5 ms·
Your comment (intentionally or not) makes it sound like humans are killing cats and dogs simply for the sake of killing them. The problem is overbreeding causin
by freehunter 12y ago
Your comment (intentionally or not) makes it sound like humans are killing cats and dogs simply for the sake of killing them. The problem is overbreeding causing too many animals. We're not forgetting that these animals make great pets, we're not killing them just for fun. There are limited options in how to handle overpopulation.
- trhway 12y ago>The problem is overbreeding causing too many animals. it is we who, pretty arbitrary, decide that it is "too many" - it means that we're killing them pretty willfully ( just a step before "just for fun" and "the sake of killing them") We definitely didn't do anything to accommodate cats and dogs inside the civilization they helped to build. >There are limited options in how to handle overpopulation. 2 myths in one sentence - "limited options" and "overpopulation"
- waqf 12y ago> too many It was http://xkcd.com/1338/ http://xkcd.com/1338/ that made it clear to me that if we didn't want cats and dogs, we wouldn't have them.
- freehunter 12y agoIt's not arbitrary, the number of house pets is limited to the number of households that can have pets plus the number of animal shelters we have. Once that number is exceeded, the options are set the animals free or find humane ways to control the population. Depending on where you live, setting them free could be a good option or it could be terrible. If the animals have no survival instinct left, they will be left alone to starve to death or die from sickness. In the city, they may be hit by cars, or they might attack other pets. They might even make other pets sick by biting them. They can easily become a nuisance in populated areas, although rural areas have a larger domain for stray animals. There's no one walking into your house saying "there's too many pets in the world" and shooting Lassie. They only get put down when there is no one left to take care of them. If you think it's arbitrary, why don't you adopt every homeless pet? If you can't do that, then you have to accept that there is such a thing as overpopulation, that we're there, and that there are limited options for how to deal with the problem.
- trhway 12y agomost of your post is basically speculation, except for the unfortunate reality of cars hitting pets. Fact-wise: >There's no one walking into your house saying "there's too many pets in the world" and shooting Lassie. that is actually what happens when your violate your local pets per household limit. As i said, human civilization policies toward cats and dogs is a circus of arbitrary speculations.
- sliverstorm 12y agoWhat are you voting for? Release all the strays into the wild? Mandatory adoption of at least X dogs per household? You haven't taken any position other than "Yes they CAN all be accommodated", which is like a three-year-old refusing to take a bath. local pets per household limit You'll have to take that one up with your local government. My town has no such limit.
- trhway 12y ago>What are you voting for? granting them rights according to their mental capacity and sentience - i.e. about the rights of a 2-3 year old toddler (or a person with extremely severe autism - very close approximation of a cat's or dog's mental capacity). For example - how would you handle an overpopulation by a toddlers? Would you set them free into the wild or euthanize? EDIT: to CocaKoala below. >But that's a ridiculous comparison because cats and dogs are not toddlers i didn't say they are toddlers. I said we should treat others at least according to their mental capacity and sentience. And treatment of toddlers or severe autistic people is an example of such treatment. >Granting cats and dogs the rights of toddlers or autistic individuals means you're giving up the right to spay or neuter your pet; nobody would advocate for sterilizing a toddler, exactly. It is definitely time to give up such medieval ways. Why aren't we using pills on cats and dogs? Because we don't want to bother with extra expense and effort. Affording the rights would force us to do it. And it would be for our own good as treating others with consideration and humane compassion would only improve our own civilization. >but many very reasonable people advocate for sterilizing house pets, and for good reasons. if you remember anything about the history of human race, you wouldn't invoke the formula "many very reasonable people advocate for <...>, and for good reasons" TO "dogecoinbase" : Summary of your post's logic - "affording rights [according to mental capacity and sentience] is cruel". Yep, no way to fight that logic. TO: CocaKoala 2nd post. I advocate for granting rights and making decisions on that basis. At the current state of technology i do see that adopting such a basis would lead to the choice of pills over surgical mutilation. To address your Edit - i didn't insist on specific everyday birth control pill taken orally. If we to talk technical details - long term birth control injection would me more close to it.
- davidcbc 12y agoIf limited options is a myth then what is the option that you propose? Don't just say "don't kill them" if you don't have a legitimate proposal for what to do with them instead.
- Cuuugi 12y agoSo i'm assuming that you are advocating the "setting free" of unadopted domesticated pets. I truly hope for the sake of the animals that my assumption is wrong, or that you are never put in that position of authority. Euthanasia is the lesser of the many evils for those animals.
- true_religion 12y agoHe said in another comment that he believes they should be accorded the same rights as toddlers or the mentally disabled. So in that case, euthanizing them just because "we don't have enough homes" isn't going to be an option.
- dredmorbius 12y agoThere are very few wild large mammal populations which number in the 100s of thousands, let alone millions. The principle exceptions are all domesticated animals: cattle, sheep, hogs, and the like. After humans, the largest non-domesticated predator mammal population is likely crabeater seals (11-12 million); land predator, the American black bear (850-950 thousand). There are fewer than half the California sea lions statewide (355 thousand) than there are residents of San Francisco (837 thousand). Most major land predators number in the tens of thousands worldwide, or fewer. Among ungulates (divided amongst even and odd toed variants for some reason), water buffalo are the most numerous non-domesticated population at about 172 million, followed by species of duiker (7 & 2 million). American bison number 530,000, reduced from a pre-Columbian population of 60 million, and a low of 750 total individuals in 1890. Of the non-domesticated odd-toed ungulates (generally: horse-like), most numerous are the plains zebra, at 660,000. The next most numerous is the Kiang, 60,000. In the oceans, several dolphin populations number 1-2 millions. Among primates, the most numerous non-human population is Müller's Bornean gibbon, 250-375 thousand. That is: other than humans, most large land mammals have populations equivalent to mid-sized human towns, a few might rival mid-sized to larger cities. And populations of dogs and cats (83.3 million and 95.6 million respectively in the US according to the Humane Society)[1] are entirely due to direct human intervention. ________________________________ Notes: 1. http://www.humanesociety.org/issues/pet_overpopulation/facts/pet_ownership_statistics.html http://www.humanesociety.org/issues/pet_overpopulation/facts...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- joesmo 12y agoI think a partial solution is to limit breeding and selling for profit, aka puppy/kitten mills. There are plenty of cats and dogs out there and we don't need people breeding them for profit in deplorable conditions, making more so that they can end up in shelters where they will be killed. Obviously law can only go so far, but only the really big factory farms would need to be targeted. Removing the profit incentives from such operations would effectively shut them down. Also, it'd help to end discrimination, for lack of a better word, against many dog types like pitbulls, etc. in apartment leases and such. Many animals are given to shelters when their owner moves and is no longer allowed to keep the animal and many are not adopted because of such conditions in the lease. Either an apartment allows dogs or not. Finally, there are a lot of people who would be more than glad to feed stray cats and dogs and many strays are very friendly. Not all cats and dogs are dangerous, so why shouldn't we allow them to roam about? Yes, they can get killed, sick, die from starvation etc., but they might also be taken care of by the locals and live. That's just life.