4 ms·
> The police tend to look at cyclists the way you do, and many times don't find fault with drivers even if cyclists are KILLED much less injured or have their b
by mindslight 12y ago
> The police tend to look at cyclists the way you do, and many times don't find fault with drivers even if cyclists are KILLED much less injured or have their bikes destroyed.
I mostly drive these days, but I'm no friend of cars in general or police for that matter. However it's important to keep in mind that injustices occur both ways, and forming blanket statements is a great way to end up just talking past one another.
Many drivers do stupid things (eg right turns, doors), many bikers do stupid things (eg ride on wrong side of road, sidewalks). That doesn't indict either group.
If 'bane is worried about being wrongfully found at fault for an accident with an irresponsible biker, I would say the best approach would be to get a dash cam (or five).
- heydenberk 12y ago>> However it's important to keep in mind that injustices occur both ways, and forming blanket statements is a great way to end up just talking past one another. That's not true. Did you look at the New York Times article? The prosecution rate of motorists who kill cyclists in non-hit-and-run crashes is close to 0. In several major cities, it is actually 0. So no, the injustices do not go both ways.
- mindslight 12y agoYour point does not refute what I said. It shows that no drivers have been criminally blamed, ruling out one kind of injustice against drivers. Other injustices, such as undeserved wrongful death/bodily injury compensation may have occurred. Regardless, OP isn't normally this obtuse. He's clearly reacting to a perceived injustice, even if it does not exist. Please read my above comment again and try to understand why I wrote it.
- bane 12y agoActually if you want to take that article literally it means that in almost every case a cyclist is killed it's their fault. Demonstrating once again that cyclists presume everybody else's area, even to the point of danger to themselves.
- mindslight 12y agoThat's incorrect. At the most, you could only infer that it wasn't legally the driver's fault. There's a huge middle ground where fault won't be pinned on either side.
- bane 12y agoNo, you're right. I was irritated when I wrote the above.
- msandford 12y ago> Actually if you want to take that article literally it means that in almost every case a cyclist is killed it's their fault. Right, because all police officers and DAs and everyone is 100% unbiased in all circumstances no matter what? Also from the article: "Take Sgt. Richard Ernst of the San Francisco Police Department, who confronted people holding a memorial at the scene of Ms. Le Moullac’s death. Parking his squad car in the bike lane, forcing other cyclists into the very traffic that killed Ms. Le Moullac, Sergeant Ernst berated those gathered, according to witnesses, and insisted that Ms. Le Moullac had been at fault. Days earlier, the department had told cycling activists that it had been unable to find surveillance footage of the crash. Provoked by Sergeant Ernst, people at the memorial decided to look for themselves. It took them all of 10 minutes to find an auto shop nearby with a camera that had footage of the incident. The police eventually admitted that the truck driver was at fault, but they still have not pressed charges." Truck runs over and kills woman. Cops don't cite or charge truck driver, nor do they investigate. Friends do investigate, turns out the driver was at fault. Still no charges by the DA. Clearly there is some bias.
- bane 12y agoNo, you're right. I was irritated when I wrote the above.
- mikeash 12y agoThe difference is that drivers are killing cyclists without consequences, while cyclists aren't killing drivers, because it's not physically possible.
- mindslight 12y agoThat asymmetry will always exist. The only way to eliminate it is to prevent any accident between bikes and cars by having completely separate networks.
- DannyBee 12y agoSo, cyclists can't physically cause road accidents that kill drivers? Interesting (and false :P)
- mikeash 12y agoI can't think of any scenario where a driver could kill somebody in an accident where the driver isn't at fault for it, except for cases where the cyclist at fault gets themselves killed. How does it work?
- msandford 12y agoFrom the article I originally linked to: "In stories where the driver had been cited, the penalty’s meagerness defied belief, like the teenager in 2011 who drove into the 49-year-old cyclist John Przychodzen from behind on a road just outside Seattle, running over and killing him. The police issued only a $42 ticket for an “unsafe lane change” because the kid hadn’t been drunk and, as they saw it, had not been driving recklessly." Kid kills cyclist, but doesn't get tried even for involuntary manslaughter. Had this kid used a gun instead of a car, you can be sure that the story would have a different ending. I believe that's a direct, nearly EXACT example of a driver killing a cyclist in an accident and not getting charged despite quite likely being at fault. If the police issued him SOME kind of a citation it stands to reason he wasn't 100% in the right. Someone else paid with their life. Here's another example in the article: "...Amelie Le Moullac, 24, pedaling inside a bike lane in San Francisco’s SOMA district when a truck turned right and killed her. In these articles, I found a recurring phrase: to quote from The San Francisco Chronicle story about Ms. Le Moullac, “The truck driver stayed at the scene and was not cited.”" How many more examples would you like to see? It takes me only a minute or two to dig these up as they're all over google. I don't have to go past the first page.
- msandford 12y agoI think the consequences of the injustices are highly asymmetric and that skews people's sense of what is right and wrong. Cyclists tend to pay with their bodies or their lives when something goes wrong in the street. Drivers -- at least when cyclists are involved -- do not. And often they do not get prosecuted at all. Please read the article linked, it has several examples. I can find plenty more if you like. If a driver suffers a 30 second delay when a cyclist does something stupid but a cyclist suffers death when a driver does something stupid it's not entirely unreasonable to discount the injustice that drivers suffer at the hands of cyclists. Furthermore you allude to "sidewalks" as something that cyclists can do wrong. I disagree. Few states have laws prohibiting sidewalk riding though some cities have passed laws against it. http://blogs.findlaw.com/law_and_life/2013/08/legal-to-ride-a-bike-on-sidewalk.html http://blogs.findlaw.com/law_and_life/2013/08/legal-to-ride-... I couldn't agree more that the best protection a driver has is a dashcam. Just the threat to the other party (driver, cyclist, pedestrian) that such a thing exists might well convince them to not pursue a frivolous claim.
- mindslight 12y agoI'm well aware of cases like the recent CA Sheriff's Deputy, and think it would be appropriate to charge him with manslaughter. I agreed with the rest of your comment, just thought that specific passage was starting to preach past. My original point is that a police bias against bikers doesn't refute that in a different situation, a driver may be incorrectly civilly blamed for an accident. Let's say a biker comes around a corner on the wrong side of the road, the oncoming car manages to stop, yet the biker then hits the hood and unluckily dies. The biker is clearly responsible for this, yet if the driver's insurance pays out a $100k wrongful settlement, nobody is going to feel bad for them. Also it's quite possible that "responsible for" was meant in the moral sense of controlling a ton of steel - that's what we want people to do, right? I was referencing "sidewalks" still in the context of cars - a biker coming into an intersection from the sidewalk at speed is an unsafe menace. Honestly reflecting on this thread, I bet this would be a ripe topic for researching degenerate us-vs-them politics.