5 ms·
I really liked Coral Common Lisp. After I ported the ISI Grapher package to Coral, I gave my Xerox 1108 Lisp Machine to a colleague. Clozure Common Lisp is ver
by mark_l_watson 12y ago
I really liked Coral Common Lisp. After I ported the ISI Grapher package to Coral, I gave my Xerox 1108 Lisp Machine to a colleague.
Clozure Common Lisp is very nice, but for some reason I usually use SBCL (and rarely Franz or clisp). I used SBCL (with QuickLisp) for the last edition of my Common Lisp book, BTW.
If there had been very good free versions of Common Lisp 20+ years ago, then I think the language would be more popular today. I think the same is true of Smalltalk. Today Pharo Smalltalk really is a wonderful programming environment and it is free. In the 1980s and 1990s it was very expensive to get a Smalltalk programming environment.
- _delirium 12y ago> If there had been very good free versions of Common Lisp 20+ years ago, then I think the language would be more popular today. I guess it depends on what you mean by "very good" and how big that "+" is, but weren't there at least two? For people with access to a Unix box (usually via universities, companies, or a shell account), CMUCL was available, typically on SPARC/Solaris, since the mid-80s sometime. And for people running home microcomputers, clisp was freeware on the Atari ST from the late '80s, and released as GPL in 1993, with ports to DOS, Amiga, and Linux.
- rjsw 12y agoKyoto Common Lisp was available in the late-80s, CMUCL on x86 in 1996.
- aidenn0 12y agoI would suspect that most people using SBCL has more to do with momentum than anything. CCL only became available on x86 fairly recently.
- lispm 12y agoEight years ago a 64bit x86 version of OpenMCL (aka CCL) appeared for Linux.
- lispm 12y agoI tend to use Clozure CL most of the time. Clozure CL's compiler is a bit more primitive, but the compiled code is smaller, the compiler is faster, the runtime is much better (better GC) and it has a basic non-GNU-Emacs IDE on the Mac. > f there had been very good free versions of Common Lisp 20+ years ago, then I think the language would be more popular today. This fails to understand a few things. Good versions of Common Lisp did exist 20+ years ago, even free ones. But Common Lisp implementations tend to be complex systems and thus its not easy to to get this financed over a long time. Common Lisp was unpopular between 90s and 2000. A new generation of developers had to rediscover it to revive some of it: SBCL, ECL, ... > Today Pharo Smalltalk really is a wonderful programming environment and it is free. In the 1980s and 1990s it was very expensive to get a Smalltalk programming environment. Common Lisp has many free and good implementations today. If you look at Pharo Smalltalk, it's nice, but it has the same limitations like Squeak and other implementations: it looks and feels non-native. That's because the UI is non-native.
- pjmlp 12y ago> Common Lisp was unpopular between 90s and 2000. A new generation of developers had to rediscover it to revive some of it: SBCL, ECL, ... And they miss so much, because they only get part of what a Common Lisp dev env used to be. Since the good alternatives are the commercial ones, that most nowadays aren't willing to pay for. > If you look at Pharo Smalltalk, it's nice, but it has the same limitations like Squeak and other implementations: it looks and feels non-native. That's because the UI is non-native. Yeah, there is this goal of trying to replicate Smalltalk, the OS, experience, instead of just being another programming language. I think Pharo is moving into the direction of better native integration, though.
- lispm 12y ago> I think Pharo is moving into the direction of better native integration, though. Currently its IDE is looking completely non-native on my Mac. No application on my Mac uses hierarchical windows. Pharo does. Its sub-windows are looking alien. It does not use the menubar like it is supposed to do as a Mac application... and so on.
- pjmlp 12y ago20 years ago, people were still paying for their compilers. Heck, we still are in some areas nowadays, outside what usually gets HN attention. In the 90's SmaltalkWorks price wasn't much different from other tooling. Actually the enterprise was already starting to use Smalltalk. But then Java came out, and everyone jumped ship. Did you know Eclipse started out as Visual Age for Smalltalk?