3 ms·
> The OP was not talking about the magnitude of the differences, but the nature of them. And what, pray tell, are the 'nature' of disorders like Cotard's synd
by gwern 12y ago
> The OP was not talking about the magnitude of the differences, but the nature of them.
And what, pray tell, are the 'nature' of disorders like Cotard's syndrome?
> OP: "Look at that person who was born with no arms due to a birth defect. They're able to live a fairly normal, happy life. Maybe arms aren't essential to human happiness."
Try going back and reading what was said. Your paraphrase is incorrect. Here's a correct paraphrase:
"OP: look at that person born with no legs. They're able to lead a somewhat normal life. This shows that anyone claiming that there might be differences between the fingered and the fingerless such as in fine motor control is a moron - because a leg is so much larger than a finger!"
> I'll leave what this makes you a demonstration of as an exercise for the reader.
Well, it demonstrates you can't paraphrase or follow the logical structure of an argument. I'm not sure what I'm demonstrating; hopefully something good.