4 ms·
With Amazon, Bezos is deferring that profit-producing, investor-rewarding day almost indefinitely into the future. This prompts the suggestion that Amazon is th
by AndrewKemendo 12y ago
With Amazon, Bezos is deferring that profit-producing, investor-rewarding day almost indefinitely into the future. This prompts the suggestion that Amazon is the world’s biggest ‘lifestyle business’ – Bezos is running it for fun, not to deliver economic returns to shareholders, at least not any time soon.
Sorry but that is ridiculous. Look at the stock price for Amazon. Anyone who has invested in Amazon has seen an amazing unprecedented ride upward, institutional benefiting the most.
I also take umbrage with the idea that Bezos is running Amazon for "fun" as though it is frivolous. Bezos seems to have a grand vision and that is not something that matches with the ridiculously short term and arguably irresponsible thinking of the vast majority of investors.
We collectively need to get away from the idea that the only valid fiduciary duty for a for-profit organization is to make profit for their shareholders instead of creating value for humanity.[1]
[1] This is refuting the broader point that Benedict Evans is making, and does not necessarily apply to Amazon perfectly.
- redthrowaway 12y agoAt no point was anyone suggesting that the purpose of Amazon is to tickle Bezos' fancy, and it would require a painfully literal reading of the article in order to think that's what the author was doing.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoPerhaps I am dense but how else could you possibly interpret the quote that I cited? Suggesting - even if lightly - that Bezos is running Amazon for "fun" and as a "lifestyle business", especially in the light of the great analysis done above it, indicates that the author looks at any business that has very long term goals as inferior to those who are solely focused on turning profits back to shareholders.
- benedictevans 12y agoTo paraphrase, "this prompts the suggestion that X is the case. However, it is not". It's a rhetorical question.
- hnnewguy 12y ago>Anyone who has invested in Amazon has seen an amazing unprecedented ride upward Only if they sell to realize those gains, and that can only occur if they can find a buyer who has an even greater expectation of profit in the future. This concept seems to elude people, but the value of a company that never makes a profit is precisely $0.
- mseebach 12y agoAmazon makes a profit, it just invests all of it in itself, returning you a more valuable stock instead of a dividend. Investors let them do it because the investment made with the profit is worth more than the cash would be. Even with all that, the value of a company that doesn't turn a profit isn't 0, it's the value of it's assets, and Amazon has a lot of those.
- hnnewguy 12y ago>the value of a company that doesn't turn a profit isn't 0, it's the value of it's assets Touche. They also have liabilities. I suppose we could be even more precise and say the price is $0 above the expected value of the net assets at the time of liquidation. But my point stands.
- 1stop 12y agoWell go and try a hostile take over of amazon where you purchase 100% of the stocks for $1. Given it's worth $0, $1 is infinitely more than they are expecting. Or admit that your point is absurd.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoThis concept seems to elude people, but the value of a company that never makes a profit is precisely $0. As others have stated profits = revenue - expenses. In this case they are positive on the right hand, even if slightly, so they are in fact making profits. Your time horizon is also wrong and assumes that there needs to be a singular point where the top level goal becomes making profit, rather than profit being a byproduct of a top level goal of adding value. I also disagree with your assertion that value comes solely from profit.
- MaysonL 12y agoAmazon is making substantial profit, but not taxable profit: it takes the profit in warehouses rather than cash.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- QuantumChaos 12y agoYou've contradicted yourself there. If Amazon's stock price is doing well, this is evidence that they are creating value for shareholders.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoThat was exactly my point. The latter portion of the post was not specifically applicable to Amazon, but was refuting the author's point of view.
- QuantumChaos 12y agooh ok, two separate issue then I guess.
- prostoalex 12y ago> We collectively need to get away from the idea that the only valid fiduciary duty for a for-profit organization is to make profit for their shareholders instead of creating value for humanity. The idea is not new, and conglomerates have been around for quite a bit now, with most prominent example being Berkshire Hathaway. Take the profits of a textile company, reinvest them in a new line of business, take the profits from that line of business, reinvest it into a new one.