4 ms·
Free as in beer is a reason to be more distrustful of the software. Sure it's more convenient, but this seems to be an area where it's really worth investing mo
by eridius 12y ago
Free as in beer is a reason to be more distrustful of the software. Sure it's more convenient, but this seems to be an area where it's really worth investing money in getting the more reliable solution.
- jimlei 12y agoWhy do you assume paid software is more reliable?
- eridius 12y agoSee this other comment I just posted: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8264450 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8264450
- pyre 12y agoAre you by chance a purchasing manager for a large corporation? Do you feel that signing a $100K-$1M Oracle contract is worth it because "if MySQL or PostgreSQL were worth something, then they would charge you for it?"
- eridius 12y agoThanks for the straw man and entirely manufactured quote. We're talking about paying $50 for software that manages your passwords for everything, not paying hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars.
- pyre 12y ago> Free as in beer is a reason to be more distrustful of the software. > this seems to be an area where it's really worth investing money in getting the more reliable solution. You're stating that "Free as in Beer" == "Less Reliable" and the fact that something costs money implies with 100% accuracy that it is reliable. Neither of these are true. Arguing that I'm bringing up a strawman because I said "Free vs. Millions of Dollars" instead of "Free vs. $50" is beside the point.
- eridius 12y agoI am not saying either. I'm saying "Free as in beer" is not a reason to trust software in this particular field, i.e. the field of security software where one error can undermine the whole point of the software and expose your secret data to the world. And I never even came close to saying that "something costs money implies with 100% accuracy that it is reliable". You are once again making up words to put in my mouth. The fact is, a lot of people still believe the "open source == more eyeballs" myth, even though that is a myth. Open source does not equate to reliability. And when it comes to software that requires this much trust, a company built around a product is more inherently trustworthy than open source, as the entire company is on the line with their product (and the livelihood of all their employees), whereas with the open source product only the reputation of the author(s) is at stake. Please note that, once again, I am not saying this is a "100% accurate" indicator of reliability. There are many factors at play. One important factor would be whether the software in question has ever undergone a security audit. Another would be whether there's proper documentation on the encryption (i.e. 1Password's file format is completely documented, both so third party software can use it if need be, and so the security of the file format can be vetted). A third would be the involvement of anyone who is already previously known to be an expert in the field. Etc. Edit: Come on guys, please stop drive-by downvoting. If you disagree, comment!
- cpach 12y agoIMHO, the license is not really the big question for this type of software. The most important thing is the competence of the team(s) who wrote and audited the software.
- eridius 12y agoExactly. I love open source software and use (and contribute to) it all the time, but the sad fact is that, despite the "many eyeballs" claim, most open source software is very rarely audited. I am willing to believe that KeePass is in fact implemented well and safe to use, but I don't actually know anything about the developer(s) behind it, don't know anything about the future development of the software (will it still be the same developers? Will new unknown people start contributing? etc), and pretty much the only thing that the developer(s) stand to lose by screwing up is reputation. On the other hand, AgileBits (makers of 1Password) is a company, with actual money on the line (in addition to reputation) serving as an assurance that the product will not only continue to be developed, but will remain secure. If KeePass screws up, some reputation is lost, people may switch to another product, and the developer(s) can just move on to working on other software if KeePass can't be salvaged. If AgileBits screws up, not only is reputation lost, but so are paying customers, depending on the severity the entire company might go belly-up (e.g. if 1Password is compromised heavily enough that it can't be trusted anymore), a lot of people are suddenly out of a job, etc. Basically, there's a lot more at stake for AgileBits, which makes it much easier to trust that not only are they going to do their job right, but they're also going to have processes in place to ensure a build never gets released externally that doesn't pass QA, etc. And don't forget that as a paying customer of AgileBits, I can get support from them for any problem I might be having. Open source projects don't typically employ support personnel, and generally rely on the community to try and provide whatever support they can. --- Ultimately, this comes down to the fact that this is a specialized class of software, where one breach can mean irreparable damage as the attacker now has access to your passwords for everything. For that kind of software, I really want the backing of a company, with a significant amount to lose, rather than just some unknown collection of open source developers. Which is to say, for nearly any other class of software, I'm much more inclined to judge it based on its merits, and open source has a lot of advantages. But this isn't any other class of software.
- eridius 12y agoWow, Hacker News really hates the idea of paying a reasonable amount of money for important software? Edit: And hates being told they hate it. How meta. If you disagree, please leave a comment. Drive-by downvoting does not help anyone.