3 ms·
Have we all been duped by the Myers-Briggs test?
- ScottBurson 12y agoTake [for example] the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI), the world’s most popular psychometric test, which is based on Jung’s theory of personality types. The MBTI is based very loosely on Jung's theory -- to the point that it's not at all clear that Jung himself would have endorsed it. Jung described eight types, not 16. Some years ago I read the descriptions of the eight types in Jung's Psychological Types and compared them with the nine types of the Enneagram. Indeed, Jung's descriptions matched up very well with eight of the Enneagram types. (He missed the Three.) The MBTI, by comparison, is a mess. It's hard to say, in many cases, how the MBTI types match up against either Jung's or the Enneagram.
- pfooti 12y agoWell, not "all" of us - people who know about experimental psychology and cognitive science (and statistics even) have known that the MBTI is pretty much pseudoscience and bunk. It's great for post-hoc rationalization of your feelings, and decent for communicating ideas about personality to people, but the actual four-factor with subfactor test is snake oil. Business executives like it because it feels science-y, and business people love metrics, even if those metrics are ultimately meaningless. See also: almost every business "reform" in education.