35 ms·
Uber Is Currently Fighting the Battle That Jitneys Lost 100 Years Ago
- Bsharp 12y agoReally enjoyed this article - seemed to give a pretty objective look at what happened then and parallels to now. What I liked most though was the author's honest assessment of what happens if Uber and others win. Most people seem to imagine this utopia of competition between the ride share companies, but given that Uber is already engaging in immortal practices to eliminate competition and hiring people to schmooze regulators, I doubt that's the direction we're headed. If they get their way, we'll be complaining about them in 20 years when they are established, another company comes along, and Uber tries to regulate them away.
- HeXetic 12y ago> immortal practices Heh.
- jacquesm 12y agoUbers model (and AirBnb) are comparable to the models employed by sites like 'justeat'. First you are a convenience, you move into an empty field and supply a service that the public loves and suppliers become dependant on. Then, once you've achieved market dominance you start the squeeze, slowly capturing more of the revenue stream. Because a huge amount of the customers now comes to the suppliers through you if a supplier balks they get cut off and that bit of the revenue stream gets redistributed over the ones that remain. Those will soon learn 'not to mess with you'. It's very clever and it works over and over again, there are quite a few industries that have suddenly found themselves in this situation. I call them 'the new middlemen', where the www was initially thought to allow us to cut the middlemen out a new generation of middlemen has stepped up and has exploited the opportunity and has in the process gotten rid of the old middlemen.
- xnull 12y agoThese middlemen are a kind of legal pimp that exist all over the United States. Salons are middlemen for hairstylists. Hollywood middlemen for movie directors. Labels are middlemen for musical artists. Google is a middleman for advertizers/people's private information. At a larger scale, credit card processing companies are a middlemen between EVERYTHING. The pimp/middleman taxes what would normally be a direct market transaction between two willing parties. Presumably in a free market (we're getting crazy here and granting classical market analysis some of its claims), two parties will undergo a transaction only if it benefits both parties. This is one of the fundamental justifications for market systems of wealth distribution and social organization. (It ignores whether the transaction hurts third parties to that exchange - externalities - but that's a side discussion). What a pimp does is take some of the value from the transaction for himself in return for organizing the transaction. In cases where the pimp hasn't actually added any value (he wasn't really required for the exchange) he is said to be "rent seeking" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent-seeking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent-seeking). The classical example of this is chaining over a public river system and charging people to run their boat down it. In this case no value has been added to the river by the chaining, in fact value was extracted and concentrated into private hands. The situation is less clear when the pimp does add some value. In the case of prostitution a pimp provides security and a first check that the 'John' isn't law enforcement. In the case of credit card companies, they facilitate the exchange of dollars over wires and track down fraudulent transactions (security). In the case of Uber, they provide checks on customers and checks on renters (security). Security is popular. But it isn't always the case. Some pimps provide an upfront investment in machinery, such as mirrors/air conditioning/shampoos. Other times the pimp takes a financial risk. It isn't always clear when a middleman is a good deal. When is your pimp robbing you as an employee? As a customer? As a service provider? Many small and medium businesses struggle with credit card processing fees as the charges cut into what are usually small profit margins to begin with. Having built the infrastructure once and not having improved on it, do credit card processing companies deserve 3% (I don't know what it is) of every monetary transaction? That's half of most sales taxes, but it goes into private hands. Is the value of providing that infrastructure enough to justify the costs? After how many years does an infrastructure have be in place before it is considered a public good? The internet was supposed to be democratizing in that it would facilitate direct transactions where there weren't any before. People with information could get it to those that needed it without having news organizations filtering it. Musicians could release without labels taking their cut. Coders could sell programs without coordinating with software stores. But today there are appstores and there are wire transfer services and there are online banks and online social filter systems. Google, Paypal, Comcast, smartphone and device manufacturers and carriers, Amazon, Facebook, Twitter, Apple store, etc all take their slice. When is it okay to put a chain across a river? What if the river is first dug deeper, or if someone puts up signs? And how long is it okay to leave the chain up?
- jmckib 12y ago> engaging in immortal practices to eliminate competition Since when is poaching employees considered immoral?
- HeXetic 12y agoHe's referring to the accusation that Uber employees are deliberately ordering and then, shortly afterwards, cancelling rides with competitors' services in order to screw with the dispatch system and waste the drivers' time.
- viscanti 12y agoThis has been throughly debunked. Those cancellations were apparently by Lyft drivers who also drove for Uber, and they were trying to recruit more people to drive for Uber. But the 5k cancellations end up being less than one cancellation for every 5 days per Lyft city (in other words a non-factor). Lyft asked Uber to acquire them (presumably because Lyft is burning cash and is on the way out), Uber balked so Lyft started slinging mud. What's more, Lyft has apparently been engagaged in the exact same tactics. http://www.vox.com/2014/8/27/6074919/the-uber-recruitment-scandal-isnt-scandalous http://www.vox.com/2014/8/27/6074919/the-uber-recruitment-sc...
- bane 12y agoIf you've ever been in a country with a completely unregulated taxi "system", Uber's success should absolutely terrify anybody. Trying to make sure you aren't part of an "express kidnapping" or "millionaire tour" is a real problem in many places.
- natrius 12y agoHa. The problem in such places isn't transportation regulation, it's basic rule of law. Kidnapping is already against the law, as is charging more for a service than you advertise.
- bane 12y agoBut in places with regulated taxi service, you won't generally be getting into the back of a random car claiming it's a taxi either. All the taxi livery, car #, driver info, etc. in a regulated taxi industry is polite-speak for "won't kidnap you can sell your body parts off to the highest bidder" and this is ensured because somebody(s) will get in trouble for doing this. It doesn't appear to be a problem with Uber or Lyft since they have some kind of QC, but what happens when the market is deregulated for anybody to open up whatever kind of taxi service they want? It's the next next guys that worry me. Random cars pulling up to people hailing taxis and offering a ride is basically the kind of stuff we were all taught to avoid as children because you shouldn't talk to strangers.
- Nacraile 12y agoAll of that livery, car #, driver info, etc is security theatre. So are background checks. If you get in a taxi with serious malicious intent, you're in trouble, full stop. Whatever limited protection they do yield is basically redundant with the license plate number. You're confusing correlation with causation in declaring that unregulated taxi service leads to dangerous taxi service.
- vacri 12y agoLaws against murder and rape are security theatre. If you are approached by a murderer or rapist with serious malicious intent, you're in trouble, full stop. This kind of argument is silly, that the mere simple existence of criminality is more important than the frequency of it.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- recalibrator 12y agoI'm convinced Uber is the next Groupon. Full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.
- par 12y agoFrom day one, if you talked to a Groupon merchant, they would mention how Groupon is fleecing them or even bleeding them dry. Hop into an Uber and talk to a driver, many of them having been driving for 6 months or even a year, and they still talk about how they love it and are making good money.
- rgbrgb 12y agoThat's still the saving grace to me. Every Uber driver I've talked to was happy to have the job and felt like they were making good money.
- joshdance 12y agoNope. Groupon wasn't great for it's main customers, small biz owners. Uber is great for it's main customers.
- pessimizer 12y agoAs of 10 years ago, jitneys were extremely common and convenient in Baltimore: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_taxicab_operation#In_working-class_neighborhoods https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegal_taxicab_operation#In_w... "'Hacking' in Baltimore has grown grass-roots style to a region-wide phenomenon, originating from 'Hack Clubs', organizations usually operating in converted rowhouses where 'hacks' made their cars available, distributed business cards with a central number, employed a 'dispatcher', and hung around the rowhouse waiting in line for calls. This practice continues today, but hacking has evolved to the point where people nowadays just wag a finger toward the street, and wait for anyone to stop. This new way of getting around remains popular, despite being incredibly dangerous, due to disillusionment with the city transit service, and the fact that licensed cabs seldom stop for fares in the most dangerous parts of town. There are plenty of willing drivers, and competition can be fierce. The fare is negotiated and paid upfront. Police maintain this is illegal, and sometimes enforce with $500 tickets, and a trip to the courthouse. However, hacking is so prevalent in certain parts of town that cops don't bother making traffic stops."
- marquis 12y agoThis practice is (was?) fairly common in Moscow. It's been a decade since my last visit, perhaps no longer. I knew many single women felt comfortable with these renegade taxis, with a far lower price.
- gph 12y agoYea I've seen people making the hand motion on the side of the road around here quite a few times. It's not so much a wagging of the finger as a constant pointing downwards, like you're tapping on an invisible desk. It makes sense, there isn't very many taxis in the area. They mostly hang around the airport and downtown.
- pessimizer 12y agoThe funniest thing about it is that if you're doing it and notice an actual cab approaching, you quickly put your hand down. People prefer hacks.
- panarky 12y ago"Jitney" is a pretty awesome name for a rideshare service or even a rideshare service aggregator.
- roncito 12y agoThanks! I think so too! http://jitney.co http://jitney.co
- spindritf 12y agoThe key difference is not that Uber is well-financed but that it's one, cohesive organization. The technological difference is also not without importance.
- tim333 12y ago>Los Angeles simply outlawed the jitney due to the amount of revenue it was losing as fewer people were taking the city's railways. They were obviously successful if they had to be stopped for emptying the trains. It's a shame they don't try something similar these days - private minibuses that you can flag down. They'd need to be regulated a bit I think as when Thatcher tried allowing private busses in the UK they all piled into the same central locations and caused jams, but if you could avoid that it could work and be a lot cheaper than an Uber.
- jacquesm 12y agoIt works like that in Latin America and parts of the former Eastbloc. The drivers tend to be totally manic, trips are erratic, cancelled suddenly, accidents are frequent and the equipment totally unsafe. Each trip like that is a mini adventure, and I'm always happy to be back on terra firma afterwards. Even in places like Panama (not exactly known for it's super infrastructure) they are trying to get rid of them ('Diablos Rojos') for these reasons.
- mason55 12y ago> It's a shame they don't try something similar these days - private minibuses that you can flag down. NYC still has dollar vans http://www.newyorker.com/business/currency/interactive-new-yorks-shadow-transit-system http://www.newyorker.com/business/currency/interactive-new-y...
- cratermoon 12y ago"once a given company "wins" it's a pretty safe bet that they're begin to act like any of the legacy transportation companies." That's pretty much all anyone needs to know about this "disruptive" business thing. In fact, Uber has already worked with municipalities to change the regulations to allow their business model, but not others. Once they are in, they will fight just as hard as any other taxi or town car company to keep the competitors out.
- Vik1ng 12y agoYou just have to look at the insurances. Instead of advacating for drivers to get a commercial or semi-commercial insurance it's handled trough Uber locking drivers in.
- exelius 12y agoI wonder how this would have played out differently if cab companies developed decent "hail by mobile" apps. Hell, they still can: mobile app design isn't that hard/expensive, and they can just use mobile phones like Uber. The opportunity still exists for them to do so. Uber is really not all that novel in what it does: at the end of the day, its main use case is to be able to hail a cab with your phone and verify said cab is coming to pick you up. But the author is right; this service is a commodity. Uber has been trying to differentiate through platform lock-in, but cab drivers will do anything to make a buck. Short of anti-competitive practices (which Uber has certainly had no shortage of) there's no good way to ensure your drivers don't leave you at the drop of a hat when something else pops up.
- cwyers 12y agoThis has been around for a while; it was called Taxi Magic, it's now called Curb.
- zevyoura 12y agoFlyWheel is the main "official cab app" player in SF; it's advertised on most cabs.
- pinkyand 12y agoUBER is far from a commodity. The ride sharing business(especially if we talk about 2 or more people sharing a ride with the same driver) has strong network effects - the more passengers you have ,you can offer cheaper prices and share rides optimally. In business that enjoys a network effects we usually see one winner controlling the market, and i suspect that's what we'll see here, and that's why UBER got such a huge valuation.
- exelius 12y agoI think you misunderstand how network effects work. What you're talking about is too localized and transient to really be considered network effects -- I can also share rides in a normal taxi if I hail a cab with 2 friends. A key component of a true network effect is that it enables exponential scalability: Facebook is the textbook example here in that it becomes more useful the more people use it. Another key component of network effects is that they enable platform lock-in by creating enormous barriers to entry for potential competition. Uber enjoys a small amount of the second component through their large driver network; but taxi drivers are more or less a commodity so there aren't really barriers to entry for a competitor to go hire a bunch of drivers. With Facebook, there's more lock-in: even if lots of people are on a competing service, if YOUR friends aren't, it has no increased value. There is no such personal component with Uber. Eventually, what I see happening are a number of competing services popping up that drive down the payments that drivers receive. This will eventually bottom out the market for taxi drivers to a supply/demand equilibrium point, which is exactly what's supposed to happen in a commodity market. My guess is that Uber's long-term plan is a brand play: everyone with even a little bit of future vision knows that self-driving cars are right around the corner, and Uber is trying to establish itself as the premier on-demand transportation service before that happens. Because once self-driving cars ARE available, anyone with deep pockets will just be able to buy a fleet and put them on the road. If Uber can establish itself before that happens, they'll have differentiated themselves with the strength of their brand, which again is the optimal strategy in a commoditized market. But I see Uber being the #1 company in a crowded market with a ~20-30% market share; not 70-90% as is often seen in markets with strong network effects.
- 3JPLW 12y agoWhat a riot. The city of Pittsburgh still has jitneys [1], and still calls them that, too. I always considered it a part of Pittsburghese, but I never knew the word was once used nationwide — I had never heard it before moving here. It's particularly interesting as the Pennsylvania Utility Commision has been giving Uber and Lyft a very difficult time [2] while the jitney has survived all these years. 1. http://www.post-gazette.com/news/transportation/2013/09/07/Pittsburgh-jitney-service-illegal-but-thriving/stories/201309070167 http://www.post-gazette.com/news/transportation/2013/09/07/P... 2. http://www.post-gazette.com/news/transportation/2014/07/23/PUC-bureau-recommends-approval-of-Lyft-Uber-emergency-applications/stories/201407230198 http://www.post-gazette.com/news/transportation/2014/07/23/P...
- mentat 12y agoThis reads like the only reasons why jitneys were regulated was to protect entrenched interests of railways. That seems to not be a particularly good thing then or now.
- bostonvaulter2 12y agoI can't believe no one has mentioned the strong parallels to the vans that operate in New York. There was an excellent article on it in the New Yorker a few months ago: http://projects.newyorker.com/story/nyc-dollar-vans/ http://projects.newyorker.com/story/nyc-dollar-vans/
- danielnaab 12y agoI think these "sharing economy" companies are going to lose out to the software that makes them possible. There's no reason that a local cab company, co-op, or simple non-profit listing service can't offer the same UX as Uber and Lyft if the software were available to them - which leads me to believe that it eventually will. Then the question really becomes one of whether or not we're going to allow a hoard of unregulated, unlicensed, and possibly, uninsured cab drivers on our city streets. In the process of figuring that out, we might decide that existing cabbies are over-regulated, or maybe not. But in any case, the unequal playing field will not last long.
- julienchastang 12y agoJitneys (aka Jeepneys[1]) are alive and well in the Philippines. The Philippines have probably one the best privately owned "public" transportation systems in the world. Jeepneys really vary from nice little minivans to motorcycles with side cars. It was in one of these motorcycles that I saw ~12 children going home from school in clown car style. I still have the picture of this on traditional film somewhere. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeepney http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeepney
- jqm 12y agoI'm reminded of two "unregulated" cab trips I took in Mexico. At the time I was staying in Lukeville, Arizona while working in Organ Pipe Monument and traveling a few miles into town. The first trip my co-workers and I were picked up by an elderly man who was extremely drunk. He even had a beer in the cup holder which he sipped on at regular intervals during the ride. The car was a huge boat... something like a 1980's Chrysler Lebaron. The guy drove about 12 miles an hour and took huge exaggerated turns. Oddly enough, I felt perfectly safe. He seemed to be a well experienced drunk driver, and everyone on the road just kind of stayed out of his way. The next trip down we were picked up by a gang of pre-teens. The driver might have been 11 and had two kids maybe 8 or 9 with him. He had the seat pushed all the way forward and could barely reach the pedals with his toes. He looked through the steering wheel at the road. On the way we came to a 4 way stop with a traffic cop directing traffic. The kid stopped and pulled himself up on the steering wheel in an attempt to make himself look taller. "Here it goes" I thought, "We are going to jail in Mexico for child endangerment or something....". The cop was not fooled by the tall act. But he glanced at the kid, glanced at us, deliberately looked the other way and waved us through. The kids waited for us at a few shops, and then drove us back to the border. We tipped them $5 and some ice creams. I don't know what the point is. But unregulated taxi services can be interesting.
- CurtMonash 12y agoIt amazes me that there was a point in history when Los Angeles regulators aggressively protected mass transit at the expense of automobiles ...