3 ms·
I may be about to say something stupid, but couldn't we preemptively cut out the tusks from wild elephants so that there would be no point in poaching them? Ar
by bambax 12y ago
I may be about to say something stupid, but couldn't we preemptively cut out the tusks from wild elephants so that there would be no point in poaching them?
Are tusks necessary for elephants to cut through the bush? I see elephants who don't have tusks in documentaries all the time, so I'm wondering.
And even if tusks are necessary, maybe we could replace the originals with prosthesis (of a different color) -- certainly not an easy task on a wild elephant, but worth a try maybe??
Or just somehow ruin the tusks while leaving them in place? Scratch them, turn them in a different color, something?
- masklinn 12y ago> I may be about to say something stupid, but couldn't we preemptively cut out the tusks from wild elephants so that there would be no point in poaching them? De-horning programs were started for rhinos in the 90s following that idea, which theoretically held up (despite being a risk to the animal, you have to put him to sleep which may kill him, and de-horning remains traumatic). De-horned rhinos still got poached: http://www.savetherhino.org/rhino_info/issues_for_debate/de-horning http://www.savetherhino.org/rhino_info/issues_for_debate/de-... There's little reason to believe elephants would fare better, sadly. > Are tusks necessary for elephants to cut through the bush? They're for battle (defence against predators animals as well as combats between males, in these case they also act as "bumpers" to protect the fragile trunk), and hard tasks: the trunk handles precision stuff, the tusks are used to move crap out of the way, dig for water or roots, removing bark from trees. They're not technically necessary, although tuskless elephants are less fit.
- bambax 12y agoMany thanks for this answer and link; very enlightening. If I understand the article correctly, it seems de-horned rhinos are poached mostly because poachers don't see the rhino has lost its horns, and they kill it then because 1) they're furious when they find out 2) they don't want to waste more time hunting it again If this is true it would probably be less of a problem for elephants as their tusks (or absence thereof) are more visible. It still sounds like a horrible procedure, but I don't think trying to curb demand will ever be effective -- or maybe in the very long run, when there are no elephants left.