2 ms·
>That's the basic reason why we have markets. No it isn't. There's no such thing as 'markets' and it's sloppy thinking to believe there is. What we have have i
by TheOtherHobbes 12y ago
>That's the basic reason why we have markets.
No it isn't. There's no such thing as 'markets' and it's sloppy thinking to believe there is. What we have have is a political system that uses a stylised propaganda framework to propagate and reinforce itself - much as the Church did in the middle ages.
Belief in 'markets' as some kind of metaphysical efficient all-but omniscient decision-making entity is central to that, in some segments of the population - just as belief in Church dogma used to be equally pervasive.
The reality from anthropology is that there's nothing inevitable about trade or markets at all. Some cultures don't have any concept of a 'market', or if they do, trade is a peripheral activity, and certainly not used as a tool for centralised decision making.
>you can't dictate to people what they should want or not want, because they won't listen to you.
Which is why advertising is such a huge industry, and all governments use propaganda?
It's actually incredibly easy to dictate what people want. What's hard is creating an educated and informed population capable of original, independent, creative thought and high-quality long-term strategy.
Using the many available tools of persuasion to direct the thinking of a majority of the population isn't difficult at all.
If you believe your culture doesn't do this, it's possible you may not have asked some hard questions about how it works.