4 ms·
Why? To support the point that citing an indictment is a highly questionable approach to attacking someones credibility, especially after witnessing it effectiv
by dmix 12y ago
Why? To support the point that citing an indictment is a highly questionable approach to attacking someones credibility, especially after witnessing it effectively derail the conversation in this thread.
The insider trading case does not disprove that QWest faced serious economic repercussions for non-compliance.
The question of whether his insider trading charge, which was filed by the SEC four years after his initial actions at QWest, was a response to his non-compliance is a lot less likely. But publicly discrediting your opponents sounds like the type of thing particular agencies do best.
- tptacek 12y agoI don't even know how to respond to this comment, because I don't see where Nacchio's "credibility" is even on the table. The guy was convicted of defrauding his shareholders out of many millions of dollars. The basic fact pattern supporting the allegation is there in black and white; his attorneys have, from what I've read, acknowledged those facts.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoThe gov't builds cases using the testimony of criminal conspirators against their accomplices all of the time. Are all of those cases are a sham? If no, then all of your noise about Nacchio's stock sales is irrelevant to the matter of whether the government's prosecution was in retaliation against him.
- tptacek 12y agoI believe this is a non sequitur argument. I'm not arguing that the government didn't "retaliate" against Nacchio. I have actually no idea whether they did or didn't (it's tricky to tease it out given the timing of the prosecution, which again happened during a wave of similar prosecutions). My point is that people should be wary about rehabilitating people like Nacchio. The accepted facts of that case do not paint a sympathetic picture. There are good, strong arguments against NSA surveillance and coercive interventions with industry. They should survive inconvenient facts. But that's not even what's being asked right now. The only question here is, are those arguments damaged by the refutation of one single very convenient fact? This happens all the time on HN: people really seem to want to observe the world through the lens of their issues. I have trouble with that. I think the NSA needs drastically better regulation, and that some of their actions warrant criminal justice attention. But I have an even bigger problem with accepting what seem to be obvious falsehoods in the service of that perspective.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoUnless I am missing something, your premise is that Nacchio is a cheat, and therefore we should discount anything he says about the motives behind the government's prosecution of him. Is that correct? Need I remind you that the government are confirmed cheats and liars here, as well? The judge who tried and sentenced him? Resigned in disgrace afterwards from some sort of sex scandal. See how Ad Homs work? As for peoples' sympathy for Nacchio, I'll tell you that I think that a company executive who cheats on stock options is not a rare thing. It's not my favorite thing, but the degree to which that affects me personally is close to nil; but a telecomm executive who (allegedly) told the NSA to piss off is something that affects me, and worth a second glance. Nacchio has been consistent in his denials and allegations throughout and continues to be to this day. Here is an interview from March. http://www.foxbusiness.com/business-leaders/2014/03/27/former-qwest-ceo-joe-nacchio-tells-story-fight-against-nsa-sec/ http://www.foxbusiness.com/business-leaders/2014/03/27/forme... And one from May http://denver.cbslocal.com/2014/05/28/defiant-joe-nacchio-lashes-out-against-those-who-imprisoned-him/ http://denver.cbslocal.com/2014/05/28/defiant-joe-nacchio-la... >But I have an even bigger problem with accepting what seem to be obvious falsehoods in the service of that perspective. What seem to be? They either are obvious falsehoods or they are not. And, I have to tell you that the things that are obvious to you and the things that are obvious to me are not always of the same set. I can't even begin to imagine what kind of saint a person would have to be to earn standing in your court.
- tptacek 12y agoNo! That is not my premise! I do not care what Nacchio has to say. You can find anything he says compelling and that is fine. I am saying that independent of anything Nacchio has to say, he does not appear to have been convicted on trumped-up charges. But that belief is extremely common; even Jason Kottke featured it on his popular blog.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y ago>No! That is not my premise! Good, and thanks for clearing it up. >I am saying that independent of anything Nacchio has to say, he does not appear to have been convicted on trumped-up charges. But that belief is extremely common; even Jason Kottke featured it on his popular blog. That's fine, but I don't think it makes much difference if the charges were trumped up or legit. When you've got the NSA, you don't always need to trump up charges. Just be patient, catch your mark breaking some law. Maybe give the mark a little nudge if needed. One of Nacchio's complaints was that he wasn't allowed to disclose certain exculpatory facts in public.
- danielweber 12y agoAn average federal indictment's stating of base facts ("on February 13th Nacchio sold 180,000 shares") is much more trustworthy than, say, the average Wikipedia page. In court, the standard is that the prosecution should prove its case to the jury of the accused's peers beyond a reasonable doubt. That's great and should stay that way. But for the purposes of Internet message board discussion, there's no need for that high of a threshold. The appeal didn't say Nacchio didn't insider-trade; just that his gains should be considered gains-less-taxes.