3 ms·
Possible, but not useful. Consider a shaped piece of glass. It "calculates" something about how a light-input bounces, is diffused, makes interference patterns
by Terr_ 12y ago
Possible, but not useful.
Consider a shaped piece of glass. It "calculates" something about how a light-input bounces, is diffused, makes interference patterns, etc. It leverages natural laws directly and quickly, literally at the speed of light. Perhaps with the right shape and the right light-beam, we can answer questions that matter to us.
Now imagine a programmed version, where all those calculations that "just happen because the universe works that way" have to be done by a CPU crunching numbers. (Ultimately relying on its own set of natural laws.) The second case is going to be much slower.
Another analogy might be a bunch of gear-based clockmakers who want to use electronic circuits instead... A gear-based simulation of electrons doesn't really help them.
- yohanatan 12y agoThat makes sense. However if the classical computer were strategically directed to the corners of the [search] space that are interesting, maybe interesting results could arise. It would be hard to have any sort of confidence in those I suppose if it must ignore large swaths of the space, however. It may serve as a discovery process informing more refined experiments though. Also, as I mentioned to another replier, I didn't say which type of computer must be used-- it should be possible with a quantum computer running software rewriting the NP-hard problem in terms most natural [i.e., native] to it. :-)
- yohanatan 12y agoAlso, I was thinking more along the lines of using randomness + probabilistic models to shortcut the actual calculations involved. Since quantum mechanics already involves a lot of probability (to which depth we don't really understand yet), it seems that this should be feasible.
- danbruc 12y agoQuantum physics is completely deterministic until you perform a measurement - no randomness involved. And the randomness associated with measurements may be just due to our ignorance.