2 ms·
"Yes - they can be distributed separately, and sometimes are," I'd observe, unless I'm way, way more out of the music loop than I realize, that the correct ter
by jerf 12y ago
"Yes - they can be distributed separately, and sometimes are,"
I'd observe, unless I'm way, way more out of the music loop than I realize, that the correct terms are that they are almost always things that can be distributed separately, and very few "albums" have more than a faint trace of coherence between the songs. That is, sure, an album might alternate "upbeat" and "downer" songs or do some other basic management beyond "random ordering", but that's usually the top end of coherence. Contrast with The Wall or something, where it really is difficult to pick out separate tracks, excepting the ones that Pink Floyd deliberately made separable so some part of it could be played on the radio.
And really, people, let's stop trying to pick apart the word "force" as if several people up thread haven't been extremely clear what they mean by the term. "Forced bundling" is a perfectly reasonable use of the term, and trying to equivocate with other sorts of force is, well, that fallacy I named.
- krapp 12y ago>I'd observe, unless I'm way, way more out of the music loop than I realize, that the correct terms are that they are almost always things that can be distributed separately, and very few "albums" have more than a faint trace of coherence between the songs. Who said that an album has to be coherent, or follow a narrative flow, for the distribution model to be justified? That's an entirely subjective way of seeing it - not invalid, but also not relevant to the question. There are probably plenty of people who would consider most of The Wall to be crap as well - and that coherence to be rambling nonsense (note: I loved the Wall, but I also really liked the Division Bell so what do I know?). My point is, there's nothing 'broken' about the model, even if there may be more convenient models available.