4 ms·
He turned things upside down. It isn't that fusion power has no risk of proliferation, it is just being developed only in the ways that have no (or extremely lo
by trhway 12y ago
He turned things upside down. It isn't that fusion power has no risk of proliferation, it is just being developed only in the ways that have no (or extremely low) weaponization potential - limiting development this way significantly slows down overall progress on reaching efficient power production. Add to that the policies (at least in the US) established almost 20 years ago when it was decided that fusion generated energy can't be cheaper than coal (yep, because most of the cost is actual turbines/generators and distribution) and thus no point in pursuing in the foreseeable future.
- duaneb 12y agoIt's such an odd stance--presumably fissile reactions are already dangerous enough that the cat is out of the bag. Everyone who CAN weaponize it can already wreak devestation.
- trhway 12y agofissile weapons are very hard to produce - huge enrichment facilities. Where is inertial confinement fusion device is just a matter of focusing enough power into small enough volume during very small period of time - pure engineering task and once technology is mastered we either have an easy way to colonize Solar system or to destroy ourselves as any ISIL would be able to use it. And judging by the current mindset of our species i doubt that Solar system if the first thing on our collective mind.
- duaneb 12y agoI must admit I don't know enough to really comment on the danger of fissile vs fusible materials; however, I was taught that one of the boons of fusion was that the energy source was stable (radioactive-wise) before entering the reaction.
- Terr_ 12y ago"Inertial confinement fusion device" != "Fusion Weapon" If you want to make a point about relative dangers, you should be comparing apples-to-apples. Simply expressing fission as a phenomenon is even easier than fusion, you can dig up rocks that do it all on their own. Weaponizing a phenomenon, on the other hand, always requires some additional work.
- mrfusion 12y agoI'm curious to learn more. Are you saying there are viable fusion methods that aren't being pursued? What was decided 20 years ago? Where?
- trhway 12y agoEven 30-40 years ago inertial confinement schemas were obviously better at producing fusion. They have also been more promising at miniaturization and thus weaponization. So, except for the laser driven - which due to low efficiency of lasers have very low miniaturization potential - the inertial confinement hasn't got any meaningful development during all that time until current days when mostly private money got into it. >What was decided 20 years ago? Where? Somewhere in 199x i remember reading something like a Congress committee's paperwork where cost of fusion was very unfavorably compared to the $0.04 cost of coal energy with thus pretty clear conclusion about economical unviability of fusion. It was like a bulb lit in my head back then - "that explains!" :). Edit: to the comment below - i should have worded better, the inertial confinement schemas are obviously better for developing future reactors as, at least, since understanding of bremsstrahlung losses in thermodynamically equilibrium plasmas it became clear the enormous, on the border of any practicality, size of possible break-even reactor and other limitation on them. Like no aneutronic p-Boron even in the great-great future of Star Trek. Where is inertial confinement have no such limits. As H-bomb - a successful break-even inertial confinement device shows - it is just a matter of miniaturization. Look at Sandia Z-machine for example - basically miniature model of what happens inside H-bomb after fission primary goes off - they aren't in a rush for any practical reactor, mind you, only to reproduce explosion conditions for weapons research - yet even from the start - something like in 1998 they were immediately closer to the goal than everybody else. 10-15% input conversion into X-rays at the 100TWt+ peak - that can be reached by NIF only today only if they replace the current lasers with semiconductor ones.
- XorNot 12y ago"Producing fusion" and viable reactors care two very different things. If producing fusion were the only concern then we'd stop at Hirschorrn fusors and call it a day.
- deleted 12y ago
- fleitz 12y agoIncorrect, once you have a fusion reactor, you have sufficient power to weaponize it. Weaponized fusion is a solved problem.