4 ms·
One of the fundamental concepts in algorithmic information theory is that the physical design and construction of your "novel golf club" is completely and perfe
by jandrewrogers 12y ago
One of the fundamental concepts in algorithmic information theory is that the physical design and construction of your "novel golf club" is completely and perfectly equivalent to a mathematical equation in exactly the same way the RSA algorithm is. The argument generalizes to all patentable subject matters. And as fabrication technology is becoming more sophisticated this fact is starting to become more obvious in practice.
No one patented modular exponentiation, they patented an encryption algorithm that employs modular exponentiation. That is a distinction with a real difference. All patents have this type of construction. The same argument could be used to assert that all chemical process patents are patenting common chemistry or facts of nature.
The deeper issue with both copyrights and patents is that they are based on legal distinctions that don't exist mathematically. The law must therefore necessarily be inconsistent and ambiguous in its treatment of such things. Piling yet another mathematically unsupportable fiction on top of the existing ones won't mitigate the problem.
I can live just fine without algorithm patents but as a matter of principle I also object to the obviously selective and inconsistent application of standards for what is and is not patentable.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> One of the fundamental concepts in algorithmic information theory is that the physical design and construction of your "novel golf club" is completely and perfectly equivalent to a mathematical equation in exactly the same way the RSA algorithm is. Equations and algorithms can't generate force or protect metal from corrosion or convert chemical reagents into medicine. They have no corporeal existence. There is no computation you can do that will get the golf ball into the hole. > And as fabrication technology is becoming more sophisticated this fact is starting to become more obvious in practice. Using a 3D printer to make a patented golf club is clearly patent infringement. Widespread availability of fabrication technology is certainly going to make enforcing certain patents much more difficult in the same way that it has for copyright but what does that have to do with patentability? > No one patented modular exponentiation, they patented an encryption algorithm that employs modular exponentiation. That is a distinction with a real difference. It's the same piece of code. Math has no particular intent. > All patents have this type of construction. The same argument could be used to assert that all chemical process patents are patenting common chemistry or facts of nature. No one is disputing that anything can be described by math. The point is that the math is different from the thing it describes. A chemical process is not itself math. An algorithm is. A good way to understand it is to realize that a physical thing can be used as a "computer" to execute the mathematical algorithm describing its behavior but the reverse is not the case. You can calculate 'E' in "E=mc^2" by setting up a nuclear reaction that will convert a mass 'm' into energy 'E' and measuring the energy that is produced. You can perform the same calculation using a general purpose computer. So the algorithm/formula "E=mc^2" can be executed on a nuclear reactor or on a smartphone. But doing the calculation without the nuclear reaction will not actually produce 'E' joules of energy that could be used to e.g. drive a steam turbine. That's the difference.
- sgt101 12y ago"Equations and algorithms can't generate force or protect metal from corrosion or convert chemical reagents into medicine. They have no corporeal existence. There is no computation you can do that will get the golf ball into the hole." Algorithms can; they can create a decision to apply a paint or to move an actuator in a particular way, or to remove access to a file or to remove a file completely. This is the way that algorithms can be materialized in the same way that a chemical process described as a series of instructions for building machines and using them to process base materials can be materialized.
- AnthonyMouse 12y agoOnly if the machine is doing something in excess of computation. Then you have a machine that applies paint in a particular way. The algorithm itself isn't the thing you're patenting anymore. Whereas "removing access to a file" is still nothing but computation. The machine in that context is fully abstract. Any general purpose computer of any design can do it. So the algorithm itself should be unpatentable and the machine is a general purpose computer that exists in the prior art, which leaves nothing to patent.
- spj 12y agoAllowing patent on even 'math' should not be an issue as long as the math technique is sufficiently complex that the probablity of someone else independently arriving at that math within the patent term seems to be very low
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> Allowing patent on even 'math' should not be an issue as long as the math technique is sufficiently complex that the probablity of someone else independently arriving at that math within the patent term seems to be very low Your criteria would exclude in excess of 99% of issued software patents. Keep in mind that 20 years is the period of time between the introduction of DNS and the introduction of the iPhone. Twenty years ago Google did not exist and Windows 3.11 was the latest version. Twenty years before that the IBM PC did not exist, Microsoft did not exist, TCP/IP did not exist, AT&T would be The Phone Company (singular) for another decade, the Cold War was in full swing, people were wearing Disco Suits and many of the parents of this year's crop of college graduates had not yet been born. Unless you meant that the term of a software patent should be on the order of six months to a year, which hardly seems worth the candle.
- loup-vaillant 12y ago> No one patented modular exponentiation, they patented an encryption algorithm that employs modular exponentiation. Then I must ask: What invention is needed to invent the algorithm, once you know the math? Is this a novel invention (no prior art about the same algorithmic idea being applied elsewhere)? Is it non-obvious (a professional computer programmer couldn't be expected to come up with the algorithm, when presented with the math)? I'm no expert, but I suspect that if you teach me the math behind a particular encryption scheme, then I could program the algorithm without too much difficulty.
- throwawaykf05 12y ago>What invention is needed to invent the algorithm, once you know the math? Math and algorithm are overloaded terms that often mean the same thing, so it's not possible to answer that question. However, to clarify what jandrewrogers meant: at the time modular exponentiation was a known mathematical construct; what was invented and patented was a new, previously unknown algorithm that used that mathematical construct as part of an encryption technique. Now both can be seen as "math" or "algorithm", but the key difference is that the encryption algorithm has practical utility (i.e. providing security) whereas modular exponentiation by itself has none.