11 ms·
We Are Entering the Age of Alzheimer's
- chaosfactor 12y agoSomeone PLEASE make a startup that somehow enables people to stop suppressing thoughts of death related to heart disease, cancer, alzheimers,etc., and instead helps up mobilize a response. 3000 people die every 30 minutes. And yet we spent trillions on 9/11. A complete waste of money. We could do so much better.
- jp555 12y agoYou are the younger version of your parents; this is how we have beat death for billions of years (you are just a branch of a much bigger genetic program). It's really easy to activate this feature, I bet you won't even need the documentation. It does require two-factor authentication although... but there are lots of startups (ie. okcupid) working to solve that problem for you. :P
- normloman 12y agoWhy do you think a startup is the best solution? Remember, startups have to make money. Good luck monetizing awareness.
- DanBC 12y agoEveryone knows that obesity is a bad thing, and that it can be avoided by not eating too many calories. Why are there so many obese people? Since everything else we've tried to get overweight people to stop eating so much has failed it might be worth looking at different approaches.
- coldtea 12y ago>Everyone knows that obesity is a bad thing, and that it can be avoided by not eating too many calories. Why are there so many obese people? Because unhealthy food is delicious, cheap AND addictive. >Since everything else we've tried to get overweight people to stop eating so much has failed it might be worth looking at different approaches. Well, a ban on refined starches and corn sugar work quite well. People were much healthier (from an obesity perspective) when such products were not available.
- DanBC 12y ago> Well, a ban on refined starches and corn sugar work quite well. People were much healthier (from an obesity perspective) when such products were not available. Do Scotland, New Zealand, Hungary use "corn sugar"? We don't use it much in England and we (along with those other countries) also have problems with obesity. I'll happily accept that calories from sugar are a problem.
- coldtea 12y ago>Do Scotland, New Zealand, Hungary use "corn sugar"? We don't use it much in England and we (along with those other countries) also have problems with obesity. How much of a problem, though, compared to say, the US? I've travelled quite a bit in Europe, Asia, etc, and I've seen nothing compared to the US level of obesity. Heck, the kind of people you'll see in a Walmart (and not isolated -- tons of them, and all over the states)... I guess it's also other stuff: deep fried anything, Sneaker and Mars bars, chips (crisps), BS "sports" drinks, sodas, etc etc.
- SupremumLimit 12y agoNew Zealand is 3rd in the OECD in terms of obesity, not far behind the US and Mexico: http://www.oecd.org/els/health-systems/Obesity-Update-2014.pdf http://www.oecd.org/els/health-systems/Obesity-Update-2014.p...
- jimmaswell 12y agoI'd rather be obese than give up my ability to eat products made with refined starches or corn sugar. Wouldn't this have a big impact on the food industry, too?
- coldtea 12y ago>I'd rather be obese than give up my ability to eat products made with refined starches or corn sugar. That's a really bad choice, though, that a lot of people make. Perhaps it will be good if that choice was eliminated, or made more difficult with a large tax. At least then people would think twice before ordering a $10 corn-syrup soda vs a $2 no-sugar one. >Wouldn't this have a big impact on the food industry, too? Well, the smoking bans also hurt the tobacco industry too. If an industry relies in causing people harm by using cheap substitutes (e.g corn sugar for sugar etc), or selling addictive shit, let them be impacted.
- jimmaswell 12y agoSome people whose comfortable level of eating happens to be above what they burn in their average day would rather eat what they want instead of counting calories, going hungry, and exercising all day.
- nilsimsa 12y agoThat is no longer true. You just have to sell your startup to someone with more money.
- djokkataja 12y agoTo people on Hacker News, startups are like hammers, and everything looks like a nail.
- joshvm 12y agoGovernments will pay you if the cost of your preventative treatment is less than the cost of providing state welfare. Don't assume that the public has to pay from their own pocket, they can pay you through other means. Government grants are often sizeable and under appreciated.
- dominotw 12y agoSociety has no use for them and doesn't deem them worth saving.
- lukevdp 12y agoThere are plenty of doctors, drug companies, scientists and researches working on these issues.
- jgh 12y agohttp://hackernest.com/dementiahack/ http://hackernest.com/dementiahack/
- melling 12y agoPart of the problem is that it affects much older people so it's out of our daily thoughts, and we might not know them as well. Also, when people get the disease, they often go into hiding. Ronald Reagan, Margret Thatcher, and Charlton Heston come to mind. I noticed that there's a Glenn Campbell documentary that covers his Alzheimer's. He was a little before my time and a superstar in his time. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glen_Campbell http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glen_Campbell Maybe the movie will bring a little more attention to the disease. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2049586/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2049586/
- kolev 12y agoThis shows how flawed the whole medical science is today. The issue is not Alzheimer, the issue is autoimmune diseases, specifically, leaky gut, constant low-grade inflammation, and others. If you try to fix just Alzheimer's alone, you've accomplished little! Fix the leaky gut issue, you've solve tens of chronic diseases at once. But, I guess, it's more profitable to sell 10 different "targeted" therapies instead of fixing one thing with lifestyle and proper nutrition! Another thing to add is the Hygiene Hypothesis - we're not adapted to live in a sterile environment, so, either get a bit more filthy (and resilient) or adjust your nutrition to more anti-inflammatory state. Anyway, I'm happy that there are conscious physicians who are revolting against the status quo and practicing Functional Medicine like Dr. Mark Hyman and others.
- kolev 12y agoDownvoting without voicing a reason what do you think is wrong with my statement is a cowardly act. This community becoming rotten by then cowards and their baseless opinions. Honestly, if one thing could be done to counter the redditization of HN is to disallow downvoting or, at least, disallow if you don't post a comment.
- DanBC 12y agoI downvoted your first comment for outright quackery with no supporting links.
- kolev 12y ago"Outright quackery", really? It seems that you haven't been following recent developments. All the quackery is proven to be coming from FDA - vilifying salt, alcohol, saturated fats, animal protein for decades with no scientific proof.
- DanBC 12y agoPeople say that, and then they blame everything on sugar or wheat or whatever and make the same mistakes. I'm not sure why you included alcohol in your list of things people said were harmful that are not harmful. Alcohol is harmful.
- jgable 12y agoThis comment is asking for trouble, but I'm making it in the hope of getting some good discussion going, and hopefully not a flamewar. I've been thinking about this a lot lately since my own family is struggling with this issue. I very strongly feel, like many people probably do, that I would not want to live with dementia. I would not want to live that non-life, I would not want my family to have to experience it, and I would not want to burden them with my care. In the not-unlikely event that I'm diagnosed with Alzheimer's or some other form of dementia, I would want to end my life while I'm able to competently choose to do so. I would want to do so with quick and painless drugs instead of a gun. However, assisted suicide is only legal in a handful of US states, and then only in cases of terminal illness with less than six months to live. There is nowhere in the US for an early-state dementia patient to commit assisted suicide. It is currently legal in Switzerland to do so, and people have traveled there for that very purpose. [1] Other people have committed suicide without assistance to avoid the ravages of dementia. [2] I'm aware of the counter-arguments to assisted suicide: that it can cross the line into euthenasia, that it makes the most vulnerable in our society even more so... but still, there has to be some way for this to be legalized. What to do? What are some concrete proposals for how to alter existing legislation to allow assisted suicide in cases of dementia? Does anyone have personal stories that make the argument against it? [1] http://www.bbc.com/news/health-22715363 http://www.bbc.com/news/health-22715363 [2] http://news.nationalpost.com/2014/09/01/ethically-this-seems-to-me-the-right-thing-to-do-wrenching-suicide-of-b-c-woman-with-dementia-spurs-euthanasia-debate/ http://news.nationalpost.com/2014/09/01/ethically-this-seems...
- notastartup 12y agoor you can just smoke weed...all the time. surely that is better than killing yourself.
- DanBC 12y agoPeople detained in a hospital against their will - something that happens to people with advanced dementia - cannot just "smoke weed all day".
- 12y ago
- apsec112 12y agoAlzheimer's is terrible, but the way our current medical system handles old age makes it even worse. A doctor friend of mine wrote an essay on this, titled Who By Very Slow Decay (http://slatestarcodex.com/2013/07/17/who-by-very-slow-decay/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2013/07/17/who-by-very-slow-decay/): "Somewhere in the process your mind very quietly and without fanfare gives up the ghost. It starts with forgetting a couple of little things, and progresses until you have no idea what’s going on ever. In medical jargon, healthy people are “alert and oriented x 3″, which means oriented to person (you know your name), oriented to time (you know what day/month/year it is), and oriented to place (you know you’re in a hospital). My patients who have the sorts of issues I mentioned in the last paragraph are generally alert and oriented x0. They don’t remember their own names, they don’t know where they are or what they’re doing there, and they think it’s the 1930s or the 1950s or don’t even have a concept of years at all. When you’re alert and oriented x0, the world becomes this terrifying place where you are stuck in some kind of bed and can’t move and people are sticking you with very large needles and forcing tubes down your throat and you have no idea why or what’s going on. So of course you start screaming and trying to attack people and trying to pull the tubes and IV lines out. Every morning when I come in to work I have to check the nurses’ notes for what happened the previous night, and every morning a couple of my patients have tried to pull all of their tubes and lines out. If it’s especially bad they try to attack the staff, and although the extremely elderly are really bad at attacking people this is nevertheless Unacceptable Behavior and they have to be restrained ie tied down to the bed. A presumably more humane alternative sometimes used instead or in addition is to just drug you up on all of those old-timey psychiatric medications that actual psychiatrists don’t use anymore because of their bad reputation."
- x0x0 12y agoemts get to deal with this all the time too. People get sick in nursing homes -- they are cesspools -- and have to be transported to a hospital. Unfortunately, they have no idea what's going on, and they're being strapped down in a van and manhandled by strangers. You can imagine how they react. After a while they get notes in their medical records saying they have to be physically restrained during transport, which terrifies them even more. I would much much rather be dead.
- tokenadult 12y agoFigures from the article may help us think about this issue more clearly. "Alzheimer’s disease is practically unheard of in adults younger than 40, and very rare (one in 2,500) for those under 60. It affects 1 percent of 65-year-olds, 2 percent of 68-year-olds, 3 percent of 70-year-olds. After that, the odds start multiplying. The likelihood of your developing Alzheimer’s more or less doubles every five years past 65. Should you make it to 85, you will have, roughly, a fifty-fifty shot at remaining sane." When we are talking about a disease with base incidence of only 3 percent even for seventy-year-olds, we are so far talking about a disease that has been a low-priority disease. It's only in recent decades, as life expectancy has increase at all ages from 40 on up to 80,[1] that a lot of people have outlived heart disease, cancer, and the infectious diseases that used to cut life short at younger ages. As more people who are otherwise healthy age into ages at which their risk for Alzheimer disease increases, there will be increasing research and study of treatments related to Alzheimer disease. The fact that there are still people who can live past age 100 without getting severe signs of any kind of senile dementia suggests that we have something to discover about individual differences to find out what protects some people from Alzheimer disease decade after decade after decade. There is no need to give up hope. Incremental improvement--a little change in treatment here, a little change in lifestyle there, and a better understanding of prevention overall--is most of what has improved healthy lifespan in relation to other diseases, and there is no reason to think that Alzheimer disease is any different. My own maternal grandmother, born in the 1800s, lived to the age of ninety-nine. Near the end of her life, she plainly had some kind of dementia, and presumably that was Alzheimer disease, and I think that was her cause of death. But she had a lot of interaction with her eleven children and thirty-eight grandchildren and various great-grandchildren for a long time after she was widowed, and I don't think anyone in the family looks back on her life and thinks that her death needed to be hastened. Some people retain memories of childhood in extreme old age even after they no longer form new memories of current events. For my grandmother, this was shown by one visit I had with her in her mid-nineties, when she no longer was sure who I was, but still remembered and was able to sing along me a song she had learned in childhood. (The song was in German, her native language, so I know she had not heard it for many years by the time I sang it with her. I had learned the song only when I studied German in university studies.) So don't give up on communicating with your aged relatives. Try to reach back in time to the best memories they have of their childhoods. They may surprise you with their understanding for a long time. And by a long time from now, when all of us reading this are old, Alzheimer disease may be largely a thing of the past. The lengthy second-person-viewpoint account of caring for an aged parent with Alzheimer disease in the article is disturbing and moving. It reminded me deeply of caring for my late dad during the last six years of his life, when his thinking was completely intact but his mobility was destroyed by a spinal cord injury. There are a lot of devastating forms of disability that human beings can face, and, no, Medicare in the United States does not take care of patients with long-term disability of any kind. I did feel a lot of futility when talking to my dad (who had difficulty talking not because his brain wasn't working, but because he was paralyzed from his second spinal vertebra down, and couldn't even clear his throat or swallow on his own). He wanted to walk again--or at least to be able to scratch his own nose again--but he never did after his injury. Taking care of a helpless relative is rough--any time, for any reason--but we didn't give in to the idea that he should die early just to make our lives more convenient. He died only when a lot of other health problems (many of them aggravated, surely, by six years of immobility) piled up just after his seventy-eighth birthday. There a lot of memories I have of my dad (and my children have almost ALL of their memories of their grandfather) after the day on which his spinal cord was injured. I was willing to interrupt a career transition and diminish my "free" time to almost nothing to be with him in his old age. That wasn't easy, but that's what we did. [1] http://www.nature.com/scientificamerican/journal/v307/n3/box/scientificamerican0912-54_BX1.html http://www.nature.com/scientificamerican/journal/v307/n3/box...
- mjcohen 12y agoIt's going to get so expensive and aggravating that killing people with extreme Alzheimer's will be allowed, or even encouraged. Don't say never until you have had to take care of one.
- c4urself 12y agoWonder if the advance of virtual reality could improve these peoples lives in some way -- kind of what they're doing in the Hogewey complex -- simulate a life that is somewhat "normal" to these people to reduce stress and anxiety.
- jqm 12y agoFrom the article... "1 percent of 65-year-olds, 2 percent of 68-year-olds, 3 percent of 70-year-olds. After that, the odds start multiplying. The likelihood of your developing Alzheimer’s more or less doubles every five years past 65. Should you make it to 85, you will have, roughly, a fifty-fifty shot at remaining sane." 1% at 65 doubling every 5 years for 20 years = 16% 3% at 70 doubling every 5 years for 15 years = 24% What am I missing?
- Someone 12y agoThe "likelihood of developing" vs incidence (what proportion of population suffers from it) 1% at 65, 3% at 70 means that, in the 65-70 year range, about .4% of that cohort develops Alzheimer's per year. Double that to .8% per year in the 70-75 year range and you get 7% incidence at age 75 (3% had it at age 70, 4% got it between ages 70 and 75). Continuing, you get: - 1.6%/year in the 70-75 range gives you 15% incidence - 3.2%/year in the 75-80 range gives you 31% incidence - 6.4%/year in the 80-85 range gives you 63% incidence That's in the right ballpark.
- jqm 12y agoDidn't you use 70-75% twice? Once in the text body and once in the list? Wouldn't your method leave you with 31% at the end if you just used this age bracket once and didn't have the extra double cycle? But for the record, I'm sure you are right. The ODDS of developing start doubling. Not the amount of people afflicted (No doubt a somewhat complicated figure as death, not insignificant at those ages, starts changing the equation. Do people with Alzheimer die at the same rate as those without?). Thanks for the explanation.
- thisjepisje 12y ago>In 1900, about 4 percent of the U.S. population was older than 65. Today, 90 percent of all babies born in the developed world will live past that age. This comparison is a bit fishy, isn't it? The 4 and 90 don't have much to do with each other, since the age at which people die isn't taken into account. Even if everybody lives past 65, if they all die at 66, only 1/66th (or 1.5 percent) of the population is older than 65.