3 ms·
That's an unlikely assumption. On what basis do you believe it is unlikely? As an example I submit that test preparation courses like Kaplan do nothing but im
by btilly 12y ago
That's an unlikely assumption.
On what basis do you believe it is unlikely?
As an example I submit that test preparation courses like Kaplan do nothing but improve how well you'll do on a certain type of test without improving your general intelligence.
As another example I am quite aware of how much of an advantage I gain on tests from my ability to relax in a situation where other people tense up. I've described this advantage before with, "Comparing me to a normal person based on the resulting test score is like starting with two runners, taking one out back and beating on him for a while, then expecting them to run a fair race."
- Retric 12y agoIndependence is to strict. Take someone with an IQ of say 50 and there not going to be good at taking tests. Now within a given range IQ rang of say 95 to 105 the correlation between IQ and test taking ability might be tiny. However, that's unlikely to hold up as you keep stretching the IQ range from say 50 to 150. PS: IQ tests where initially more about testing the low end of the scale than the high end and in that context there not that bad. The early assumptions where also looking at the correlation with IQ and things like reflexes when that failed people started looking into mental retardation etc.
- btilly 12y agoIn other words the toy model that I am suggesting is unlikely to be perfectly true. Granted. But I think the point remains that a certain amount of what goes into the IQ score is something we don't think of as intelligence. And this means that IQ doesn't measure intelligence nearly as directly as most of us would naively think.
- Retric 12y agoIQ does a reasonable job of categorizing people. It does a crap job of ranking people. If you compare say: 0-65, 66-85, 86-115, 116-135, 135+ you find plenty of significant differences. Generally 85 vs 86 is meaningless, but 85 vs 116 is not. Which means any hard cutoff is going to exclude people close to the cutoff on a fairly arbitrary basis.
- btilly 12y agoI think we're in agreement here. I don't have any better way to categorize lots of people than an IQ test or equivalent. But people selected by success in life tend to on average have decent but not outstanding IQ scores. And people selected for their outstanding IQ tend to have decent but not outstanding success in life.
- gohrt 12y ago'yummifajitas is on break today, but he'll tell you that test prep courses DO NOT improve test scores.