9 ms·
Sofware seems to be like wine — it has to age for an arbitrary number of years before people will consider it "production ready".
by outworlder 12y ago
Sofware seems to be like wine — it has to age for an arbitrary number of years before people will consider it "production ready".
- Alupis 12y agoNo, it's more-or-less we haven't had this large codebase around long enough, and it is changing too rapidly to have uncovered all of the show-breaking bugs (not even mentioning the new ones that will be introduced). People still don't use BtrFS because of the scare of losing data, and it's been around for years. But why has the same enterprise crowd bought into Docker being totally safe and bug free enough to put into production large scale? It's like flying a prototype jet into combat.
- outworlder 12y agoBecause they are two different things. BtrFS is a brand new filesystem. It's low level stuff where the tiniest bug can obliterate an enormous amount of data. Docker is basically a bunch of glue code between several technologies that are getting quite old now. At a basic level, it creates LXC containers that, while not as old as BSD Jails, are quite reliable already. Same goes for cgroups and most everything else. The only questionable thing imho is (surprise) AuFS. But that's not implemented by Docker either.
- markbnj 12y agoExactly. The comparison with BtrFS is not reasonable.
- SEJeff 12y agoNot really, it is using all of the exact same kernel namespacing code that LXC has used. Would you consider LXC pretty battle tested? I certainly would. It has been in the kernel for years. Now you mentioned earlier that Docker is not a "super chroot" (your words, not mine). Yes it is! You can break out of a chroot with root privilege inside the chroot, ditto for a linux container using LXC or when using docker without the right settings to drop capabilities. Granted, this all changes when user namespace support is merged into the Linux kernel, but they've been working on that code for quite some time. Additionally, if you want to be pedantic, it Btrfs, not BtrFS. As other people have said, docker is really not a huge codebase. It is primarily glue code on existing and very well established functionality in the Linux kernel. Try to check your facts next time before spouting so much FUD.