2 ms·
> With some kernel patching you could simply hide the /dev node after the boot is done with it. At some point we have to make the call on diminishing returns.
by kbenson 12y ago
> With some kernel patching you could simply hide the /dev node after the boot is done with it.
At some point we have to make the call on diminishing returns. It will always be possible for root to bork a system (without a rewrite of many, many utilities that rely on root permissiveness), it's just a matter of how hard we can make it to do that accidentally. To be clear, I think this work is very useful and appreciated though. As someone that spends almost all of every working day in terminals on remote systems, often as root, I applaud any effort to reduce catastrophic mistakes. Every time I have to rm -rf as root there's that little after-I-hit-enter-panic, where I have to assure myself I double checked and didn't accidentally just delete /bin. The root is protected from the errant rm mistake, but there's oh so many more ways to reduce a perfectly fine system to an unbooting heap of hardware.
> The root/user distinction places all your faith in octal permission bits. In some ways a properly designed run-as-root system is less risky, because the safeties are baked into the OS at a much deeper level. It is the difference between a dangerous machine having physical safety interlocks and paper-thin "for your safety" policies.
Give me both. Please.