3 ms·
I feel like there is a lot of beating the dead horse with this issue. Is there (holding the jingoistic flag wavers aside) any real disagreement on the conclusi
by AndrewKemendo 12y ago
I feel like there is a lot of beating the dead horse with this issue.
Is there (holding the jingoistic flag wavers aside) any real disagreement on the conclusion that the US healthcare system is terrible for the average user - such that we need continual reminder?
Didn't the whole ACA debate prove that yes, we get it it's broken and there is major popular support for changes, even if the actual changes made were not themselves popular by a plurality?
- danielweber 12y agoEveryone agrees that it needs to change. There is little agreement on how to change it. Most proposed changes are "let's gore the other side's ox."
- rodgerd 12y ago> There is little agreement on how to change it. That's because, generally speaking, the more collectivist proposals rely on evidence from the many, many countries that pay less for healthcare per-capita and get better outcomes, while the side that feels a more lassaiz-faire approach are relying on an essentialy religious position.
- danielweber 12y agoThe former group also ignores countries like India and Singapore, and pretend that there is just one kind of health-care system everyone else uses, sometimes calling vaguely calling it "single-payer." People like Ezra Klein desperately try to correct these people, to no avail. And after all, why should they care to learn the facts? All they need is enough buzzwords to call the other side stupid on message boards, and they are perfectly happy.
- xtracto 12y agoI believe that one of the reasons why discussions around the US healthcare debate do not bring any plausible alternatives is because the /real/ solutions would comprise something like socialization of medicine (like Norway, Canada, or other developed countries) which is something that the American culture is against in its deepest roots. This is comparable to the discussion we have here in Mexico about Oil, which is also a very touchy issue because culturally, in Mexico we have always been taught that Mexico´s oil is Mexicans property, and that any attempt to privatize some of its processes would mean to "sell the Fatherland/country" to evil transnational companies. Thus, given this premise, it is almost impossible to have a "grown up" discussion about how to fix the problems related to energy.