7 ms·
Calico, Google’s Anti-Aging Company, Announces New Research Facility
- exratione 12y agoThis is another point of reinforcement for my view that this effort is going to look much like a mix of the Ellison Medical Foundation plus Sirtris: vastly expensive and with little other than knowledge to show for it once investors give up, because the researchers are from the outset trying to do something that is very hard, and which even if achieved will produce only small benefits. (Which is to say carry on trying to make drug candidates like Rapamycin do something useful enough to become a clinical treatment, bashing the square pegs at hand into the circular holes of regulation and clinical benefit). "The AbbVie partnership seemingly makes it clear that Calico will be a drug discovery and development company, which is what many observers expected based on Mr. Levinson’s background in drug development." In the best scenario, five years of this will raise the water level enough for more meaningful approaches than calorie restriction mimetics, autophagy inducers, and other attempts at slow-aging drugs that have consumed billions to date with nothing to show for it, to raise significant funds themselves. In the worst scenario, it burns investors for a decade on the whole topic. It is a real time of choice and opportunity at the present. The lumbering monolith of mainstream research can continue to pursue things like Human Longevity Inc and rapamycin derivatives that are probably going to be profitable yet achieve next to no useful gain of human life span (because again they are doing hard things that can only achieve small benefits at best) or, hopefully, some form of disruption for a better path will overtake enough of the community to make a difference. It is clear that far from everyone in the research community thinks that old school drug discovery, farming the natural world to take potshots at restructuring metabolism so as to work slightly better when damaged by age (without in any way fixing the underlying damage!) is the smart way forward. There is SENS, there are the European researchers behind the Hallmarks of Aging manifesto, there are some of the Russian contingent with novel ideas. The near future doesn't have to be an enormous waste of time and money that will go nowhere but to generate voluminous databases, entirely bypassing any realistic opportunity for achieving actual rejuvenation and repair of the causes of aging. But I fear that it will, based on what we're seeing the big money do.
- epicureanideal 12y agoI have very similar concerns. Thanks for taking the time to write this comment. Yes, I really don't understand why the super-wealthy don't allocate some tiny slice of their wealth toward doing science differently. I stumbled across an article recently about the Flexner Report (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flexner_Report http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flexner_Report) which would be a great model for someone to apply to our broken process of scientific research.
- ajcarpy2005 12y agoDon't forget Telomerase-restoration and protection factors. And don't underestimate the reverse-correlation of nutrition and mortality age. It's definitely statistically significant.
- refurb 12y agoCalico has done a good job of keeping out of the press, so I'm happy to see more details. I'm somewhat surprised by the partnership with Abbvie, who is widely known as an "old school pharma company", not exactly a bastion of innovative thinking and risk taking. Also, the focus on age-related diseases is an interesting one. Originally Calico was sold as a "fighting old age" company. That's vastly different than "fighting diseases associated with old age". At the same time, targeting age-related diseases is much easier than fighting aging itself.
- epistasis 12y agoGood job at keeping out of the press? For an age research facility, it's been in the press a prodigious amount! You probably don't even know about other age research!
- refurb 12y agoMeh... when did we first hear of the company? A year ago? How much more do we know now than then? I guess my comment is referring to not staying out of the press, but more keeping the details under wrap.
- evv 12y ago> Originally Calico was sold as a "fighting old age" company. That's vastly different than "fighting diseases associated with old age". The difference isn't really clear to me. Could you elaborate?
- refurb 12y agoI guess I think of it this way: "fighting old age" - attempting to stop the aging process itself (i.e. longevity) "fighting old age diseases" - looking to cure diseases associated with old age (i.e. treating a specific condition) In the second example you could be treating a disease, but not having any impact on the aging process itself.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago
- biomimic 12y agoThe largest impact in the history of humankind will be made by those companies that work to extend human lifespan. Good to see how this whole race to increase lifespan can change Silicon Valley, moving it once again toward true innovation, truly changing the world, while other companies like Craig Ventor's http://humanlongevity.com http://humanlongevity.com http://genopharmix.com http://genopharmix.com http://www.sens.org http://www.sens.org and http://buckinstitute.org http://buckinstitute.org come into to play.
- baddox 12y agoI would say that lifespan lengthening is in the top tier of impactful technologies, but I think there are three equals in the top tier: strong AI, nanotech, and biotech. Of course, all of these four are quite intertwined, with some being enabled or perhaps even prevented by progress in another.
- biomimic 12y agoWe need more time.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoI tend to group biotech and nanotech together. Because essentially, what is life made of if not nanotechnology that is not ours, and we don't yet know how to control? The simplest way to build our own nanomachines is to start with tweaking the ones we already have around us.
- radiorental 12y ago"The largest impact in the history of humankind will be made by those companies that work to extend human lifespan." True but I feel for the wrong reasons. To my mind, the single greatest challenge our species has faced in our brief history on this planet is how we minimize our impact on the finite resources available to us. Researchers recently reexamined the predictions made in the 1970's book http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Limits_to_Growth http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Limits_to_Growth and found the models are holding true. The elephant in the room is how do we curb population growth in a meaningful and humane way. What's the point of extending life if there's a diminishing return experientially?
- sebastianavina 12y agothis is exactly the plot for an action movie. big-rich guy, funds anti aging company in order to be inmortal... anyway. nice work google
- TeMPOraL 12y agoWait for his TED2023 talk ;). ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v2BxH-xwc9M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v2BxH-xwc9M )
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- baconstrp 12y agowhere the first wave of zombies will eventually crawl out. JK :)
- flohofwoe 12y agoThis sounds like emperor Chin's quest for immortality to me, e.g. pure hubris (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qin_Shi_Huang#Elixir_of_Life http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qin_Shi_Huang#Elixir_of_Life). I'm really not looking forward to a world where a few rich and powerful old geezers are cementing their power through being virtually immortal (think of a mix of Kim Jon-un or Fidel Castro, but in a corporate setting like the russian oligarchs). The youth and new ideas will be subtly supressed by the 'better arguments and wisdom' of the elder. It would make a good dystopian science-fiction book though ;)
- irremediable 12y agoI partially share your views, but, if you've not already, I'd highly recommend watching one of Aubrey de Grey's talks on the subject. He offers a very different viewpoint, which made me reconsider my thoughts on radical life extension.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoAs a member of the tl;dr culture, who is too lazy to Google for them himself, I want to ask if you could link the ones you find most interesting/relevant?
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoRight, where can I invest?
- fizixer 12y agoIn case some people are on the fence about the whole idea or have questions: The Anti-Deathist FAQ: http://carcinisation.com/2014/07/13/an-anti-deathist-f-a-q/ http://carcinisation.com/2014/07/13/an-anti-deathist-f-a-q/