5 ms·
Did it strike anyone else that this piece was specifically written to discourage people from working with Homejoy? Not clients, but folks who do the cleaning? I
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
Did it strike anyone else that this piece was specifically written to discourage people from working with Homejoy? Not clients, but folks who do the cleaning? It seems a number of these articles all have the same touch points which come out of the union organizing handbook, "you deserve paid time off", "you deserve workmans comp", "you deserve a retirement plan" (all things unions have arranged for workers and things which services such as Homejoy don't provide)
The article never seems to go to the question of "Gee there are Janitorial Service companies that offer all of those things, the workers who feel they deserve those things should seek them out at those companies." Except those same companies are losing business to the Homejoys of the world.
That suggests to me that there is a structural imbalance in the availability of labor and a wage floor which prevents that labor from being engaged. That we're getting more people working, is that a bad thing? That more people can get rides in the city is that some how evil? I get that it is a challenge if you're organization is competing with another that isn't similarly constrained, but is the right answer to constrain the competition, or is it to loosen those constraints? Are we trying to keep existing businesses in business or get more people employed?
- Kalium 12y agoUnemployment was lower when slavery was the order of the day. That doesn't mean it was a good approach.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoSo you agree with the narrative that non-union employees are no better off than slaves? I would be interested in how you reason to that point of view.
- publicfig 12y agoNo, their statement was that lowering unemployment is not an adequate sign of whether or not the labor force is healthy using an example from the past.
- aroden 12y agoIf you'd like to argue for a pure market system then please direct the poor to starve on your door step. Personally, I prefer having this social safety net but it comes with the responsibility of keeping employers from abusing the system as well with things like minwage. That is why how this is evil (read: unfair to other employers). As the article states this guy gets DC bus rides for free. That annoys me. Homejoy users should pay the full cost of getting their home cleaned. It does not make sense for tax payers (including myself) to be providing a subsidy for home cleaning service. Is this really the a wage floor or just indirectly abuse of the a social-safety net for cheaper services by the wealthy?
- arebop 12y agoPrivate companies such as traditional unionized(?) maid service organizations shouldn't be trusted to provide a social safety net either.
- pkaye 12y agoMostly they are trying to build a business without taking any of the responsibilities.