4 ms·
I completely agree with you, but for the use of the word "dependent". What user is dependent on Twitter? Seriously? Can't one stop tweeting in an instant withou
by bambax 12y ago
I completely agree with you, but for the use of the word "dependent". What user is dependent on Twitter? Seriously? Can't one stop tweeting in an instant without any ill effect on her life?
For developers it's a different story -- but they should know better.
- pchristensen 12y agoAside from people with huge audiences and Twitter-related businesses, anything you choose to use and incorporate into your life is at least somewhat of a dependency, even in the presence of substitutes. For example, I love Chick-fil-A sandwiches. When I moved, the closest Chick-fil-A is now far away. I was dependent on Chick-fil-A, and I'm less happy without it, even though I have missed no meals and probably eaten healthier in its absence. All kinds of things are like this - if emacs went away, I could learn vim. If my apartment building went condo, I could find another place to live. If my favorite TV show got cancelled, I would find something else to watch, read a book, etc. But those are all things I chose to use, and taking any of them away would reduce my welfare by definition, even if only a little bit.
- bambax 12y agoIf words have meaning and if we try to stay away from hyperbole, you are not dependent on Chick-fil-A, never have been, never will be.
- pchristensen 12y agoWhat would you suggest (more for e.g. Twitter users than my example)? Reliant? Used to? The whole concept of dependence is that substitutes aren't perfect. Windows/Mac, Android/iOS, emacs/vim - no one is dependent on those, but a lot of people would be pissed if any one of them went away.
- Double_Cast 12y agoI would say that users have a vested interest Twitter's continued service. Also, I don't think substitution has anything to do with dependence. If "dependence" signified inferior substitutes, I'd expect "independence" to signify fungibility rather than autonomy.
- avalaunch 12y agoThe issue is obviously one of semantics but your concept of dependence is not the widely accepted concept. Dependence means completely reliant on - no substitutions would do. The thing you're dependent on is a requirement, not a preference. For example, you are dependent on food. Remove food from the equation and you will perish. You are not dependent on Chick-fil-A. Twitpic is dependent on twitter. There are no substitutions that they can make and still survive. They can't port to a service comparable to twitter as there are none. EDIT: Whether or not users are dependent on twitter is up for date. I imagine it depends on their use case.
- pimlottc 12y ago> Dependence means completely reliant on - no substitutions would do. I disagree with that. Package managers have concepts like optional dependencies or alternatives (only 1 of multiple options required). Anyway, you seem to be speaking of dependencies in a technical sense - build dependencies, package dependencies, etc. In a more general sense it is quite normal to say something like "I depend on my bike to get to work" even if I could take the subway or use Uber, or "I depend on YouTube for my daily dose of cat videos" even though you wouldn't really die without them.
- jychang 12y agoArguably, Twitpic isn't dependent on Twitter per se, just a large microblogging website. Twitpic can possibly open up a Chinese branch that runs on Weibo instead of Twitter, for example.
- duaneb 12y agoYou just made a great argument for why you aren't dependent on Chick-fil-A.
- frogpelt 12y agoYou could find out how many people were dependent by taking it away. What would happen if tomorrow Twitter was completely gone? I guess society would move on. But probably one way they/we would move on is by building another Twitter.
- rhizome 12y agoI would split a hair here: It's not the users as people who are dependent, necessarily, it's the content they've spent time contributing that is dependent on the existence of the 3rd party service and on Twitter itself.
- count 12y agoI have many, many twitter acquaintances I have literally no other way to contact (many I don't even know their actual names). So yes, dependent in that it's an independent, non-duplicated social graph, completely disjoint from other social graphs. Leaving it would, in fact, cause an ill effect in my life (multiple ill effects, actually), just as withdrawing from any social group.