3 ms·
A judge, a jury, it depend on legal system. In the legal system that Mojan resides in, Sweden, the lowest court is made up by 3 politicians and one judge which
by belorn 12y ago
A judge, a jury, it depend on legal system. In the legal system that Mojan resides in, Sweden, the lowest court is made up by 3 politicians and one judge which then vote on the issues at hand. To simplify, lets call it "a judge decide", but in truth, it depend on the justice system in the nation that the case is put forth in.
> plagued software copyright law for 20+
For something to plague, it has to inflict it. The question about derivative work is not brought up in cases around copyright law. Lawyers are not arguing about it in court, judges are not deciding about it, and juries are not asked to vote on it. At most, it has plagued software legal scholars, but then that claim would have to be supported by statistics from academia.
>Is there no precedential case law...
Industry standards is not precedential case law, its just the defined status quo. If one for example read the US supreme court decision around Aereo, one find that industry standard and status quo has a considered impact on judgments. The legal system in Sweden commonly uses industry standard when defining legal theory in unprecedential areas (See the Pirate Bay trial for example).
> In any case, there is literally no industry standard here
I strongly beg the differ. Larger commercial companies both uses GPL and LGPL, and the praxis is to differentiate the licenses on linking. A company like HP and Apple will distribute GPL software, and will combine LGPL and proprietary software. Someone could argue in court that the perceived praxis do not exist, but I suspect a number Amicus curiae would then be sent in arguing the opposite.
> no intent in the written license text
"The GNU General Public License does not permit incorporating your program into proprietary programs." - GPLv2 and GPLv3
If a client of yours take GPL licensed software and incorporate it into a proprietary program, I would strong doubt arguing the definition of derivative work in court will yield successful result. Its the primary reason in my view why there is no precedential case for derivative work in GPL licensed software.