3 ms·
> I respect what the "leakers" did (transparency is good) What? You're not being serious are you? Are you actually saying that no one should have any sort of p
by madeofpalk 12y ago
> I respect what the "leakers" did (transparency is good)
What? You're not being serious are you? Are you actually saying that no one should have any sort of privacy?
- wcummings 12y agoYeah... radical transparency isn't leaking nudes. That's just breaking the law.
- miguelrochefort 12y agoWhat is good doesn't necessarily correlates with what is legal. I'm totally aware that it's illegal, but that doesn't mean I can't support it.
- wcummings 12y agoIn what was is this good for anyone?
- miguelrochefort 12y agoWere there not any demand for these? Demand alone demonstrates it's good for at least a few people. Generally speaking, transparency makes the world better and more efficient. You might not be able to see what good it does, but the positive effect is certain. Privacy and secrecy is just ignoring the problems. We must see them in order to fix them, and that's why transparency and communication is so important.
- madeofpalk 12y agoI hate to go for the obvious one[1] here but... 'At least a few people' have demand for child porn and enjoy it. Are you saying pedophilia is good? [1] Please tell me which logical fallacy I'm using here
- miguelrochefort 12y agoI was asked if X is "good for anyone". I did not make any statement about the objective value (good or bad) of pedophilia, but I do think it's subjectively (to some people) good. Given an objective question instead of a subjective one, I would have answered differently.
- bane 12y agoWhich part of which celebrity's body did you think needed "fixing"?
- miguelrochefort 12y agoWhat needs "fixing" is the thing for which all the drama is a symptom. Someone can tweet that [some celebrity] was at [some location] at [some time], and little or no drama will occur. We just accept that this knowledge can't remain secret, and that's alright. We should react the same way for all knowledge/data/information, including these pictures. I understand that people react this way because it's "new", but we quickly will get used to it, as these leaks will become the new normal. Transparency just accelerates this shift, which is unavoidable in the long run.
- miguelrochefort 12y agoYes.
- nknighthb 12y agoPost all your accounts and passwords right here, right now, or you are a hypocrite.
- miguelrochefort 12y agoAs long as we rely on secret keys to validate identity, making this information public would be a mistake. The objective of transparency is access to knowledge and truth. By making my private keys public, I give the world the power to claim to be me, which is fraud. This leads to the spreading of false information, which is against what is good. I wish I could share this information with you, but society currently makes it impractical by relying on the expectation that private key identification is reliable. I wouldn't be surprised if it were illegal for me to share such private keys.
- nknighthb 12y agoSo you're a hypocrite and a coward. If you won't practice what you preach, don't expect anyone else to.
- miguelrochefort 12y agoI believe that cocaine should be legal. Does that mean I should snort a line in front of a policeman?
- nknighthb 12y ago"Cocaine should be legal" is distinctly different from "everyone should do cocaine". If you said the latter, then the answer would be yes. You seek to deny everyone privacy. That does mean you should deny yourself privacy. But you won't.