2 ms·
Implicit population selection biases can lead to all sorts of fun. One that I saw a paper get wrong a while ago was one which claimed to find an inverse correl
by btilly 12y ago
Implicit population selection biases can lead to all sorts of fun.
One that I saw a paper get wrong a while ago was one which claimed to find an inverse correlation between two different traits that individually improved intelligence. The catch? The sample population was chosen from university students at no name school X. But people who did well on both traits would have done well enough to go to a better school and so were underrepresented in the population sample!
(I forget the paper, but pay attention and you'll find lots of other examples...)
- gwern 12y agoSpeaking of intelligence and Berkson's paradox, it looks like Berkson's paradox may be responsible in a very similar way for why the personality trait Conscientiousness seems to correlate negatively in some studies with intelligence - the studies were using selected samples while more representative population samples show the expected independence: "How are conscientiousness and cognitive ability related to one another? A re-examination of the intelligence compensation hypothesis", Murray et al 2014 (https://pdf.yt/d/Dfl1N6pbR-4vYaKk https://pdf.yt/d/Dfl1N6pbR-4vYaKk ; excerpts: https://plus.google.com/103530621949492999968/posts/aQ51UnLCLee https://plus.google.com/103530621949492999968/posts/aQ51UnLC... )