4 ms·
Fascinating read, and as amazing as email is, the OP manages to still make me realize how much I take it for granted: > So I think we need totally new approach
by danso 12y ago
Fascinating read, and as amazing as email is, the OP manages to still make me realize how much I take it for granted:
> So I think we need totally new approaches. The first idea people have is to make sending email cost money, but that sucks for several reasons; most obviously - free global communication is IMHO one of humanities greatest achievements, right up there with putting a man on the moon. Someone from rural China can send me a message within seconds, for free, and I can reply, for free! Think about that for a second.
- nsns 12y agoSomeone from rural China can send me a message within seconds, for free, and I can reply, for free! Yeah, you both "only" need some machine that can go online, an internet connection, electricity, the required technical knowledge, and to (implicitly) agree to your personal data getting harvested... otherwise it's "free".
- scrollaway 12y agoI am willing to give you £50 in cash for free as long as you come pick it up at my place in Sweden. This offer is only available for you alone and in person. Are you interested? Because I'd really like to know how your pedantic definition of "free" works out for you when it's obvious that things that require infrastructure (such as online communications, or traveling to a different country)... require infrastructure. (TLDR: If you don't find it amazing that with a very small indirect investment we can actually communicate with people anywhere in the world for free, you and I need to have a long chat about being spoiled.)
- meepmorp 12y agoWell, you could mail the money. Using the national postal systems that exist in both countries that have established means of transferring mail long distances. Same as the farmer in rural China could send a message to the Google engineer. It costs money, yes, but if you're sending a one off message and it's not time citical, it's not unreasonable to say that sending the message via email is cheaper overall. Edit: which isn't to say that communication via the Internet isn't really cool, just that it's not actually free, nor would it necessarily be cheaper than sending a message via other means, depending on the circumstances.
- scrollaway 12y agoYou missed the critical "within seconds" in the original message. Email is near-instantaneous. Are we seriously debating the merits of email over snail-mail on hacker news? I hope this is merely people enjoying being thick and provocative, because the alternative is that there's some massive bubble-blindness going on right now.
- meepmorp 12y agoAnd I was considering nsns' point about how the costs associated with sending email aren't nonexistent, and how, given a certain set of concerns and constraints, might be higher than other means. I also thought your £50 example was a bit silly. Of course infrastructure costs money. There's means of communicating and delivering things like money that use infrastructure that require a far lower initial investment for a user, and that might be a better deal for that user, circumstances dependent. And not all communications need to be near-instantaneous.
- scrollaway 12y ago> the costs associated with sending email aren't nonexistent > Of course infrastructure costs money. You do realize you're.. well, you're not contradicting yourself, but on the one hand you agree it's obvious and on the other hand you insist it must be pointed out. My example about money was just that. I could use Western Union or a bank transfer. Those things also have non-nonexistent (sic) costs. If you start pointing out everywhere that "Oh but there's this cost you didn't think about!", you won't be done by next week. You know all those libraries that let you check out books for zero cost? Reading those books requires education, which in turn is no free (No matter how much you wish to contradict that statement, the road you've taken requires you to admit to an unending set of cost upon cost which you don't think about in your day to day life). You live in a society which expects you to have access to certain things. In the case you can't, there usually is infrastructure in place to help you out at little to no cost. So again, please, just take this in: You can communicate with people at the other end of the globe. For free. This is not a legal forum and we don't need asterisks everywhere.
- angersock 12y agoYep. Pretty amazing, isn't it?
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoI remember using dial-up to connect to my college's unix system. I fired up the email client (mail? mailx?) and was hesitant for a moment to send an email to England. I thought back to my days using BBS's and worrying about dialing out to per minute charges. I just couldn't believe I could email anyone in the world for free using smtp email. Obviously, both of us need computers, email accounts, network access, etc but there's no per region metering or anything. The cost of sending an email to someone sitting 10 feet from me or 10,000 miles from me is exactly the same. Mike's right, this is revolutionary.
- _delirium 12y agoIn the actual BBS days, I don't recall that being a common point of confusion, oddly enough. I dialed up to local BBSs, and it was obvious where I was dialing because I actually entered the digits, and the modem audibly dialed them. Then sometimes I would correspond with people in other states or countries, through FidoNet echoes or mail. But it was clear that I wasn't dialing them to do so. I transmitted my message to my local BBS, and the BBS relayed my message onwards. I'm not sure at the time I entirely understood what mechanism the BBS used to do so, but I knew that I wasn't myself dialing Norway or Germany to do it, nor paying any kind of destination-based charge. I even played some multi-country multiplayer door games, all for free. So once I got an internet account, it didn't seem too magical!