3 ms·
I was initially going to downvote you but after analysis you're correct. It continues on to specify specific instances of leaked IP information, which is compl
by gamblor956 12y ago
I was initially going to downvote you but after analysis you're correct.
It continues on to specify specific instances of leaked IP information, which is completely irrelevant hearsay if the stated means of discovery were supported by properly documented evidence.
Hearsay is, literally, an "out of court statement offered to prove the truth of the matter asserted [in the statement]". Hearsay must be (1) a statement (2) by a person and (3) offered to prove that something else happened. A log of IP addresses generated outside of the courtroom to prove that a defendant visited those computers/sites/addresses would normally be hearsay. However, in the US, hearsay specifically excludes records of regularly conducted activity. (See Federal Rule of Evidence 803). Internet access is a regularly conducted activity, so IP logs, like phone records and GPS addresses, have been deemed by the courts not to be hearsay.
But all of this is irrelevant. Weev's demand is asinine and shows that he (still) doesn't understand the law. In order to use the IP logs in court, the prosecution must turn over the IP logs, and all evidence collected with respect to those logs, to the defense during the discovery phase prior to trial. The defense will get their opportunity to investigate those logs. As other commenters have already pointed out, there isn't likely to be anything in the IP logs that would substantiate the NSA theory over the far more likely scenario of RU having borked his server configuration.
- dllthomas 12y agoMy understanding is that frequently the records must be regularly collected; it might not suffice that the activity is regularly conducted. I wouldn't hope to rely on this in your defense without talking to a lawyer first, but it's a good thing to keep in mind to stress the importance of (for instance) regularly keeping meeting minutes and such which might wind up needing to be exculpatory evidence at some point.
- mpyne 12y agoIt seems to me that IP logs would be even more "regularly collected" than meeting minutes though. And somewhat ironically, would not be exculpatory evidence here, but substantiating evidence of the FBI claim that DPR didn't know how to configure SR to safely serve as a Tor hidden service.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dllthomas 12y agoSure, it's plenty likely they're still "regularly collected"; my intent was simply to add some interesting tangential details, not to assert that they were relevant to the case at hand.