3 ms·
> So, for Bob's case, (....) so that our estimator Z = g(X_1, X_2, X_3) = 1 - (1/3) (X_1 + X_2 + X_3) is an unbiased estimator of p. We expected something else?
by kgwgk 12y ago
> So, for Bob's case, (....) so that our estimator Z = g(X_1, X_2, X_3) = 1 - (1/3) (X_1 + X_2 + X_3) is an unbiased estimator of p. We expected something else? This was difficult? (....) For Alice, a different derivation is required.
A different derivation that you tried (I saw your comment appear briefly). You proposed Z=1/N, which is (as before) the maximum-likelihood estimator. And the likelihood function is the same for Alice and for Bob, so it is not surprising that we get the same estimate p=1/3 in both cases. But after "proving" that "again our estimator Z is unbiased" I guess you noticed that this was not in fact correct. Did you expect something else? What was the difficulty?
> My point is that from Kolmogorov we have some rock solid foundations for probability and, then, do not have to consider either frequentism or Bayesianism.
Both are based on probability, how is probability going to replace them?
> So, students struggling over frequentism or Bayesianism can relax and just f'get about these two.
Sure, they can avoid thinking about the different approaches to inference... and just do it in the frequentist way. Assuming that the unknown parameter is fixed, that the estimator is a random variable, that the criteria to select an estimator are the unbiasedness, consistency or asymptotic distribution... all of these are frequentist considerations (even if you say that you "do not have to consider either frequentism or Bayesianism").
You never answered my questions about Alice and Bob getting different interval estimates (even though the outcome of their experiments is identical and their model for the loaded coin as well). We've seen that they agree on their (MLE) point estimate, but their confidence intervals will be different.
I imagine you accept the frequentist idea of confidence intervals, and agree that they will be different because the distribution of potential experiment outcomes is different.
Do you think that Alice and Bob can get different conclusions from the same model and the same data?
Carol performs another experiment. She starts by rolling a die to see if she'll do it like Alice (even) or like Bob (odd). So with 50% probability she will throw the loaded coin 3 times and with 50% probability she will do it until she gets a tail. She gets 5 on the die, she throws the loaded coin three times and gets 'HTH'. How will you select your estimator for p? Do you use the results you obtained for Bob? Do you repeat you analysis considering the mixture of both experiments?