2 ms·
I... think this articles applies a degree of analysis that the work in question simply doesn't stand up to. I don't mean that as a criticism of Star Trek per se
by jerf 12y ago
I... think this articles applies a degree of analysis that the work in question simply doesn't stand up to. I don't mean that as a criticism of Star Trek per se, just that when you really get down to it, it is a work produced for mass consumption over the course of decades, in several shows, by many many dozen authors, written for the needs of drama to fit into an hour, targeted at a mass audience.
For instance, is the fact that Race = Culture actually a statement that Star Trek is trying to make (on any level you like, cultural, deliberate, accidentally revealing, whatever), or does it reflect the belief of the authors and producers that their audience is not looking for a lot of nuance out of the various races of Star Trek and the viewer's "novelty budget" was already spent just on having lots of different races for the viewer to keep track of? Sure, I'd contend that the last 10 years of TV have shown that TV viewers are able to deal with more than producers in the 60s-90s thought, but most of Star Trek took place in a time where TV was just... simpler. That simplicity can still lead one to conclusions about what simpler thing was chosen, but I don't think it can be used to complain in general about a lack of complexity... if that complexity had been there we probably wouldn't be talking about it because it would have just died, or at least so the producers probably believed.
Oh, there are things you can draw out of the details of Star Trek, but I think a lot more care is needed to ensure that the message is actually something the show is trying to convey, and not something that lives in the constraints of the medium (including its multi-author nature), or the modern mindset of the viewer.
(For instance, in particular, the Sisko example where he masqueraded as a Lieutenant instead of a Captain doesn't stand up to that analysis. Obviously, he expects that everybody in the area knows who all the local captains are, and walking around decorated as a Captain on the Enterprise is going to be a huge problem. The analysis that he didn't do it because he was black doesn't stand up to the fact that nobody except James Kirk, personally, could do it. And not just "a white man", but, James Kirk, personally, whom everybody would know.)