3 ms·
The most effective way to influence this as a consumer is 1) Don't buy these products (in any form) 2) Do buy products from people who are doing things differ
by ska 12y ago
The most effective way to influence this as a consumer is
1) Don't buy these products (in any form)
2) Do buy products from people who are doing things differently (in ways you approve of) even if very expensive.
Vegetarians do #1, but not #2 - which doesn't encourage a change in practice at all, just a reduction of amounts.
It can be hard to stick to #2 when faced with a $20 roasting chicken, but that's the nature of this sort of change.
editing additions (above is unchanged) because I was obviously not clear enough.
I was responding to a post asking what can be done to change a market like that, not saying anything about the choice of being vegetarian itself.
If you decide to become vegetarian for whatever reasons, that is a market signal. However, it is not a market signal to change how meat is being processed, it is a market signal to reduce how much is being produced under any method.
DeusExMachina's point is fair, eggs are a valid (for some versions of "vegetarian" [1]. The rest of his comment is exactly the same as what I'm saying - by participating in the market but choosing to buy products that are more expensive because of the way they are raised, you are signalling a value for that practice. This is much more effective for change in how that market produces goods than simply not participating.
So to be clear - I'm not making a value judgment on choosing to be a vegetarian, I'm just pointing out something fairly obivous - that not participating in a market is not a very effective way of changing how that market produces things.
[1] in my lexicon vegetarians don't eat cheese or eggs either, which is different from vegan's who wouldn't eat honey for example - but that's not really important
- DeusExMachina 12y agoI don't really understand your comment about vegetarians not doing #2. First, vegetarians don't buy meat, so yes, they don't do #2 because that's not something they would do. No matter how better animals are treated, vegetarians don't eat meat by definition. Second, it's not even true that they don't buy more expensive products. I'm vegetarian (not vegan) so I eat eggs, but only if they are biological and from free range chickens. Yes, they cost more, but vegetarians don't buy only on cost.
- jmulho 12y ago> but only if they are biological... Aren't all eggs biological?
- dragonwriter 12y agoThe French term for "organic" as used in "organic food" or "organic farming" is "biologique", which in its more general use translates to "biological" in English. So I suspect that the intended meaning is "organic" in the "organic food" sense (I've occasionally seen this in English, not sure if it's a standard use from a different English speaking context then I'm used to or a non-standard use.) But, yes, all eggs are both "biological" and "organic" in the more general sense of those words.
- mikestew 12y agoIf everyone quit eating meat, I would assume there would be market research into why that happened. Change would then occur. Now, of course that's never going to happen but on the other hand I don't think buying $20 chickens is in a practical sense going to do much, either. But one of the reasons I'm a vegetarian is not to effect change (because it probably won't) but to simply not participate. I choose not to pay people to torture animals for me by proxy. It's all philosophical differences, IMO. Fact remains that there are far more people out there that are concerned about saving fifty cents on their next roaster. But choosing not to play is as valid a reason as any, even if it's just so one can sleep better at night.
- ska 12y agoI've responded to most of this in the original comment, but to one particular point. I think you are exactly wrong about the effect of buying the expensive version of something early on if it meets your needs. I think of this as necessary but not sufficient to change. Typically these sorts chickens, to stay with the example, are expensive because they are being raised in small numbers, without the advantages of scale and the sort of research that goes int the big producers. Sometimes the farmers themselves haven't really worked out how to do this as well as they can yet, too. If some people who can afford to don't choose to support these people at the price that makes it viable for them, then it will never get past this point, period. If enough people support it though, the interest will be noted, the scale will start to get better, and the price will come down a bit. Not, obviously, to the levels of the price-is-everything practice, but cheaper. Much like some tech will never really get off the ground without early adopters supporting it.
- Xodarap 12y ago> I'm just pointing out something fairly obivous - that not participating in a market is not a very effective way of changing how that market produces things. Everyone participates in the market for buying food. There's probably someone out there who has the very narrow goal of changing how meat (and only meat) is produced, but for everyone else this is a strawman argument. We want to change food production, and overpaying for similar products is obviously going to be less of a signal than larger dietary changes.
- ska 12y agoThis thread is dead now, but a quick response - it's not (just) less of a signal, it is a very different signal, which is important. I wasn't addressing at all the issue of whether some group of people want to get rid of a product entirely which I had hoped was clear. "The market for food" is a very broad category and contains many markets.