2 ms·
To diagnose a mental disorder, there must be impairments to normal living. A person who is able to function constructively in society might have tendencies, hab
by snowwrestler 12y ago
To diagnose a mental disorder, there must be impairments to normal living. A person who is able to function constructively in society might have tendencies, habits, leanings, personality traits, or whatever word you want to use to describe the differences between people. But if they are functioning and not in distress, by definition they do not have a disorder.
That does not stop people from using disorder names as shorthand. "OMG I'm so OCD about checking that my back door is locked!" "I'm pretty Aspberger at parties." Etc. But it's important to remember that these are a casual shorthand, not actual diagnoses. People with actual Obsessive Compulsive Disorder do not laugh about it; they are in deep distress about it.
So: while we can talk about psychopathic tendencies, or use "psychopath" as a shorthand, people who operate normally or successfully over a long term in business are likely not afflicted with a psychopathic disorder. They might be ruthless, they might be hard headed, they might have lower empathy than average. That doesn't necessarily mean they need to weeded out, excluded, treated, etc.
The hard question is: at what point is not a normal and adaptive difference in personality, vs. a disorder that must be weeded out? And who is in that position to do so?
It's tempting to look at something like the 2008 financial meltdown and chalk it up to a bunch of psychopathic banking CEOs. I think that's a bad idea for two reasons.
First, it can inhibit a more detailed and nuanced understanding of the root causes of problems. We run the risk of not addressing the real causes, stuff blowing up again, and then just blaming it on psychopaths again. Cycle, cycle.
Second, it runs the risk of demonizing skills or personality traits that might actually be valuable in business.
When you're making decisions by numbers, you might sometimes have to set aside or reduce the emotional content of your decisions.
When leaders try to give people everything they ask for, they create unsustainable systems, because there are not infinite resources in the world. And things change; innovation eats old products and business models. And then when the system collapses into bankruptyc or mass layoffs, the leaders left holding the bag are accused of making psychopathic decisions.
Whereas as less empathetic leader (or more disciplined, if you want to put a positive spin on it) might have made more economically sustainable decisions in the first place.
- thenomad 12y ago" People with actual Obsessive Compulsive Disorder do not laugh about it; they are in deep distress about it." This is extremely important. "OCD" has become a joke to many, but it's a horrible, debilitating mental condition to those who actually suffer clinical OCD. Oddly enough, Cracked came out with one of the best articles I've seen explaining why OCD is so very far from a laughing matter: http://www.cracked.com/blog/4-things-no-one-tells-you-about-having-ocd/ http://www.cracked.com/blog/4-things-no-one-tells-you-about-...