4 ms·
When I read this article, I was blown away by this passage: > Typically, outsiders cannot comprehend how the massive expenditures never manage to yield energy.
by jessriedel 12y ago
When I read this article, I was blown away by this passage:
> Typically, outsiders cannot comprehend how the massive expenditures never manage to yield energy. Typically, insiders cannot comprehend how little is being invested in a project that presents such immense technical obstacles and also such potential. A graph commonly passed around among the insiders—an enduring scrap of twentieth-century budgetary ephemera—depicts the 1976 federal plan to build a working thermonuclear reactor. The graph tracks various scenarios for attaining fusion energy. The “maximum” effort, the most expensive up front, with initial spending as high as nine billion dollars a year, was projected to yield a reactor by 1990. The “moderate” effort, with spending never exceeding four billion dollars in a year, would take fifteen more years. The fusion community might be easy to criticize for its many unmet milestones, but for decades the United States has never come close to even the moderate effort. In 1977, when the American fusion budget was at its peak, government investment in the research, adjusted for inflation, was seven hundred million dollars; by 1991, this had fallen by more than half. It is now half a billion, not appreciably more than the Korean budget.
The chart was produced by Energy Research and Development Administration (ERDA), which was later subsumed into the Department of Energy and presumably represented the expert wisdom at the time. (Please correct me if you have info that most experts were in fact more optimistic.) It can be found, in 1976 dollars, as figure 1 here:
http://www.21stcenturysciencetech.com/Articles_2010/Winter_2009/Who_Killed_Fusion.pdf http://www.21stcenturysciencetech.com/Articles_2010/Winter_2...
I am having a hard time getting over the importance of this. For all the discussion of global warming, energy prices, population crunches, etc., etc., fusion is always ignored as a solution for the simple reason that people think it's unfeasibly costly. And they think that only because they think it's had a history of being grossly more expensive than promised. But if we've really known how much it would cost to get commercial fusion power since 1976, then this reasoning is completely faulty. So then if we just haven't spent the modest amount of money on it...isn't this insane? Someone please tell me what I'm missing.
- callesgg 12y agoWell it might eventually be shown that it is just to unstable to be usable. It is a big gamble to put money in to unproven stuff, if money was not a parameter global warming could be fixed whenever we wanted.
- rwallace 12y agoNot everyone thinks the problem is the R&D cost. I mean if that was the only problem, then yes, I would agree, give them a blank check. It's my opinion fusion just isn't a good way to generate power on the scale at which 21st-century civilization operates (i.e. a fusion reactor wants to be very much larger than a gigawatt) so we would be better off to forget about it and spend the money on either fission (which can actually do everything fusion promises except have emotional appeal - and I suspect the real source of the emotional appeal of fusion power is that it exists only in people's imagination) or if people won't politically accept fission, just keep working on solar, wind and biofuels.
- jessriedel 12y agoAre you arguing that we shouldn't pursue fission because we won't need as much power in one place as is provided by efficient large-scale fusion designs? Because that seems very weird to me. Power is great. Our civilization thrives on power. The costs of making things energy efficient are large. Now, the current thinking is that available power sources either cause harm (fossil fuels) or are expensive and intermittent (renewables). And that thinking is prudent. But if we can solve all this with fusion...that would be fantastic! Think of all the things you could do if you had cheap power, and all the regulations you could dispose of. Is your argument really that we won't find a way to make use of cheap, clean power?
- rwallace 12y agoOkay, so let's build a petawatt-scale fusion power plant. I can actually think of practical ways to build one if it can be that large. But that's not going to happen. A petawatt-scale fusion power plant is not going to be economically or politically feasible this century, no matter what progress we make on plasma physics and no matter how cheap it would be per watt. Every power source has a preferred scale. A fuel cell can be the size of a mitochondrion, but a combustion engine, in order to be efficient, really wants to be at least big enough for a lawnmower, and an efficient fission reactor wants to be at least a good few megawatts. My conjecture is that a fusion reactor wants to be at least a petawatt, and even if we solve the plasma physics problems, a gigawatt fusion reactor will cost more per watt than the equivalent in solar plus appropriate attached storage - which makes it pointless to work on fusion at this time.
- willyt 12y agoFrom the article, ITER is currently projected at $15B which is not that much for a construction project of this scale. The crossrail project in London is costing ~$25B. Heathrow terminal 5 cost ~$6.5B. Also, it's not unusual for the costs of a major infrastructure project to be double or triple the estimate. I think they are doing just fine.