6 ms·
To Make Streets Safe, Make Them Dangerous
- hasenj 12y agoI was in Damascus around 6 years ago, and I noticed that most major downtown intersection are basically "shared" roads for cars and pedestrians alike. In my head, I was making a joke about how North Americans should learn "co-existence" from these streets where everyone has equal rights to access the street. I have no stats about accident rates, but it seemed that somehow everyone manages to make it "work out". I don't think this was due to any vision about how to make roads safe ... it was just ad-hoc city planning.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoIt was only a very deliberate and expensive efforts that created car supremacy in America. Drivers who killed walkers were at first tried as murderers, as makes perfect sense. Of course people should be free to walk over public thoroughfares. Only well funded measures created the legal idea that a driver is not in all circumstances responsible for injuries and deaths.
- eru 12y agoShouldn't that be manslaughter? Anyway, I agree with your point. And those does the NYT: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/10/opinion/sunday/is-it-ok-to-kill-cyclists.html?pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/10/opinion/sunday/is-it-ok-to...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- samirmenon 12y agoAccording to the Department of Transportation Commissioner, “the chances of a person being killed is cut in half when you reduce the speed limit of the moving vehicle from 30 to 25.” http://newyork.cbslocal.com/2014/08/09/gov-cuomo-signs-bill-lowering-nyc-speed-limit-to-25-mph/ http://newyork.cbslocal.com/2014/08/09/gov-cuomo-signs-bill-...
- kansface 12y agoIs this because the accidents are avoided or turn non-fatal?
- thrownaway2424 12y agoThis factoid relates the mortality rate for an accident at the given speed. It doesn't assume more or fewer collisions.
- zo1 12y agoWow, really? Sounds like an incredibly dishonest way to twist a simple statistic into suiting your agenda.
- streptomycin 12y agoAnd then we have the other side of the argument which says that speed limits have a small impact on how people drive http://priceonomics.com/is-every-speed-limit-too-low/ http://priceonomics.com/is-every-speed-limit-too-low/
- thrownaway2424 12y agoThe blurb incorrectly cites a real fact. It is the impact speed, not the speed limit, which makes a difference.
- dunmalg 12y agoYep. The flaw in the plan is right there in the quote from a NYC resident: “We live right up by 96th and people are getting killed left and right by cars going too fast". Lowering the speed limit from 30 to 25 has no effect on people who ignore speed limits and drive too fast.
- zo1 12y agoCan someone explain to me why pedestrians are being hit in NYC? Are they wandering onto the roads? Are the cars driving onto the pavement? Are pedestrians stepping in front of cars? Cars running red lights while pedestrians assume that "green" means they can go? I'm honestly curious what sorts of "pedestrian accidents" people have seen in NYC?
- cafard 12y agoI was walking up one of the avenues in Manhattan once, and came to the next intersection. The cross-street had the green light, and no traffic just them. But a van was parked on the corner, obstructing the view. I peered around, saw a car approaching at 30 mph, and shouted "Stop!" just in time to keep some people next to me from stepping out in front of it. I cross against lights quite regularly, if I can see that it is safe. Some people drop the condition.
- omonra 12y agoI just visited Sweden where I learned that cars are not allowed to park 10 meters from the corner. I could be wrong on the 10m (someone on the street just told me when I was parking) - but the idea that cars should not be parked adjacent to the intersection is great.
- cafard 12y agoThere are rules in much or most of the US on distances from corners. They just happen to be violated, a lot. I live in Washington, DC, where one does find signs explicitly setting the distance, but it seems to me from long ago driver's tests that jurisdictions do have a standard distance.
- defen 12y agoThe number one cause is the "left hook". This is when someone is turning left and doesn't notice pedestrians in the crosswalk moving across the street the driver is turning onto. Unless there is a dedicated left-arrow green, these pedestrians almost always have the right of way, but the driver doesn't notice them because they are too focused on the oncoming traffic or other hazards, and completely forget to check. I've attempted a crude ASCII diagram. C is a car with a green light, attempting to turn left, P is a pedestrian walking up | | | | | | ____ ____ --P- ---- ‾‾‾‾ ‾‾‾‾ | |C| | | | | | |
- userbinator 12y agoI've never understood why pedestrians seem to be given the right of way by default in many countries - pedestrians can see cars, stop, and change directions far easier and faster than vice-versa, so this makes for a more dangerous situation. If you slow down the cars to compensate, doesn't that somewhat defeat the purpose of having cars in the first place? As anyone who has experienced the traffic in Beijing probably knows, having a mix of pedestrians, cars, bicycles, and other vehicles of various construction in the same space is not efficient nor particularly safe at all.
- justinator 12y agoI don't own a car, so I don't know this, but does the privilege of right-of-way come in the glove compartment of new cars or something? In all honesty, what are we creating things for? People, or cars? Which one should we be optimizing out shared space for? It's food for thought.
- thrownaway2424 12y agoThe privilege is a subconscious process which springs from having spent a lot of money on the car. One begins to believe one is entitled to things in return. In fact antisocial behavior of drivers is directly proportional to the price of their cars.
- eru 12y agoThat's a good argument against cars, not against pedestrians.
- hsitz 12y ago"If you slow down the cars to compensate, doesn't that somewhat defeat the purpose of having cars in the first place?" Hmm, well, requiring cars to give way means that they're less likely to kill someone. Which is kind of the point, outweighs slowing cars down a smidgen. Although pedestrians have right of way it's only an insane pedestrian who would rely on that to stay safe: whether they have right of way or not, pedestrians need to be fully aware of what cars are doing.
- sentientmachine 12y agoIn some sleepy town centers like near Portland maine they put aggressive cobblestones on a main road and the gigantic flower pots, park benches and sidewalks invade the street to a point that makes it inhospitable to cars so much so that the cars are limited to the gawker sight seers who don't know where they are. And those cars that do attempt passage get their teeth and windshield tested for hairline cracks. Ai self driving cars are the only viable solution to the humans killing humans with metal boxes on wheels problem.
- ANH 12y agoI recently drove from my home near DC to Manhattan and back. Exiting the Lincoln Tunnel and heading north, my expectations of "normal" traffic behavior were shattered. I wondered why there aren't bodies littering the streets and hulking wrecks of naive visitors' cars abandoned, leaking, everywhere. It was truly mind-expanding. NYC pedestrian deaths are on the rise, says Google. Meanwhile, I look out my window as I type this and see the suburban road adjacent to my group of homes being resurfaced. It's a beautiful expanse of asphalt they're laying down. It's smooooove, and fast. The neighborhood toddlers want to cross that road, and parents have trouble explaining to them that this road in sight of their homes is just too dangerous. We live in a town renowned for its planning and quality of life. I don't really have a point, but something is obviously amiss.
- wozniacki 12y agoCommonsense dictates that you would have more people on foot rather than in their cars ( especially single-occupant driving cases ) if cities actually paid attention to the plight of persons on foot, on sidewalks. It has to be said that I am uniquely referring to cities like SF known for their less than splendid sidewalk conditions. I am discounting the fact that SF is quite hilly and thus not very conducive for walking, unlike other flatter cities. SF is notorious for its grubby, thrash-discharged, excrement-laden and generally deplorable sidewalks. Just this week : http://sfist.com/attachments/SFist_Jay/poop-map.jpg http://sfist.com/attachments/SFist_Jay/poop-map.jpg [1] Anyone familiar with SF knows that whether you are on the sidewalks abutting the San Francisco Museum and Historical Society and right next to an upscale mall or in seedier parts of Inner/Outer Mission, you can never take a pleasant walk for granted. Prominent sidewalks are openly defecated on. Casual violence of vagrants and the professionally-homeless is quite common. Entire sections of neighborhoods are poorly-lit, with dodgy surfaces to boot. All this not even accounting for the unenthusiastically enforced sit-lie ordinances [2], a thriving homeless industrial complex supported by the city's SROs and rising crime in parts of the city [3] This irks even otherwise civic minded, forward-thinking residents who have all but given up on the city's frowziness and its celebration of the unhygienic and unsanitary. I think there is a strong Well that is SF for you. If you don't like it, go live in Marin ethos prevalent here (and in other cities like SF). And that is not one bit helpful. [1] http://sfist.com/2014/09/03/photo_du_jour_poop_map.php http://sfist.com/2014/09/03/photo_du_jour_poop_map.php [2] http://www.sfgate.com/news/article/Sit-lie-law-primarily-enforced-in-Haight-3763521.php http://www.sfgate.com/news/article/Sit-lie-law-primarily-enf... [3] http://www.sfgate.com/default/article/Duboce-Triangle-neighborhood-getting-scary-with-5706948.php#photo-6764035 http://www.sfgate.com/default/article/Duboce-Triangle-neighb... edit:rewording
- Tiktaalik 12y agoIncreasingly I think cars are the core problem. We need to decrease car use much like we have with smoking. It's just not healthy for our society. They're too dangerous. There's many very valid uses for cars, but most people shouldn't need to use them every day and we should be building cities and towns designed such that you rarely if ever need to use a car.
- johndevor 12y agoWhile I think your statement may be hyperbole, I do agree that bicycles would help. In particular, I'm very hopeful to see more electric bicycles on the streets soon.
- Tiktaalik 12y agoEven if bicycles didn't exist I'd feel the same way. Why not walk? We can build trains for short and long distances. Cars are only necessary because we've made it so.
- raarts 12y agoBackground: I am Dutch, in my fifties and recently moved to the US. Mondermans ideas are only implemented in a very limited part of the Netherlands: only in one of the 12 provinces, and only in about hundred locations. And this is one of the least inhabited provinces.. So, the fact that the Netherlands has a 60% lower fatality rate can absolutely not be attributed to just his work. In my personal view the real causes are: - mandatory traffic lessons in elementary school - standards for drivers licenses are much higher - kids must be 18 to get a license - less big cars - smart road design, more lighting, better road quality - narrower roads with more variety make drivers more careful, especially wrt bikers - slower traffic must keep right on highways - maximum speed for trucks is 15mph lower than other cars - much attention to traffic safety everywhere - stricter traffic laws and enforcement So even though Monderman was on to something, many more things are needed, to keep the stupid and irresponsible from ruining lives.
- Swizec 12y agoIt is terrifying to me as a European how easy it is to get a driver's license in the US. Everything I hear from friends beggars belief. No wonder speed limits have to be kept annoyingly low everywhere. I recently drove on some mountain roads in Californias[1] where I could safely drive 2x above the posted speed limit most of the time. Driving as slowly as the rules wanted would be no fun at all. And, naturally, I will never understand why people are allowed to operate 2 tonne death machines before they are allowed to look at tits. [1] the speed limit was 35mph, in the Alps we'd have the speed limit set at 55mph and the road would be about half the width with cliffs on each side right next to the road (no shoulder, just railings or even just stone pillars every few meters). For example: http://irena.blog.siol.net/files/2009/02/cesta.jpg http://irena.blog.siol.net/files/2009/02/cesta.jpg
- joshAg 12y agoWere those posted limits on white or yellow signs? Just in case there's a cultural barrier (like right turn on red) you know the yellow signs are not mandatory in CA, right?
- 12y ago
- martingordon 12y agoI don't know what percentage of cars on New York City streets are cabs, or how many deaths are caused by taxis, but could a potential solution be to raise the slow-speed fare to incentivize drivers to slow down? A cab driver makes $0.50 per 1/5 of a mile if going over 12 mph or $0.50 per minute if going under 12 mph. The average speed of a taxi hovers around 13 mph[1], but I bet most cab drivers think its higher, meaning they think they make more by getting to their destination quickly (e.g., if they think they average 15 mph, they think they're making $37.50/hour instead of $30 using the timed rate). Suppose the slow-fare rate was raised to $1-$2? Would that help reduce cab-involved accidents (at the expense of longer cab rides)? Further, introducing traffic signal patterns with dedicated turning periods would help a lot. Without fail, I get dirty looks daily from drivers turning onto a street I'm crossing because I'm not scampering out of their way, despite having the right of way (even still, more pedestrians were killed in 2010 when crossing with the signal than against it[2]). I've been fortunate to never been hit, but it is a significant problem. [1]: http://iquantny.tumblr.com/post/93845043909/quantifying-the-best-and-worst-times-of-day-to-hit-the http://iquantny.tumblr.com/post/93845043909/quantifying-the-... [2]: http://www.villagevoice.com/2014-02-05/news/nyc-pedestrian-deaths/2/ http://www.villagevoice.com/2014-02-05/news/nyc-pedestrian-d...
- Theodores 12y agoA lot of traffic is derived from people just looking for somewhere to park. In parts of London people will drive around a dozen streets just looking for that elusive parking space hoping they will catch someone just leaving. This driving is seriously anti-social. Yet planners see this as traffic to accomodate. We also have one way systems to steer this flow of 'traffic' around so that it 'flows'. This means that even more traffic is generated. People just drive round and round. The distance seems absurd if you cycle and obey the signs yet motorists just go with it. It might be much better if we thought again about that and allowed for natural congestion. I could build a spare room in the street, it would not take long though for the council to tear down that extra bedroom, studio or whatever it was that I built. Yet I could buy a £200 car, pay a similar sum in tax and park right outside my door to leave the £200 heap there in perpetuity just so long as I paid the tax, which is a fraction of a month's rent for a room. Why do we have it so motorists have a god given right to park on the streets? We need to think whether we need our streets walled in by tin boxes. Fixing this is easy, we make it so that you cannot park within a distance of a junction, whether that be a junction on to a big road or a side street. Then we increase that distance year by year. In so doing we remove the tin boxes and those looking for that elusive parking space. We could then get back to natural streets where you can drive/ride/walk safely.
- twic 12y agoReminds me of a situation in Brighton, where the council is forcing people to move bike sheds from their own front gardens, while allowing cars to continue to be parked willy-nilly. As a journalist writes [1]: I suppose it depends on how you view a street scene. A small shed is, for me, considerably less intrusive than a parked car. And yet the residential streets of Withdean are full of cars. But that’s seen as normal. Bike stores are not. More anomalous still is the fact that if you have a sufficiently big front garden and don’t live in a conservation area you can, in most circumstances, turn that garden into a driveway to leave your car, without the need for without planning permission. There are conditions on using water-permeable materials to avoid cumulative flood risks, but it’s fairly straightforward. I don’t know about you, but when if comes to local impact I’d say a driveway containing a Humvee (or even something smaller) might be slightly more significant than a discreet bike shed. [1] http://www.theguardian.com/environment/bike-blog/2014/aug/01/brighton-green-council-crackdown-cycle-stores-barriers-cycling http://www.theguardian.com/environment/bike-blog/2014/aug/01...
- BrandonMarc 12y agoI once read about a city in Europe - maybe it's the one in the article - which ripped out half of the signs along the roads, and found the drivers paid much closer attention and drove more carefully. I heard of another city in England which removed its street lights (and didn't install stop signs / roundabouts) with the same result. It's fascinating to look at some 3rd world locations, where there are far fewer rules, and many modes of transport sharing the same street. This YouTube video really drives the point home. Scooters, walkers (some heavy laden), and cars all chaotically (at first glance) going every direction on a piece of asphalt. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eC4BN9kInXg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eC4BN9kInXg As Richard Fernandez says, look closer ... watch a few times ... and a few basic rules pop out. http://fallbackbelmont.blogspot.com/2006/12/into-heart-of-chaos.html http://fallbackbelmont.blogspot.com/2006/12/into-heart-of-ch... As the veteran of many a Third World traffic jam, I think the vehicular flow situation is a little more complex than Economics with a Face suggests. But he may be correct in thinking that under certain circumstances and in particular cultures fewer rules or perhaps the appropriate rules make more sense than the overly regulated forms the First World is used to. It reminds me of that old Artificial Life program "Boids", which implemented just 3 very basic rules, and from this produced very organic flocking and obstacle-avoidance behaviors. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boids http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boids https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GUkjC-69vaw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GUkjC-69vaw
- twic 12y agoThis business about taking out the road signs and so on is called "naked streets", and is part of a broader "shared space" theory. It is far from settled that it is a helpful tool in any situations, let alone all situations. We have to be very careful in interpreting the outcomes of experimental applications of naked streets (or other large interventions). Firstly, because of a Hawthorne effect - when a road is changed, drivers become more cautious because it's different, so safety improves, whether or not the change itself improves safety. Secondly, because it's a change that is very context-specific; naked streets seem to work well if the motor traffic level is intrinsically (or is engineered to be) low, but that doesn't mean they're a good way to handle a flow at a higher level. The English example you may be thinking of was Exhibition Road, in Kensington, London. This rather long blog post takes a good look at it: http://aseasyasridingabike.wordpress.com/2013/01/21/lessons-from-exhibition-road/ http://aseasyasridingabike.wordpress.com/2013/01/21/lessons-...