3 ms·
> Haskell is not for most people, Prolog is not for most people, Coq is not for most people, why does Common Lisp need to be for most people? Prolog and Coq do
by oblio 12y ago
> Haskell is not for most people, Prolog is not for most people, Coq is not for most people, why does Common Lisp need to be for most people?
Prolog and Coq don't really feel like general purpose languages, they have very specific uses. Haskell and Common Lisp are general purpose languages, they are not meant to be used just for one domain.
What do general purpose languages such as Haskell and Common Lisp gain by remaining niche languages?
I'm genuinely curious. Sure - the community might be a bit more tight knit and the overall signal-to-noise ratio is a bit higher, but the overall output of a community 100x larger will always drown out the smaller one. And among the hundreds of projects out there at least some will certainly outshine the "polished to perfection" projects made by the smaller community. At a certain point the larger community will just have more quality projects than the smaller one.
So what does Common Lisp gain by purposely avoiding contributions? I'm genuinely curious.
- lispm 12y ago> So what does Common Lisp gain by purposely avoiding contributions? Does it do that? Contributions are welcome. It's just that it is not easy for most people to contribute to something like Haskell or Common Lisp. Many people just don't have the time or capacity to learn in. There are some people who learn Common Lisp because of specialized tasks (like composing music), but they have a motivation to learn a special tool.
- oblio 12y agoMany people don't have the time or the capacity to contribute to Python or C++ or PHP, either. Yet I rarely see comments as dismissive of the general programming population such as yours, coming from Python/C++/PHP users.
- lispm 12y agoCommon Lisp, the standard does not change, but each programmer can radically change the language in a day. This power is simply not for everyone and not everyone needs it. There is nothing dismissive about it. It's not that many people need a language, where working on one of several meta-levels is the norm and not the exception.
- eropple 12y agoYeah, there's a lot dismissive about it. Or, put more bluntly: stop being an asshole. It demeans you and what you're trying to champion.
- lispm 12y ago> Yeah, there's a lot dismissive about it. It's not. Different people have different intellectual capabilities. Some can read Hegel, most don't. Some understand Monads, most don't. That's how it is. Some can debug compile-time macros, others can't. > Or, put more bluntly: stop being an asshole. It demeans you and what you're trying to champion A personal attack. Great style!
- eropple 12y agoDude, I'm not even disagreeing with what you're saying. I'm saying you're being an asshole all over this thread. Chill.
- lispm 12y agoI'm neither your dude nor your asshole. Get some manners.
- oblio 12y agoWell, he is right that you're definitely not polite.
- lispm 12y agoBecause I told you guys that not everyone is intelligent enough to be able to program Lisp on a competent level? Is that a surprise for you? See the 2008 Ruby conference keynote from Yukihiro 'Matz' Matsumoto. He explains it in detail. Start at 8:40. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDnOBXD167k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDnOBXD167k I have interviewed many Java programmers in the past five years. I never found one who could explain how GC works, what lambda in Java 8 does, etc. There are a lot of ordinary programmers out there, even some of them with ten years work experience were surprisingly bad at actual programming. I hired some good ones, but generally the number of not so good programmers is high. Giving them a language where code is data, is a recipe for failure...