3 ms·
This only works for certain classes. You can't study history without memorizing things.
by sp332 12y ago
This only works for certain classes. You can't study history without memorizing things.
- nine_k 12y agoMemorizing things certainly helps in every discipline. Why having to look things up makes a bad historian, but not a bad physicist?
- WalterBright 12y agoIf you work with things a lot, you wind up memorizing them without any particular effort to do so.
- sp332 12y agoPhysics can be more abstract. E=MC^2 regardless of exactly how fast C is. You should have a general idea that "mass and energy are interchangeable", but you can look up the exact equation, and then look up the value of C.
- makmanalp 12y agoTo some extent. History can be more focused on knowing concepts than factoids and dates. "Explain the role the industrial revolution played in the rise of the British Empire" is a way better exam question than "When was the British Empire founded?".
- baddox 12y agoBoth of those questions require memorization.
- triplesec 12y agoeverything requires memory. You are being obstreperous. Memory alone against considered, analyical skills is the issue here.
- afafsd 12y agoIf you want to define the debate in that way then sure, memory plus considered analytical skills is better than memory without analytical skills, but I don't think anyone was questioning that. People are more likely to question the importance of memorising things (because it's "boring") than of considered analytical skills. One question that pops into my mind: can considered analytical skills actually be taught? I'm not sure they really can, they might be just plain old innate, in which case perhaps classes should focus on the thing that can be taught, which is stuff.
- WalterBright 12y ago> can considered analytical skills actually be taught? Yup. I came out of college far better at that than going in.
- baddox 12y agoI'm being serious. You need to memorize a lot more facts to answer those "why" questions than you do do answer what year some war started.
- WalterBright 12y agoThis is incorrect. The interesting thing about history is not what/when, but why. Asking exam questions like "Why did Caesar's conquest of England fail, and what could he have done differently?" and "Why did the American Revolution not result in a reign of terror?" are much better.
- baddox 12y agoAnd both of those "why" questions require memorization.
- WalterBright 12y agoDepends. If the "why" was covered in the class material, then probably you're expected to memorize/regurgitate it. If not, if only the facts were covered, then it takes some thinking skills to select and distill the facts into a "why" narrative. There also is no one "why", it's subjective. For example, what were "Hitler's biggest mistakes"? Ask 5 historians, and you'll get 5 different answers. A grade would be based on how well and insightfully you justified your answer.
- sbilstein 12y agoTo formulate a "why" answer you need the context, which requires some degree of memorization of previous events. You can't derive the events from first principles, but you must derive your conclusion from some knowledge.
- WalterBright 12y agoYou still have to study. You just don't have to memorize.
- sbilstein 12y agoTo formulate a "why" answer you need the context, which requires some degree of memorization of previous events. You can't derive the events from first principles, but you must derive your conclusion from some knowledge.