4 ms·
>despite being required to obey all traffic laws however ill-suited they are for pedal powered vehicles. I absolutely agree with this general sentiment. Bikes
by bane 12y ago
>despite being required to obey all traffic laws however ill-suited they are for pedal powered vehicles.
I absolutely agree with this general sentiment. Bikes aren't vehicles and can't perform like a motorized vehicle along virtually any parameter. They shouldn't be regulated like a vehicle and they shouldn't be sharing space with vehicles.
They also clearly aren't pedestrians since sharing space between bikes and pedestrians is usually a bad experience for everybody (I've been hit by numerous bike riders while out jogging or walking on local trails. They usually yell at me for blocking their path if the collision causes them to have to stop or fall). However, because they move at much higher speeds than pedestrians, they're dangerous in mixed spaces.
But they're a valid form of transport. But clearly distinct from both other modes. So I fully support bikes having distinct travelways. I'm even delighted that my tax dollars might help pay for it.
- slykat 12y agoI don't understand this perspective that much. Have you seen how road traffic works internationally, specifically Europe? There are many examples where significant bike traffic can safely share the road with cars. The Netherlands is one of the best examples here. The issue is that: 1) Road design - many/most cities do not have adequate road engineering to deal with bikes 2) Driver training - Road drivers in the US aren't trained to deal with non-car traffic 3) Weak Bike traffic law enforcement - I don't think that bike negligence is a key cause of accidents but I do agree that police enforcement of traffic laws on cyclists is lax. So I disagree with the notion that bike traffic needs to have a separate roadway from urban traffic. I think there are plenty of good examples where a sharing system works.
- bane 12y agoWell, up top, I specifically endorsed the protected bike lanes as a good idea. I'm not sure if that counts as "separate" or not, but I'm on board with the idea. I've spent months all over Europe, and in general, in cities cars are a liability, bikes work much better. In the countryside, the motorways I've been on are basically deathtraps for bikes and I've never seen one on them (likely due to it being illegal or some such but I wouldn't know).
- xiaoma 12y agoYou've been hit by numerous bike riders while out jogging or walking on local trails? This is mind-blowing. As a former distance runner, I've put in 10,000+ miles of running on trails, on sidewalks and on small roads and done so in several countries. In over a decade of that, I was never hit by any cyclist. Even in terms of close calls I can only remember a couple. What kind of trails do you frequent and what the heck are you doing to get hit not once but numerous times? Are you using some kind of headphone that blocks out surrounding sounds?
- bane 12y agoI had a full on collision last year that sprained my elbow so bad I may have to get surgery. I'm waiting to see if it heals up. The bicyclist gave me an earful about blocking the shared-use trail with my walking until I called pulled out my phone to call the cops and then he high tailed it out there. It was literally a vehicular hit and run. And if I need surgery will cost me thousands of dollars and months of physical therapy on top of the medical and physical therapy bills I've already paid. About a month ago I was clipped by a guy in full kit who then kept on pedaling without checking on me (another hit and run). My wife was pushed off a trail by another guy in full tour de France kit while out for a walk earlier this summer. I've probably been hit or clipped or pushed a half dozen times since I moved into my neighborhood. I could go on. Bike riders around here are really serious about their hobby and are generally assholes to anybody who gets in their way.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- msandford 12y agoThat's pretty awful and I can see how it might affect your views on cyclists. I would want to punch those guys myself. I had the good fortune to start cycling seriously with a university club where the coach was really strict about safe riding being a pre-requisite to participation and as such I don't do the kinds of things you're talking about. In fact most of the cyclists I know don't do that stuff either. But just because I'm not exposed to a bunch of jackasses doesn't mean they don't exist. I think your support of separate spaces for separate uses is admirable given the bad experiences you've had.