2 ms·
>I was fortunate in winding up at Caltech, which had a policy of open book / open note exams There is a widespread miscoception that openbook exams are somehow
by dominotw 12y ago
>I was fortunate in winding up at Caltech, which had a policy of open book / open note exams
There is a widespread miscoception that openbook exams are somehow more better and forward thinking. You don't have memorize the exact formula but you still have to memorize where that formula is, one is just memorizing different kind of information.
Learning is about learning how to learn a particular subject . A good exam should test you on weather or not you can pick up/learn a new (slightly advanced) topic on your own based on your current knowledge. It should test you on what you can learn not on what you have already learnt. Open book exams don't address this fundamental flaw.
- WalterBright 12y ago> you still have to memorize where that formula is I don't recall a single exam question that was merely "plug the numbers into a formula and write down the answer" which is what you seem to be implying.
- dominotw 12y agoWhat were you using open book for?
- WalterBright 12y agoThe same thing you'd use open book for on homework problems. Open book / open note changed the focus of trolling (studying) for exams. Instead of using flash cards to memorize formulas, one made sure one understood all of the homework solutions and previous exam solutions, A-Z. Many of the formulas were far more complex than one could conveniently memorize anyway, such as the equations for jet turbine performance. And like I mentioned, none of the exam questions required mere formula plugging or had answers one could pluck out of the notes or book.
- pwnna 12y ago> It should test you on what you can learn not on what you have already learnt. I'm not sure if this is the right approach, either, especially when materials get harder. It sometimes takes a lecture or two to fully teach a concept. You don't usually have that kind of time when you write an exam. What I really enjoyed are my fluid dynamics exam. We learned all the theories in class + a handful of example scenarios. The exams had radically different scenarios than what we are used to (although if you look through it, it's the same and you apply the same principles to solve them). I don't know if that's the right approach either, but it was fun to think about.