3 ms·
The example phonetic address they use for a bunch of examples is "RERI-NUCA". Not very memorable. And what happens if you misspell it? The example of spelling
by egypturnash 12y ago
The example phonetic address they use for a bunch of examples is "RERI-NUCA". Not very memorable.
And what happens if you misspell it? The example of spelling "Pine Hill" as "Pine Hil" is easy for a human to see and correct; would I be able to realize that "RERY-NOOCA" was a typo?
These are also utterly useless for navigating without GPS. Even if we assume that all maps are replaced with ones that have this letter-based coordinate system as their grid, I still can't see it being easy to give directions, or to navigate without a phone.
How does this work for languages that do not use Roman characters?
There is a scheme for creating "street names" in this (though it doesn't seem to handle streets that turn). However these names are all pretty much gibberish names. And naming all streets this way would remove the local character of place names - a Los Angeles street name has a different character from a New Orleans street name, and a Parisian street name has a stranger one yet.
I dunno. It's moderately clever but it doesn't really feel like it's designed for human-scale interactions.
- Alupis 12y agoThis is yet another attempt[1][2] to turn the already-very-good-and-precise coordinate system into something more overly-complex and unnecessary. If you need to meet at exact locations where both parties don't have a common name for and no commonly-assigned address exists (like someplace in the middle of a large park), just provide a coordinate -- it will be accurate and all GPS/Map systems can take them, including your phone. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8052908 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8052908 [2] http://www.mapcode.com/ http://www.mapcode.com/
- wuliwong 12y ago100% agreed. In Atlanta, we name all our streets some version of "Peachtree". Definitely gives a feel to the place. Doesn't help navigating so much, but whatevs. :) In Philadelphia, we have an area called the "tree streets," for Chestnut St., Walnut St., etc. Just can't see that stuff going away.
- wuliwong 12y agoOh yes, and the Roman characters. I was thinking about that. I'm pretty sure in China, loads of popular websites are just number strings. I can't imagine that this UBI system would be better for them. So knock off 1 billion people right there. hah.