4 ms·
This entire piece throws out conjecture as fact and appears to back none of it up with substance. > By making the Ferengis a race of intergalactic traders with
by noir_lord 12y ago
This entire piece throws out conjecture as fact and appears to back none of it up with substance.
> By making the Ferengis a race of intergalactic traders with oversized appendages and an addiction to “gold-plated latinum,” Star Trek merely updates Jewish stereotypes.
If you read the TNG novels you will find that the Ferengi tourists to earth all head for Wall Street regarding it with something like religious reverence, I suspect though don't claim the Ferengi where meant to embody the end result of a "perfect competition" style of capitalism and the capitalist personalities that you end up with and not a shot at the Jews.
In fact I'd ponder whether his apparently evidence less assumption that the corrupt money grubbing characters where meant to be the Jews shows his own prejudices rather well.
- mhurron 12y agoNovels are not cannon. More importantly, Data referred to them as analogous to the 'Yankee Traders' of the 19th century. It's pretty clear they were not based on Jews.
- leepowers 12y agoAdditionally, the Ferengi were initially conceived as a militaristic enemy, worth of sparring with the Enterprise crew. Their orcish appearance was meant to evoke malevolence, brutishness and aggression - not greed or "Jewishness". It was only later that they were re-imagined as a parody of unfettered capitalism.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Spooky23 12y agoArticles like this always drive me nuts. Adopting some smug position painting a person/institution/other work with an ethnocentric or culturally insensitive brush gives many people license to make ridiculous statements while insulating themselves from critique. After all, if you disagree, you must be some bigoted monster. Like any other performance art, TV reflects the zeitgeist of the society at large. 1960's TV in particular had to fit in a prime-time slot of ONE of three television networks -- you needed to appeal to a mass audience. I think Star Trek is a show that has to be viewed through the lens of its time. For example, the fact that there was a black woman prominently featured on a major network show in a positive way was a huge step forward in a way that is difficult for many to appreciate today.
- goodcanadian 12y agoLike any other performance art, TV reflects the zeitgeist of the society at large. While it wandered a bit, I think that was the point of the article, or rather Science Fiction reflects the zeitgeist of the society at large.
- leepowers 12y agoNot according to the author: > However, to read Star Trek’s future as a simple reflection of the period in which each show was produced ignores how the franchise evokes longer histories of exploration and imperialism. The author is explicitly taking cultural reflection off the table. For him, it's all colonialism, all the time.
- jewbacca 12y agoIt's not like "Ferengi as Space Jews" is an original point this author has devised: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk%3AFerengi#The_Jews_of_Space.3F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk%3AFerengi#The_Jews_of_Spa... Though he has overlooked / omitted contradictory references in other places. In the grandest traditions of nitpicky Star Trek apologism on the internet: > In the DS9 episode “Trials and Tribble-ations,” Sisko and his crew travel back in time to TOS to prevent a bombing by the Klingons. To blend in, these travelers change their uniforms to match the color codes of TOS. > [...] > When one of his crew calls Sisko “Captain,” Sisko responds, “Lieutenant, actually. I didn’t want to push my luck.” Sisko provides no other explanation for this hierarchy change. Perhaps he strategically diminishes his own authority to prevent infelicitous questions or scrutiny by other Starfleet officers. However, on the heels of Dax’s remark, another possibility comes into view. As a black Starfleet captain—an impossibility in TOS’s “time”—Sisko would trouble the utopian terms of Star Trek’s future past. Commodore Stone, an officer above the rank of Captain, appeared in the Original Series episode 'Court Martial' and was played by an actor identified as being of Afro-Portugese heritage (though I am not certain if that's how he would have identified as himself; there is no ceiling to the level of semantic wrangling necessary to credibly discuss such topics, and even this is cutting short the dissertation that this disclaimer would need to be in other contexts), whom I'm sure the author of this article would agree fit with his usage of the reductive term "black". source: http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Stone_(Commodore) http://en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Stone_(Commodore) There's also several other captain-or-higher officers depicted by "black" actors in the TOS movies, though those were produced, physically and temporally, TNG-adjacent, by Paramount in the mid-80s. Which is still honestly not a great record. But, as much fun as it is to go Derrida on everything, "Kirk would have serious problems with the idea of a Commander-or-higher-level officer serving on his ship that he had never heard of before." is pretty solid canon to me.
- brudgers 12y agoOK, I can't believe I am compelled to "someone is wrong on the internet" over fucking Star Trek...but Anyway, the first Star Trek film [Star Trek: the Motion Picture] predates The Next Generation by a decade. The next three movies [Wrath of Kahn, Search for Spock, and The Voyage Home] also predate the premier of The Next Generation. To put it in perspective, the cultural big deal with Star Trek: The Motion Picture was a woman with a bald head. That is how the world was before MTV.