4 ms·
I wonder if Russia would let him go if Switzerland did really grant him an Asylum.
by gambiting 12y ago
I wonder if Russia would let him go if Switzerland did really grant him an Asylum.
- jacquesm 12y agoOf course they will. How he will get there is another matter, he'll have to cross at least two other countries and we've already seen a plane ordered down in order for it to be searched. Whether some nation in the flightpath from Russia to Switzerland would have the required fortitude to do that to a plane owned by the Swiss government is another matter entirely. Pissing off Bolivia is probably a mild '2' in international relationships, pissing off the Swiss would likely rate a '9' or so.
- tomp 12y ago> Of course they will. You haven't really substantiated your claim. I assume the parent poster was referring to the fact that Snowden is (potentially) a very valuable asset.
- jacquesm 12y agoSnowden has repeatedly asserted that the documents are out of his control, the only value that he has is in a potential barter deal with the US. Since even in the cold war spies were traded rather than those that fled their home country I highly doubt such a scenario could materialize. It would also make Putin look even worse than he already does on the international stage, and more importantly he'd look bad in the eyes of his own people (assuming they'd ever hear about it). Snowdens main value to Russia has so far been of the PR variety (And mostly for the home front at that, 'sticking it to the USA'). If you wish to make the case that Snowden will not be permitted to leave Russia then I think that is the claim that needs substantiation, rather than the opposite. Maybe you're right and they won't let him go but that would need a plausible scenario first.
- sfk 12y agoHe can also fly Aeroflot. Highly unlikely to be ordered down by anyone.
- DominikR 12y agoMultiple Aeroflot machines with Russian officials on board that were on they way home have been forced to land in EU countries because of sanctions. The only plane that probably would be safe is the Russian presidential plane.
- spacefight 12y agoHmm... Morales' plane coming to mind.
- gambiting 12y agoYeah but then again what was Morales going to do about it? Get a little bit angry? That decision was literally consequence-free. I highly doubt anyone would order Putin's plane to land anywhere though. Just like no one would order the air force one to land forcibly, it's just not done.
- jacquesm 12y ago'land or we'll start World War III'.
- gambiting 12y agoReally? Like what, launch nukes because Russia doesn't want to hand over Snowden? Come on, that's just ridiculous. If Putin sent his plane(or went himself on official business) to Switzerland, absolutely no one could do anything about it.
- jacquesm 12y agoWe're in violent agreement here. It was merely an illustration of what kind of ultimatum would be required to get that plane to land and I really don't see that happening. So I think if there is a formal offer of asylum by Switzerland and Russia lets him go un-opposed (which I assume they will) then he will arrive in Switzerland.
- saalweachter 12y agoGive Russia some time; they're working on reducing the number of countries between them and Switzerland.
- jacquesm 12y agoEast-Ukraine is not between Russia and Switzerland on any conceivable flight path and West-Ukraine barely so. But that was a funny comment.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoDepends where in Russia you leave from, Russia is big. A great circle from Moscow to Zurich passes through Belarus, Poland, Czech Republic and Germany, however if you went from Volgograd to Zurich you would go straight through eastern Ukraine.
- jacquesm 12y agoI don't think there is currently any commercial carrier that sends its planes over Eastern Ukraine. Not any commercial carrier that wishes to remain in business.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoRight now, according to Flightradar24, there are airliners from Dniproavia, Metrojet, Yamal Airlines and Air Moldova flying across eastern Ukraine. They are mostly going across the north of East Ukraine apart from Dniproavia, which may yet swing north, but it isn't as though airlines are avoiding the whole of eastern Ukraine.
- jacquesm 12y agoThe 'contested' area is completely free from planes right now.
- 12y ago
- joesmo 12y agoI'm quite sure every NATO or EU nation between Russia and Switzerland would order the plane to land at the behest of the US.