4 ms·
We really should have a lower limit for housing. Meaning if you're "homeless" you get given something about the size of this to live in that will at least keep
by Someone1234 12y ago
We really should have a lower limit for housing. Meaning if you're "homeless" you get given something about the size of this to live in that will at least keep you alive until you can find something else.
Currently we have people building "homes" literally within the suspension beams of bridges, in shop doorways, and we have hundreds of people freezing to death out of the streets yearly. When we could build a basic "home" for under $150, it seems completely avoidable.
I think, counter-intuitively, the biggest roadblock to doing something like that might be regulations (e.g. building codes). They define what a "home" should and shouldn't be, but ultimately set the bar very high (and we wind up with the current situation).
Maybe there should be a new set of regulations for "emergency accommodation." Nobody should be literally homeless in 2014 in the Western world, particularly as it would cost less than an iPhone to house them for a year (assuming only a roof and basic electric space heater, nothing else).
- humanrebar 12y agoLikewise for earning income. It's a good thing that people want to keep regulators away from kids' lemonade stands, but what about an adult? Isn't it also a barrier to pulling yourself up by your bootstraps if you can't legally sell things like lemonade, childcare, and plain white Ts?
- fibbery 12y agoThis is how you get slums.
- beloch 12y agoOne thing most homeless people need in order to find a home is income. Being homeless carries a huge stigma with it that can make it difficult to find a job, so low-income (or no-income) housing is indeed immensely important. However, one big problem with such housing is that it often isn't that close to jobs. People who can't afford a home often can't afford a car either, and Austin's (for example) public transit is a hot steaming pile of garbage. Rich people in the suburbs typically don't want low-income housing next to their homes or shopping malls so, indeed, zoning is an issue. Concentrating low-income housing in one area creates a lot of problems. Another major problem is that there is a large correlation between being homeless and mental issues. In Canada, you can go on welfare and get housing if you need it, but you have to jump through hoops and interact with government employees to do so. Some people just aren't able or willing to do that. Of course, the climate is rather deadly up here for large portions of the year. There are shelters that the homeless can go to, but there are always those who seem to prefer sneaking into abandoned buildings or sleeping on transit vehicles. Persuading these people to get off the streets takes a lot more resources than people expect, so those resources just aren't there a lot of the time. Perhaps small, spartan, stand-alone shelters that aren't in large blocks of low income housing and aren't formally assigned would attract those unwilling to seek other forms of shelter.
- mindslight 12y agoIt's not building codes. It's that as soon as you have something that resembles a bona fide home, it becomes legible to the legal system, ownership is claimed/assigned, and then its occupant is on the economic treadmill of the debt-based financial system (or they are forced out).
- jonah 12y agoI think with appropriate legal protections against default, seizure, etc. it might be worth it. Pride-of-ownership is pretty powerful.
- mindslight 12y agoWhat specifically are you proposing? Our entire economy is kept going at its current rate only by the sheer majority of people being forced into make-work jobs so they can pay rent for a piece of land to sleep on. My point is that unless you think it good to create a second class of citizen that gets conditional freebies for jumping through government hoops, then the underlying treadmill that everyone is on needs to be remedied first.
- jonah 12y agoI agree the current situation is a mess. My comment relates to an idea I heard recently and really liked. Essentially it advocated subsiding mortgages instead of rent for the classes of people who can't do it on their own. That way, they're building equity and have something to call their own. In addition, we'd need to provide some additional protections from foreclosure, etc. commensurate with their need. Stability is a key factor to being to climb out of the hole.
- mindslight 12y agoSubsidizing mortgages will just cause them to go up - property "valuations" are only limited by the carrying cost of the loan. Honestly I think this is why California prices are so astronomically high - there are no heating bills in the winter to distract from mortgage payments. > commensurate with their need If satisfying government hoops is a requirement, you turn that into their primary job. And thats a dead end for respectability. > Stability is a key factor to being to climb out of the hole For many people, there is no discrete "hole" - their existence in an area is simply not economically viable. I don't state this harshly because I wish to cast them off, but because I wish to illustrate that putting a bandage on their individual situation still leaves the underlying treadmill that we're all on. (And yes, life itself is a treadmill as well - living isn't free. But tally up the costs of necessities such as food/water/shelter, and compare to the man-made rent to have a place to put that shelter)
- harlanlewis 12y agoBuilding codes don't need to be thrown out to construct low cost housing, and low cost housing doesn't need to result in slums. Salt Lake City recognized the total cost of a large homeless population was significantly higher than building permanent homes paired with services to accommodate them. Reducing the chronic homeless population increases capacity of emergency services, saves the community money, improves quality of life for both homeless and those living/working in an area with a large homeless population, and creates a setting where support services (health, wellness, education...) can be more efficiently and effectively provided. The 2013 report goes into detail: http://jobs.utah.gov/housing/documents/homelessness2013.pdf http://jobs.utah.gov/housing/documents/homelessness2013.pdf Some highlights: Salt Lake City has 779 permanent housing units for supporting chronically homeless. On a random night's count, 87% of the homeless population was sheltered. Chronic homelessness decreased 9% from 2012-2013, and has decreased 74% since program start in 2005. 2005 - average annual cost for emergency services and jail time for each chronically homeless person was $16,670. The cost to house them and provide case management services was $11,000 per person. Over half of those housed by the program moved on to permanent destinations. Only 8% returned to homelessness.
- jacquesm 12y agoWhat a super project. Besides the fact that it was even more economical (I think if there had been a surcharge it would still be the right thing to do). But it also seems to have been instrumental in providing a stable base from which to return to a more normal life. Wonderful.