2 ms·
There should be a sliding scale of apportionment, and a statement of the perspective doing the evaluation (and there is no 'global' perspective). For Q1, it's
by gojomo 17y ago
There should be a sliding scale of apportionment, and a statement of the perspective doing the evaluation (and there is no 'global' perspective).
For Q1, it's fairly easy to say 100% store -- there's an implied warranty their food is fit to eat, and the friend has no special insight or customary duty to double-check (via lab equipment?) the healthfulness of already-warranted food.
For Q2, it could approach more like 50/50 -- and depends on the perspective involved. From the perspective of the driver or victim, it's easy to say 100% car company -- again because the risk flowed through the car company, which had the expertise and commercial duty to sell a safe product.
But between the car company and the original feature developers it depends on their arrangement. If the developers are an outside firm that sold the system as fit for a particular purpose, much or all of the blame then flows to them. If the developers are the car company's in-house employees, the company probably agreed to take on the blame along with the profits, as the company is the coordinator and tester/seller of a multi-person process that failed.
For Q3, again it could vary and be a matter of perspective. From the perspective of the customer, it's 100% the shop, which has taken on responsibility for the benefits and costs generated by its employees in the performance of their duties. (From the customer's perspective, the barista and the shop are one and the same.) For the shop owner, responsibility may be thought to lie with the barista, especially if the rate of mistakes goes beyond typical/achievable levels. Still, as a practical matter of employee morale and labor law, a policy where the barista pays the costs of occasional errors is unlikely. The remedy for excessive errors is change of employees, not compensation for individual mistakes.