2 ms·
> That's assuming that consumers place a higher value on fair-trade and conflict-free than they do on getting a cheaper product. What if fair-trade-conflict-fre
by baddox 12y ago
> That's assuming that consumers place a higher value on fair-trade and conflict-free than they do on getting a cheaper product. What if fair-trade-conflict-free costs 5x what the unverified stuff does?
Obviously any social system needs to deal with the realities of externalities. Simply invoking the concept of externalities is insufficient to dismiss anti-regulation, libertarian, or anarchic positions, because the literature of those positions nearly universally [0] recognizes externalities and constructs arguments under the acceptance that externalities exist.
The first thing to recognize is that government regulatory agency is not a simple cure for externalities. There is no obvious inherent reason why a government would even be able to estimate externalities better than a market, much less enforce the internalization of those externalities.
[0] My claim of "nearly universally" is mostly anecdotal, based on my own reading of prominent literature from laissez-faire and anarcho-capitalism. I am sure there are some people who use those labels yet deny the existence of externalities, but I think in principle one should argue against the strongest version of your opponent's position.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> There is no obvious inherent reason why a government would even be able to estimate externalities better than a market Well, assuming effective equal democracy [1] there is, given also the assumptions on which market efficiency in transactions without externalities is based [2], since presumably interest in promoting or preventing a transaction one is not engaged in directly engaged maps to the expected utility or disutility experienced as a result of the transaction (i.e., its positive or negative externality.) [1] which is a big assumption, to be sure. [2] which are also big assumptions, but they are also the entire underpinning for the idea that libertarian, market-based economies are efficient for any kind of transaction, so in considering regulated vs. libertarian markets, its pretty fair to assume them in consideration on the regulated side.
- baddox 12y agoIndeed, all the economic models I'm aware of are explicitly theoretical, including ones that cover how governments and markets work. They often contain assumptions that are obviously not present in the real world: like perfect information or zero transaction costs. Of course, that doesn't mean they're not occasionally testable to some extent, but I'm strongly skeptical of anyone claiming to have a "proof" of any nontrivial claim regarding these ideas. That said, I do personally find the arguments that markets will outperform governments more convincing than the inverse. On the topic of market transactions with externalities, you might find the Coase theorem interesting, and the related folk theorems in game theory. I see it as a compelling rebuttal to the Pigovian model of using a centralized organization (generally government) to internalize social costs. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coase_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coase_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folk_theorem_(game_theory) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folk_theorem_(game_theory) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax
- dragonwriter 12y ago> On the topic of market transactions with externalities, you might find the Coase theorem interesting, and the related folk theorems in game theory. I see it as a compelling rebuttal to the Pigovian model of using a centralized organization (generally government) to internalize social costs. One can envision idealized democratic government as a mechanism for realizing the required precondition for the Coase theorem, to wit, the democratic process of policy making in such a system is the venue in which externalities are traded. (That such exchanges occur in the policy making process in any government of human beings is widely observed, the "ideal democratic" part is that that all citizens have equal power in the policy making process, such that the trade is generalized.) This, of course, unifies the Coase theorem with the Pigovian model (the separation between the two comes from treating "government" as something distinct from the participants in the economy, rather than a venue in which those participants interact.)
- pavel_lishin 12y agoIt was not my intent to dismiss anything, but derefr didn't address these issues. I'm glad that someone has spent time thinking about this stuff, but no possible solutions were mentioned. I also agree that a government isn't a simple cure, but a government can definitely enforce things better than a free market. As a hyperbolic example, if I use slave labor to cook meth to sell on Ideal Silk Road 2.0, my worst case scenario is losing my business - with a government, my worst case scenario is fines and decades in prison.
- baddox 12y ago> a government can definitely enforce things better than a free market. It might be true that government can more effectively enforce the rules which is chooses to enforce, although I might even argue that. It is not definitely true that government will more effectively enforce the rules which you (or society) believes should be enforced.