4 ms·
"But I'm actually more worried that this, left as it is, is just going to be used by mothers and fathers of children with autism, or the adults around them, as
by jerf 12y ago
"But I'm actually more worried that this, left as it is, is just going to be used by mothers and fathers of children with autism, or the adults around them, as an indictment that they weren't "good enough parents"."
That's already something parents with autistic kids get to live with. You may get to choose your friends, but you don't choose your relatives, and some relatives have a hard time dealing with autistic grandkids/nephews/nieces/etc. Denial is a popular option. It would be stupid to even think about holding back a treatment because of this concern.
I'm also frankly astonished that we have to preface stories about autism treatments with how wonderful autistic people are and how we're not trying to "eliminate their uniqueness". My autistic son is only lightly autistic, but believe me, this is a disability. It's great, it's truly great that many people manage to live with it and their lives aren't entirely ruined, but believe me, it's still a disability. If you can mitigate it, do so.
- jimmaswell 12y agoIt's not always really a disability. Some have it light enough that it's not really a hinderence moreso than a difference. I had a minor diagnosis of it and so have others I know, and I don't feel like it negatively impacts my quality of life. I'm not alone in this and your one data point doen't disprove this. This doesn't mean it shouldn't me midigated but you shouldn't make such sweeping claims about it.
- jerf 12y agoI am well aware of that. My point is, in some sense, the exact opposite... the fact that some people like you have it to a very minor degree shouldn't result in researchers having to half-apologize for trying to find treatments for it. Autism runs from barely-present all the way to total incapacitation and institutionalization... the idea that researchers have to defend themselves from people for trying to help cure it is crazy. The fact that they may or may not cure it someday, or mitigate it, or change it, none of that affects the humanity of the individuals, or who they are, or is a denial of anything about them, or anything like that, and I sincerely hope nobody ever so much as stalls a research application as a result of logic like this.
- Mz 12y agoI have two autistic sons. They are neat people. Yes, they have some problems. I have never met anyone who does not have problems. I am tempted to make the comparison that I am female and that definitely comes with a raftload of disadvantages in this world yet that doesn't mean I wish I were born male, but, given the audience here, I am not sure that will make much sense as an analogy to suggest. (Yet, I seem to be making it anyway. Oh, well.)
- fecak 12y agoThe reason for prefacing stories and mentioning uniqueness is at least partially rooted in criticisms stemming from the 'neurodiversity movement'. There are at least some with autism that consider it a gift and criticize anyone who may try to alter the behaviors of children. Autism charities and advocacy groups have to deal with this frequently. Because of the wide range of the spectrum, you have some with autism who have advanced abilities who feel the need to advocate for low-functioning people who happen to share the same diagnosis. Unfortunately, the autism of my child is quite different than the autism of someone with the ability to speak out for others. If you have been involved with charities or advocacy groups, you'll see the neurodiversity people on message boards and such.
- otakucode 12y ago>I'm also frankly astonished that we have to preface stories about autism treatments with how wonderful autistic people are and how we're not trying to "eliminate their uniqueness". Even the most profound and obvious disabilities are adopted by parents who refuse to see it as a disability. They take this so far that they will resist attempts to correct it. This is huge in the deaf community, for example. There is open aggressive opposition to cochlear implants, because they are seen as robbing deaf children of exposure to 'deaf culture'. It is a complex issue, because children need to be given cochlear implants long before they are capable of making decisions for themselves, so they are often crippled for life at the hands of their own parents - parents who can not share in the same treatment because they are too old. The lowest weaknesses of the human spirit are on display in some of these people, denying hearing to their children because they don't want their children to be 'better' than they are.
- dogecoinbase 12y agoAs a thought experiment (I'm not saying it's exactly analogous), imagine some sort of genetic treatment for a fetus that gives it white skin rather than the black skin of its parents. White people have more opportunities in life, are generally more successful, certainly have a lower lifetime risk of being murdered by police, et cetera. What arguments apply in the case of a cochlear implant that do not apply here?
- endtime 12y agoBeing deaf is an objective, unambiguous disability. I don't think the same is true of being black, even if it correlates negatively with certain metrics.
- justinpombrio 12y agoIf you were the only person in the world, would you prefer being black or not? How about deaf or not?
- jerf 12y agoIn a nutshell, I refuse to engage in the degree of ethical chicanery necessary to even pose such a silly question. This is one place where "common sense" has it right, and sophomoric philosophical debates are just a way of seeming sophisticated while in truth being horribly debased. But hey, if you're going to play "I'm too twisted in knots by postmodernism to understand ethics anymore", why not ask whether it would be correct for a deaf couple to deliberately induce deafness in a child not otherwise destined to be deaf? (The best part is that these questions probably cease to be hypothetical in another 20 or 30 years.... and then the shit really hits the fan....)
- mpyne 12y agoMy oldest son has autism, and much more than "lightly". My youngest son may or may not have it, he seems to be right on the edge. I am aware of how disabling it can be, which is why my wife and I employ the mitigating techniques we can get our hands on to try to help our oldest son navigate a neurotypical world, without turning him into just another lab rat. My point stems instead from a question: If the "cure" is attempted, and does not succeed, is that because the parent was a failure? Or did the "failure" we see reflect an even better outcome for a child who might have been even more severely autistic without that intervention? We live in a world where a not-insubstantial number of people honestly believe that vaccines cause autism, so whatever the answer to the previous question actually is, I can tell you the perception of the answer may very well be much different. The "Refrigerator mother" concept pointed out by makomk is precisely what I was referring to in our past. I hope that such slanders will remain a part of our past and don't pop up again.