7 ms·
Revisiting the Moon
- sp332 12y agoDo people really think of the moon as "as a problem solved and a bit retro"? Anyone I've talked to about it would love to see people get back up there. Especially with the recent, incredibly expensive Mars missions, it seems like we could put a little more effort into checking out the Moon.
- tokenadult 12y agoWhat would we find up there that we didn't find last time with a new moon mission? EDIT: I guess the assumption about basketball played on the moon is that most of us would watch that on television. But how much would a team have to make in TV advertising revenues to recover the cost of sending athletes to the moon and keeping them alive there? (A similar question applies to the costs of running the Olympics on the moon.) Ladies and gentlemen, those are fun jokes, but is this kind of joking response going to prompt anyone to invest their own money in a moon mission?
- jacquesm 12y agoIt's not what we would find up there it is what we could do up there. For one we could set up a lunar observatory.
- hugs 12y agoGravity on the Moon is 1/6th the gravity of the Earth. Re-inventing every sport to take advantage of this could be pretty fun. Who wouldn't want to see a basketball game played inside an arena on the Moon?
- TeMPOraL 12y agoHosting Olympics on the Moon to bankroll a Lunar observatory... this is one hell of a nice idea :).
- hugs 12y agoInspired by this thread, I just whipped up a funny idea for a sci-fi-ish book: "Tranquility Base Hotel" https://gist.github.com/hugs/198e37dd75f814723c14 https://gist.github.com/hugs/198e37dd75f814723c14
- dalke 12y agoWhat could a lunar observatory do that an orbiting one like the planned James Webb Space Telescope or the proposed Advanced Technology Large-Aperture Space Telescope couldn't?
- jacquesm 12y agoStay aloft indefinitely (or at least, for our purposes indefinitely). Satellite based telescopes will always have a limited life-span, either they end up dropping too low and de-orbiting or they run out of aiming propellant.
- dalke 12y ago"Aloft" is a bit of a misnomer, I believe, for something sitting on the Moon. Both of the space telescopes I mentioned are targeted for L2, which is well beyond the Moon's orbit, so there's no chance they'll de-orbit. I believe they use reaction wheels for pointing, not propellant, but as L2 is not stable, you're right that it needs some fuel for station keeping. On the other hand, the Moon has quakes, and large temperature swings. Wouldn't that be much easier to set up an effectively stationary sunshield for the stillness of L2 instead? Plus, the Moon blocks out about 1/2 the sky, which seems like it might limit what you can do.
- jacquesm 12y ago> "Aloft" is a bit of a misnomer, I believe, for something sitting on the Moon. Sure :) But it's attaching something to a satellite rather than launching a satellite. After all, the moon is a satellite of the earth, but a natural one rather than an artificial one.
- dalke 12y agoI still don't see what science objectives it could do better than one of the ones proposed for L2.
- 12y ago
- hugs 12y agoMoney. I think we should build hotels there and make it a tourist attraction. For many countries, their main source of revenue is tourism. Why not the moon, too?
- soperj 12y agoWell I'm sure there were a lot of lessons learned in the 70s that have been completely forgotten by now w/r to having a man in space on another celestial body. Could certainly learn a lot about staying alive for an extended period of time on another planet.
- sp332 12y agoWho cares? We'd have people on the moon! :) Anyway, there have been a grand total of less than one full man-day of moonwalks. You think we discovered everything interesting in that amount of time? For starters, how about sampling all that comet debris on the poles. It seems easier than sending probes like Rosetta on 10-year comet-chasing missions.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoWell, maybe faster. Not easier. People require vast life-support systems (most of the payload weight). Can't beat a probe for efficiency.
- timdierks 12y agoThere's a lot of different "big science" investments humanity could make. In space alone, there's space stations, moon missions, Mars missions, cheaper Earth-NEO transport, etc., etc.; then there's particle accelerators, telescopes, and every other big science project under the sun (or beyond it). Two questions: first, in a zero-sum model, why is human exploration of the moon more worthy than other similar unfunded projects? In an non zero-sum model, why is it worthy enough to justify growing the funding pie for science projects? How many billions of dollars are there in "a little more effort", in your estimation?
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoTwo questions: first, in a zero-sum model, why is human exploration of the moon more worthy than other similar unfunded projects? In an non zero-sum model, why is it worthy enough to justify growing the funding pie for science projects? It's not in either case in my opinion, and I would argue is it significantly less worth than those other projects.
- maaku 12y agoYour mistake was assuming a zero sum model.
- maaku 12y agoWhy the downvotes? Expanding Earth's economic sphere to all of cislunar space necessarily expands the resources and energy available to human industry. There will be returns, and the economy will expand. It's not zero-sum.
- timdierks 12y agoEven in a non-zero sum model, each investment needs to justify itself vs. alternatives at the time. I may have a wealth of investments that can have guaranteed positive returns, but I must choose which to invest in at any time with limited resources. Even if I can expand available resources because of the promise of these alternatives, or through reinvestment of gains, I still must choose what to do at any time, until I have enough resources to pursue all promising avenues simultaneously.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoI always feel like a curmudgeon when the topic of manned space travel comes up or really space exploration in general. From my perspective I see literally thousands of ambitious projects yearly that go unfunded that would do mankind magnitudes more good than sending people into space or generally peering upward. I have heard the arguments ad-nausea for why investment in space exploration has a positive ROI and find none of them compelling. No, the handful of "dreamers" that it produces is not worth the billions of dollars, No, the handful of technologies [1] that we can find terrestrial use for as a byproduct are not worth the billions of dollars spent. If invisible braces were that big of a need we likely could have found the solution through much cheaper means. We should be putting our money into Fusion, AGI and longevity research. Not walkabouts on the moon. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_spin-off_technologies http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_spin-off_technologies
- pavel_lishin 12y agoLongevity is a great way for billions of people to witness the impact of the next Dinosaur Killer. Not so much for making sure the species survives.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoNot so much for making sure the species survives. What do you see as the long term (100,000 year) future of the Human race? The species you are describing (us) evolved to be successful in the specific environment of the earth. We know enough about our solar system from terrestrial based observation to determine that there is no other habitable planet for humans within our solar system. Moving us somewhere else without significantly changing our biology or having the unlimited resources to terraform and build synthetic atmospheres would be an exercise in futility given the insane costs. On the other hand if we are able to live long enough to build Fusion ("free" energy), build superhuman AGI to help us optimize our decisions and activities, and become blended with technology such that our biological limitations are removed, space exploration is trivial.
- pavel_lishin 12y ago
- acct123456789 12y agoThe main point of interest is "what's on the dark side of the moon?"
- FD3SA 12y agoNow that we're sadly past the era of "Big Science", we need to rely on business models to get anything done. This includes trips to the moon. I would argue though, that even if Big Science were to make a comeback, manned Moon or Mars missions would not be an efficient use of those precious dollars. There is much more pressing and productive research that is starved for funding at the moment. Robotic space exploration is cheap and effective, and scientifically far more useful. I say this as one of the biggest space nuts I know. Let SpaceX and Bigelow Aerospace do their thing and develop commercial space. We'll get our Moon bases eventually, it'll just take time to grow the economic infrastructure.
- digikata 12y agoI worry for humanity in the long term if the only broad direction we can give ourselves are evaluated in the framework of ROI. The very calculation of ROI assumes that there's a known and stable model for predicting both the investment required and a known output. Comparing many ROIs estimates assumes the slate of options covers the gamut of where one should invest - it could work very well for a small or midsize company with limited options going forward, but it feels like a huge fallacy to assume that covers an entire nation - let alone all of mankind. The best answer I can muster against framing the question in terms of ROI, is that we suspect we could go to the moon and stay there longer than ever before, and that puts us on a path of opening up vastly more unknowns, more rapidly than we would otherwise encounter by staying on the Earth and sending probes with limited sets of instruments, with narrow perceptions into space. Indeed, why would anyone travel anywhere on Earth even, when it's cheaper to look at pictures of the destination from the internet, or read the guidebook and be done. You could dismiss this as a purely humanistic argument, but if at least some of our resources aren't allocated to get to places where we simply don't strictly know the outcomes, we will simply will never grow beyond some confines.