6 ms·
http://matrix.org/blog/2014/09/03/hello-world/ http://matrix.org/blog/2014/09/03/hello-world/ http://matrix.org/docs/spec http://matrix.org/docs/spec http://m
by pessimizer 12y ago
http://matrix.org/blog/2014/09/03/hello-world/ http://matrix.org/blog/2014/09/03/hello-world/
http://matrix.org/docs/spec http://matrix.org/docs/spec
http://matrix.org/docs/howtos http://matrix.org/docs/howtos
http://matrix.org/docs/api http://matrix.org/docs/api
- Sarien 12y agoI intentionally did not try to answer the question myself because I assume there are people who are much more familiar with the details of the XMPP protocol and much more suited to making a comparison. So fuck you and your shitty rtfm answer. I can't just read that and find out myself. Just like a bunch of satellite images would not answer my question what the weather will be like tomorrow.
- dang 12y ago> So fuck you and your shitty rtfm answer Nothing of this on Hacker News, please, regardless of how unhelpful someone else's comment may have been.
- zo1 12y agoIt's better than a downvote, if you ask me. A downvote is an anonymous put-down, and that's why people use it to punish anyone that disagrees with them, or if they don't like someone's opinion. Perhaps if down-votes were displayed, and people could respond. Dunno, perhaps we're over-complicating it.
- dragonwriter 12y agoA downvote is a tool to provide community management of the signal-to-noise ratio on HN. Encouraging noise to trigger more noise would not be an effective means of serving that purpose.
- zo1 12y agoThat's not been my experience with downvotes here so far. I've regularly had meaningful comments, that would have been seen as "conversation" in a normal context, get downvoted here. Now I don't know what "noise" that got rid of, but it sure did serve a pretty powerful way of signaling others to jump on board with the downvotes and/or ignore my comment.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> I've regularly had meaningful comments The fact that you thought they were meaningful does not mean that others found them as meaningful contributions to the discussion. > but it sure did serve a pretty powerful way of signaling others to jump on board with the downvotes Downvotes (because the fact that they have been given is visible and, with a small number, the comment text's visibility is not reduced much) do encourage others to moderate -- either with downvotes or upvotes. If they are piling on with downvotes, that's perhaps a signal that lots of people here think your comment is inappropriate. I've had lots of posts of mine draw both hostile responses and a few downvotes -- but most of those get reverse by upvotes quickly. On the rare occasions where I've gotten more than a few downvotes that haven't been quickly countered by upvotes, I've usually been able to see a plausible explanation other than simple disagreement why people would see the post as not a substantive addition. And that's been true of most of other people's posts I've seen downvoted more than slightly, so I am not inclined to think that there is a broad, general problem with downvoting on HN.
- ThomPete 12y agoI think this is true when discussions tend to be quantifiable areas. But I have seen and experienced downvotes purely based on disagreement about political opinion which is why I wish downvotes mandated a comment as to why the downvote is happening. Other than that I agree with you.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> But I have seen and experienced downvotes purely based on disagreement about political opinion You've seen downvotes and you've assumed were based purely on disagreement about political opinion. > which is why I wish downvotes mandated a comment as to why the downvote is happening. If they mandated a comment, then every downvote would produce discussion of the merits of the downvote, which is exactly the opposite of the purpose of having downvotes. Ironically, this whole subthread has become a demonstration of why comments about downvotes are big distractions from whatever the substantive topic under discussion is.
- pessimizer 12y agoLots of drama here. >I would like to know how this is different from jabber/xmpp and how likely it is that these differences are worthwhile. I thought the question was fairly content free, and something that someone would be able to answer themselves if they had enough knowledge of XMPP to actually care, and 10 minutes to read the announcement blog. >I wonder if improving the way XMPP works wouldn't ultimately create a better result. After all, a lot of thought and experience has by now gone into it. A vague objection and a truism. Sorry if you felt bullied or something.