y agoIt is as bad as that. Distribution, marketing, awareness, etc., are the mechanics AFTER research.
- cbd1984 12y agoPeople use the same argument about a lot of things, but we still eradicated smallpox despite how profitable smallpox treatments must have been. Really, it's a horrible argument. It presupposes that everyone working for Big Pharma is a sociopath who only cares about the next quarterly report.
- qq66 12y agoActually, nowhere near "everyone working for Big Pharma" needs to be a sociopath for the industry to act sociopathically. In fact, it can happen with as few as one or even zero sociopaths, since the organization has properties of its own independent of the constituent humans. My favorite exploration of this idea is the TV show "The Wire."
- cbd1984 12y agoIt presupposes that there are no defectors, in a game-theoretic sense: Every company that could develop a cure or cheap therapy doesn't, even though that would be a very lucrative product: A cheap lithium pill would sell in huge volume and be profitable even with a minimal markup.
- lutusp 12y ago> A cheap lithium pill would sell in huge volume and be profitable even with a minimal markup. The problem should be obvious -- lithium is an element that cannot be protected by trademark, patent or copyright. Anyone marketing it is sure to be undercut as soon as the product begins to win public acceptance and show a profit. The other issue is toxicity. Without professional advice, people might think that, because a small amount confers benefit, therefore more is better. But, not unlike vitamin A, lithium becomes toxic above relatively low levels. For that reason it's not likely to be sold over the counter.
- ConceptJunkie 12y agoBy your logic no one could make money selling Vitamin C. Also, the article talked about the benefits of consuming lithium at a tiny fraction of the therapeutic level. There are plenty of legal, common supplements that are similarly toxic if consumed in those amounts.
- refurb 12y agoThat makes no sense. Lithium carbonate is a prescription drug and companies are making money off it.
- wiredfool 12y agoIt's not patented, and it's cheap. (I think it's less than my insurance copay for a month's supply) Yes, they're making money off of it, but it's nowhere near levels where it's worth doing any marketing for it.
- efm 12y agoThe original post has bad math. 1000x .170mg is "1,000 times less than a fifth of a milligram," not 1000 times a fifth of a gram. http://www.gwern.net/Nootropics#lithium http://www.gwern.net/Nootropics#lithium has a significant number of references to the literature on lithium, and is worth reading.
- meowface 12y agoGwern's writeups on nootropics are some of the best you'll find on the Internet. Honestly, his writeups on most things are pretty spot on.
- jonnathanson 12y agoGwern's writings on nootropics are particularly fascinating. They read like the works of a mad scientist (in a good way). Erudite, meticulous, and also a tiny bit reckless. Gwern treats himself like a human guinea pig, then documents and analyzes the results more carefully than I've seen in some research papers. The whole process, furthermore, reads like a dialogue between Gwern and the reader. To be more precise, it reads like a dialogue between Gwern and Gwern's imagined idea of a highly intelligent reader -- a reader whose place you find yourself wanting to fill. Gwern's archive is eccentric, to say the least. But it's one of the best places on the web to lose oneself for an afternoon.
- meowface 12y agoCouldn't have said it better myself.
- emmelaich 12y agoGood catch, though you should avoid 'x times less/more than ..' Better is 'one thousandth of a fifth of a milligram'
- hammock 12y agoThe "benefits" of lithium come at a cost, which this article doesn't really address. Lithium evens out your emotions, good and bad, some describe it as "turning into a soulless robot." That could mean a more docile society (the legal, behavioral, etc benefits described) but sounds pretty close to THX 1138 to me.
- dozenal 12y agoThey are talking about amounts that are a tiny fraction of the therapeutic dosages of lithium for mood disorders.
- jamesisaac 12y agoBut if the only reason decreased suicide rates are observed is that the members of society become slightly more docile (obviously to a much lesser degree than those on prescription doses), it makes it a lot more questionable whether this is a valid way to tackle the suicide problem. It would be one thing if micro-doses of lithium were sold as a supplement, which individuals can opt to take. But the article goes as far as to suggest adding it to drinking water -- it seems very irresponsible in my eyes to leave it to the government to decide "how docile" the population should be above the natural level / what trade-off with suicide rate is acceptable. There are better ways to deal with the problem of suicide than pushing society slightly closer to the "souless robot" end of the spectrum.
- derefr 12y agoBiology isn't made of perfect sliding scales between two extreme problems, where in the middle you have 50% of both problems. Instead, in the middle, you usually have neither problem. For example, the amount of moisture in your skin: too little and it cracks and bleeds, too much and you get fungal infections. But adding moisture to cracked-and-bleeding skin isn't making it "a bit more fungal" -- it's pushing it into the healthy buffer range.
- jamesisaac 12y ago
- jessaustin 12y agoUsing the word "millenniums" twice in an article the topic of which is not idiosyncratic diction is obnoxious.
- desdiv 12y agoBoth Merriam-Webster and Oxford says it's acceptable: http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/millenniums http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/millenniums http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/millennium http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/millenn...
- rectangletangle 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_(medication)#Side_effects http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_(medication)#Side_effec... The dosages required to achieve "beneficial" psychoactive effects will probably result in adverse side effects in a significant portion of the population. Lithium should be prescribed by a doctor on a case by case basis, not indiscriminately dumped into the water supply.
- learc83 12y agoThe article was talking about trace amounts, very far below the therapeutic dosages that cause those side effects. Trace amounts of lithium already occur naturally in many municipal water supplies.
- rectangletangle 12y agoThe dose makes the poison, the higher PPM of lithium, the larger the percentage of individuals that will be affected. Even if it affects a tiny fraction of the population at the proposed concentrations, it's still unfair to that demographic. Would you wan't to have to buy special non-lithium supplemented water?
- RichardFord 12y agoYeah, she was way too gung-ho about potentially forcing this stuff on people via the water supply. But I'm not surprised that an academic would want to social-engineer this way.
- learc83 12y agoI live about 3 miles away from Lithia Springs, but I can't seem to find any information online about how much lithium is actually in our drinking water. I know our water and sewer authority publishes a report on water quality each year, but I don't remember seeing lithium content in the report.
- morganvachon 12y agoI'm just inside Paulding County with a Powder Springs address, and that's who I pay my water bill to, but the yearly water quality reports I get come from Cobb County. It makes me wonder if Lithia Springs even gets their municipal supply from the spring, or from a Douglas County source.
- learc83 12y ago> It makes me wonder if Lithia Springs even gets their municipal supply from the spring, or from a Douglas County source. The spring is privately owned. Here it is on google street view [1]. Lithia Springs gets their tap water from from the Dog River Reservoir in the southern part of Douglas County. [1] https://www.google.com/maps/@33.8005688,-84.6403093,3a,75y,119.32h,87.77t/data=!3m4!1e1!3m2!1sbaehH8WENLgRKMsGz_NFzA!2e0 https://www.google.com/maps/@33.8005688,-84.6403093,3a,75y,1...
- morganvachon 12y agoThanks, I've never actually been to the spring itself, though we drove by there just today playing Ingress. I grew up in Cedartown, where the natural spring is also the town's water supply, so I just assumed it would be the same for Lithia Springs.
- ryandvm 12y agoPeople play Ingress?!
- possibilistic 12y agoNot to detract from the flow of the conversation, but do any of us Atlanta-area hackers have any formal events or get-togethers? I'd love to meet some of you and hack on stuff.
- morganvachon 12y agoI live just a couple of miles from Lithia Springs, Georgia, and oddly enough I've never seen "Lithia Water" on sale anywhere around here. I suppose it gets bottled and sold to retailers in other states. As for lithium-infused water chilling people out; well, I've lived here long enough to know that I wouldn't walk the streets of Lithia Springs at night. There are some rowdy people living there. Maybe they all drink Dasani or Aquafina instead of the local tap water.
- tokenadult 12y agoThe article points out 1) therapeutic doses of lithium as a prescription medicine for mood disorders are MUCH higher than doses occurring through lithium in the water supply, and yet 2) there is perhaps some epidemiological signal suggesting differing rates of suicide and depression in places where lithium levels in the water supply are higher. Kay Redfield Jamison, author of some of the most compassionate books about depression you will ever read,[1] credits lithium with saving her life. I'm glad her life was spared so that she could write from the inside about what it is like to have a severe mood disorder, and apply her creativity to communicating with people who cannot directly understanding her personal experiences or the experiences of other patients. I think the article's call for further research, at a minimum, is worth taking seriously. The neuroprotective effect of lithium demonstrated in animal studies (verified by necropsy and examination of the animal's brains after the animals die) is well established, so we may as well check whether adjustment of water supplies by intentional supplementation has a beneficial effect if (and only if) epidemiological studies and animal experiments suggest doing so. This is, after all, how the beneficial effects of fluoride on tooth enamel strength and resistance to decay were discovered. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Kay-Redfield-Jamison/e/B000AQ1IC8 http://www.amazon.com/Kay-Redfield-Jamison/e/B000AQ1IC8
- Xcelerate 12y ago> The authors discovered that people whose water had the least amount of lithium had significantly greater levels of suicide, homicide and rape than the people whose water had the higher levels of lithium. The group whose water had the highest lithium level had nearly 40 percent fewer suicides than that with the lowest lithium level. I can't but help wonder whether higher levels of lithium also correlate with a clean water supply, which would indicate a more affluent community. It may simply be the case that those areas with cleaner water have a better economy, and thus less crime, etc. Although lithium undoubtedly has antidepressant effects. It's funny this article popped up on here. Today I was actually reading about how chromium picolinate was found to have a positive effect on those with atypical depression. It can be purchased from any vitamin store. It makes me wonder if trace elements (lithium, chromium, etc.) are vital to the brain's proper functioning via some as yet undiscovered mechanism. Also, why is it that you have to have a prescription to get certain compounds, but other ones you can just purchase yourself? Is it simply the potential for toxicity?
- fnordfnordfnord 12y ago> Is it simply the potential for toxicity? Probably not. Acetaminophen is otc, yet rather toxic. I've always thought it was the potential to have unearned fun.
- lutusp 12y ago> I can't but help wonder whether higher levels of lithium also correlate with a clean water supply, which would indicate a more affluent community. Not likely, because the water supply of an affluent community would have highly filtered water containing few "impurities" including lithium. Further, if the community in question were conservative in their political views, the water might even lack fluoride, another component with known beneficial traits but one that has become a political issue in some places. > Also, why is it that you have to have a prescription to get certain compounds, but other ones you can just purchase yourself? Is it simply the potential for toxicity? No, it revolves around the issue of medical applications. If a substance has known medical applications, then its dissemination will likely be controlled by the FDA. Even advertising a substance's possible medical benefits is not permitted in the general case, without FDA approval and substantial controls. For example, if I sell willow bark as writing paper, no problem. If I sell it as a pain-killer without possessing medical authority, I will be in a heap of trouble.
- jrapdx3 12y agoGood timing. It happens I'm going to Ashland, OR next week. The town is famous for the Shakespeare Festival (world-class performances) and Lithia Park. The latter is a natural lithium containing mineral water source. It's easy to sample, just a short stroll from the Elizabethan theater, a drinking fountain bubbles up the spring water. ATM I'm not sure of the exact concentration of the minerals, but from prior years, saying it tastes really bad isn't nearly a strong enough description. Other water supplies containing Li may be quite acceptable, but except for Ashland palatability isn't the main issue. In the article, the cited concentration of Li at 0.170 mg/L, if referring to Li+ ion alone, the water supply would actually contain ~1/100 of the lowest therapeutic dose of Li. Medicinally Li is provided as the carbonate salt. A minimal dose is 300 mg/day, which contains ~ 30 mg elemental Li. Consuming Li-fortified water 2 L/d -> 0.34 mg Li or >1/100 of low medicinal Li dose . Of course in nature Li is always in ionic or combined form, but the article didn't give details about Li concentrations, so it muddies the water trying to parse Li effects in any number of ways. Here in Portland OR, city water is sourced high up near Mt. Hood from condensation of atmospheric water (mist or rain) and piped the short distance to the city. It's basically like distilled water, very low in mineral content. So low in fact, the federal government insists that alkaline minerals are added to the supply since distilled water is acidic and leaches lead from old plumbing. However, Portland has among the lowest suicide attempt rates in the US. Our neighbor to the north, Seattle WA is among the highest, along with Salt Lake City UT and Dallas TX. http://socialcapitalreview.org/seattle-region-ranks-2nd-of-33-in-u-s-suicide-attempts/ http://socialcapitalreview.org/seattle-region-ranks-2nd-of-3... Other data would show something different re: suicidal behavior but contradictory data sets are kind of the point. Li could be a factor but I'm skeptical. We must remain alert to the hazards of drawing conclusions from population-based observational data. In this domain, experimental studies are difficult to design and conduct, but further study to narrow down confounding factors would be useful. What I do know is water purity is sacred here. The last fluoridation campaign failed by about a 3:1 lopsided vote. What chance would there be of adding lithium to our water supply? I think it would not be voted in.
- klodolph 12y ago> distilled water is acidic Distilled water is neutral, it is the reference point against which acidic and alkaline solutions are compared. Technically one could argue that it is acidic, because any concentration of [H+] is acidic, but this is like arguing that Jiminy Cricket is tall because he has height. However, rainwater will naturally absorb CO2 in the air (and since the industrial revolution, NO2 and SO3), making it acidic.
- jeffdavis 12y agoMostly a reasonable and interesting article. But when you talk about adding something psychoactive to the drinking water, it's just a horrible idea. It doesn't matter if it's otherwise natural. Nature is inconsistent in dosages (so diverse perspectives can flourish) and doesn't have ulterior motives. Maybe it brings down suicide rates, but what other effects does it have? Does it affect the likelihood of voting for a political party or cause? Does it affect the likelihood of political participation in general? It's kind of like CO2 levels in the atmosphere. Higher levels will have some effect; we're basically arguing over the significance of it, what to do about it (if anything), and whether politicians can be trusted with the power to make those changes. Similarly, mind-altering substances will affect aggregate political behavior. Once someone finds out how, they will use it to their advantage.
- andreasvc 12y agoI'm not sure whether you can call it psychoactive. I think psychoactive substances have an immediate, noticeable effect. Especially at the doses suggested, lithium does not. What do you call psychoactive? Tomato sauce can make me happy, but it's not sensible to call it psychoactive. On the contrary, it is widely reported that lead plumbing causes higher crime levels, lower IQs, and all sorts of bad things. Should we then resign and say we should not mess with the "psychoactive properties" of our drinking water? No, most things in our society are already artificial and engineered to achieve certain ends. I don't see the point in being paranoid about affecting political behavior, first it's something which should first be established, second, people couldn't possibly get more apathetic than they already are.
- DanBC 12y ago> But when you talk about adding something psychoactive to the drinking water, it's just a horrible idea. Should we remove trace amounts of lithium from water in areas where it's naturally occurring?
- gwern 12y agoExactly. If it's a bad idea to add any lithium to water (anywhere up to the FDA-approved safe levels), doesn't that imply it would be a good idea to control randomly-varying* lithium levels to even lower levels? See also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reversal_test http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reversal_test * lithium levels in drinking water change constantly, in part due to variations in rainfall in a region
- afro88 12y agoIf there is a concrete correlation between trace amounts of Lithium in the water supply and lower suicide rates, surely there are other effects? The studies done seem quite one sided to me (or more likely, this article is). For serious consideration, not only do more studies have to be undertaken for other cities, but other factors have to be measured as well. Other psychological problems, rate of divorce, physical activity (sport etc), unemployment, debt, other drug use, education etc. Perhaps there's a lower incidence of suicide because people are much less active? Unemployed, no ambition, but not enough drive to end it all as well?
- lutusp 12y agoThe answer is that, as one moves into more behaviors and more detail, the chance to meaningfully correlate outcomes with lithium exposure becomes more difficult. Also, because no one knows why those correlations exist (why lithium has the effect it does), it's not possible to turn a correlation into a rigorous, scientific cause-effect relationship. The gold standard in science is not a correlation, but a cause-effect relationship accompanied by an explanation. With respect to lithium, we're a long way from that goal.
- vesche 12y agoAn interesting analysis from a self study if you haven't read it already: http://www.gwern.net/Nootropics#lithium http://www.gwern.net/Nootropics#lithium
- lutusp 12y agoQuote: "But there are undoubtedly other reasons for its neglect. Pharmaceutical companies have nothing to gain from this cheap, ubiquitous element." Ah, of course. This is why lithium is ignored or actively disparaged, while drugs whose ineffectiveness has been demonstrated in a now-famous meta-analysis -- http://www.plosmedicine.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pmed.0050045 http://www.plosmedicine.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fj... "Meta-analyses of antidepressant medications have reported only modest benefits over placebo treatment, and when unpublished trial data are included, the benefit falls below accepted criteria for clinical significance." [emphasis added] -- continue to be aggressively marketed. This is not to say that lithium is a panacea or not dangerous if mishandled. It is to say that it has measurable beneficial effects in the right doses, on the right people. No one knows why this is true, but that's true of all such medications.
- scrame 12y agoAbsolutely fucking not.
- ksec 12y agoLithium is naturally occurring? Wiki seems to suggest otherwise.
- gus_massa 12y agoIn some place, running water has more lithium. For example, there was a recent study that correlates the suicide rates with the content of lithium in water in some cities of Japan: http://bjp.rcpsych.org/content/194/5/464.full http://bjp.rcpsych.org/content/194/5/464.full
- DanBC 12y agoModern chemical analysis is exquisitely sensitive. People take medication and excrete some of it. Sensible water use, especially in drought areas, means that water is reused - the water you drink has gone through someone else before you. BBC Radio Four has a programme about this: "Urine Trouble: what's in our water?" http://bbc.co.uk/news/health-29108330 http://bbc.co.uk/news/health-29108330 Other uses for very-sensitive analysis of waste water include real time drug sampling. We can tell that it's the weekend by the amounts of MDMA and cocaine (metabolites?) in the water; where heroin doesn't show weekend spikes. This can be used at festivals to see if "legal highs" are actually used and in what kind of quantities. The programme is better than this page makes it out to be.
- falconfunction 12y agoSounds like the pseudo science that kick starts 'end of the whole mess' by Stephen king.
- xtrm0 12y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pkcJEvMcnEg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pkcJEvMcnEg