3 ms·
That is no necessarily a bad thing though. When you are designing a bridge, you had better not be deriving equations. My grandfather was an flight repair manage
by Balgair 12y ago
That is no necessarily a bad thing though. When you are designing a bridge, you had better not be deriving equations. My grandfather was an flight repair manager. He always had the tables up on the walls for the guys, not even equations. His thinking was that if you remembered the torque on the wheel brakes, you could also mis-remember them. Therefore, 'Never remember anything!' was the motto. I can only assume this maxim came about after a very scary incident. This also applied to much engineering and design. Yes, it is sad to see and hear about minds gone to 'waste', but it is very necessary for life to not go to waste.
- WalterBright 12y agoIn my experience, when people used formulas with no understanding of where those formulas came from, nor what assumptions underlaid them, they misapplied them. All book formulas are based on models, which have limitations. Would you really want formula pluggers designing life critical systems? Not me. Book values, however, provide valuable feedback on whether an answer is correct or not. While the book may not provide the right formula for the job, it often provides formulas that "bracket" the right answer, and so can be used as a reasonableness check. A central part of engineering design are reasonableness checks.
- Balgair 12y agoTo speak on civil engineering, of which I have only observed from the outside: They do use formulas and calculate things, but they do NOT recalculate the constants, even though they may be derived each time. The tensile strength for steel is just assumed, from what I can tell, even though it falls out of tests and formulas itself. In fact, I would trust the computer better than the deriver. The guy that just plugs it in, in a proven system, is safer to my ears. The guy that recalculates everytime is bound to have false positives and negatives and whatnot in the calculations. A good aphorism is 'A man that has one watch knows the time, a man with 2 is never sure.' I do agree on the standard values though, it does give a ball park, and that is valuable. One thing to keep in mind is that the brain power required to do all these calculations simply does not exist. Physicists typically are less then 5% of a undergraduate class, I'd actually argue for less, but I haven't a source. These are the guys that can run the calculations through everytime. However, the need for the various jobs is FAR outstripped by the output. Hence you get engineering and the margin of safety, as we know you can't get the proper people in there, but you have to get someone to check at least something otherwise the people will just make it regardless of safety. And then boom, bob's your uncle, you get the casualty differences between Chinese earthquakes and the 6er in Napa. Yes, it's not much, but it's better than nothing.